Showing posts with label crisis in Syria. Show all posts
Showing posts with label crisis in Syria. Show all posts

Monday, January 14, 2019

Syria: The underlying reasons for this terrible bloody war

Michael Payne

Journalist Michael Payne says in his article for the “Interpreter”, titled: “Syria: The underlying reasons for this terrible bloody war”: So here’s a message for (US president Donald) Trump: in addition to Syria get out of Iraq, get out of Afghanistan, and get out of the entire Middle East where this current government, with an overly aggressive foreign policy, never did belong and had no right to be.
Trump, the “lame duck” president who is on his way out the door, has just set off a massive firestorm in Washington D.C. with the announcement that he is going to remove all US troops from the bloody war in Syria. Washington D.C., including the Congress, the military establishment, and various foreign affairs experts and observers were shocked and stunned after hearing that news.
In a very short time, Secretary of Defense James Mattis announced that he was resigning and would leave the Trump administration at the end of February. He indicated he is resigning in protest of the move that he has called a monumental mistake. Trump, upon hearing of his resignation and the reasons he stated, immediately fired him.
It’s been widely reported that “Mattis’s resignation letter was the sharpest, and most public, protest from inside the Trump administration over the president’s rejection of the alliances and relationships that have underpinned American security since the end of World War II.”
Washington is in an uproar over this sudden move, one that is not going to die down in the near future.
I have a very different view than Trump relative to the Syrian situation. He wants to pull our troops out of that country because he believes that Daesh has now been defeated and that terrorist group is no longer a threat in that country.
I think that American troops should be removed from that country, but for an entirely different reason; because they should never have been sent to that country in the first place, that their illegal entry into Syria was in no way justifiable.
My position on this issue is not new. In fact, it was clearly stated in an article that I wrote back in September 2015, the purpose of which was to identify and report on the specific root causes of the war in Syria, based on the facts and evidence gathered from some of the best, highly respected Middle East experts.
Many of my conclusions were based on the excellent writings and conclusions made by one of the very best Middle Eastern and Eurasian affairs experts, Pepe Escobar, who for many years was the main writer for the Asian Times website. There are few of his kind who can match his expert views and conclusions in these regions of the world.
Here are some excerpts from the article: “This situation is very complex and there is much confusion over who initiated this war; who is the most responsible and the most guilty, and how and it will ever be resolved. We must not just accept the usual explanations that are offered up by this government or the controlled national media but, instead, think deeper to try to develop the most plausible underlying causes.
With that in mind let’s turn our attention to the vast oil and natural gas reserves in the Middle East and the transit systems that are used to deliver these resources to other countries. When we speak of pipelines it should be understood that a tremendous competition currently exists for delivery of natural gas to many of the European nations.
The tiny country of Qatar has substantial reserves of gas which it badly wants to sell to these European countries, to take the business away from Russia, the current major supplier, and prevent to Iran from doing the same in the future. The favored, most expeditious route for the Qatar gas pipeline is via Saudi Arabia, Jordan, and Syria, to Turkey and then to Europe.
President Assad of Syria refused to endorse Qatar’s plan. And that was what then triggered this massive, bloody conflict that has devastated the country of Syria and its people.
Assad refused because he decided to align himself with the planned development of the competing Iran-Iraq-Syria pipeline – the shortest and surest pipeline to the Mediterranean Sea.
That move on his part is why many geopolitical experts say that this clash between Syria, Iran and Russia on the one side and Qatar, Saudi Arabia and the US on the other, was the main reason why this conflict erupted.
Is it logical to think that competition over a pipeline route could actually cause such a massive war and crisis? Well, many past wars were started over much less important issues; and in this situation, the European gas market represents mega-billions of business for whoever is the major supplier and controls the method of delivery.”
Back to this article: The Washington government at that time, with President Barak Obama in office, was intent on helping Saudi Arabia, its close ally, and Qatar to build that pipeline so that it would compete with and take business away from the existing Russian pipeline going to Europe. Saudi Arabia?
Oh, yes, I remember now; Saudi Arabia was the home country of 15 of the 19 hijacker terrorists that supposedly caused the horrific 911 incidents in New York in 2001.
At that time Assad and Putin were the bad guys in the eyes of the US government. Now it seems that the situation has been reversed since Putin has become a very good friend of Trump and is no longer the bad guy.
Let me correct Mr. Trump on one of his many examples of misinformation. I heard him say more than once that President Obama created Daesh when he initiated the removal of US troops from Iraq in 2007 that was completed in 2011. Hey, Mr. Trump, Obama did not create Daesh during that time because it already was in existence.
The facts of the matter are that G.W. Bush and Dick Cheney were entirely responsible for creating Daesh after they illegally invaded Iraq. Many, many Iraqis were killed and millions were sent into exile in nearby countries. So Mr. Trump, hopefully, this will provide you with the real facts that many others already know so you can stop spreading your misinformation on this issue.
So why is Trump really pulling American troops out of Syria? He says it is because Daesh has been defeated but that seems to be just a diversion from the real truth. Think about this:
It’s no secret to those in the know that Putin feels that Russia and Iran have defeated the combination of the anti-Assad government forces and Daesh and various other terrorist groups and that this war is now winding down. He has stated that he would like to remove most or all of his troops and let that country slowly return to normal. But he’s not going to pull them out as long as American troops are there.
So, all of a sudden we hear that Trump, without any agreement from the US military establishment, will pull out American troops.
Now it becomes more clear about what Trump’s real motive may be. If he follows through with this surprising move, and that then prompts Putin to make his exit, then we will have the answer; we will see the clear connection between Trump and Putin and their mutual strategy.
One way or another, if both Russian and US troops are removed from war-torn Syria then that will be a great thing for Syria and the entire world; no matter what the real reasons behind these decisions may be.
So here’s a message for Trump: in addition to Syria get out of Iraq, get out of Afghanistan, and get out of the entire Middle East where this current government, with an overly aggressive foreign policy, never did belong and had no right to be. Just get out and stay out.

Tuesday, December 25, 2018

US withdrawal would hand northeastern Syria to Turks

Whitney Webb


The Trump administration is set to rapidly withdraw US military forces from northeastern Syria, where it has occupied around 30 percent of Syrian territory since mid-2016.
These were the remarks of Chile-based journalist Whitney Webb in her article for MintPress titled:  US Withdrawal Plan Would Hand Northeastern Syria to Turks.
In what is being characterized by some as a “drastic reversal,” reports in both the Wall Street Journal and the Washington Post have claimed that the Trump administration is set to rapidly withdraw US military forces from northeastern Syria, where it has occupied around 30 percent of Syrian territory. The Pentagon has officially stated that there are 2,000 troops in Syria, though the true figure is believed to be closer to 5,000.
Trump bragged in his tweet – without convincing anyone – “We have defeated Daesh in Syria, my only reason for being there during the Trump Presidency.”
Seeing would be believing. However, there is reason to doubt these new claims that the US could soon withdraw the troops that are currently stationed in the Syrian Arab Republic, in light of the fact that Trump made a similar announcement earlier this year in April. Then, just days after reports that he had instructed military leaders to withdraw from Syria “as soon as possible,” a false-flag chemical weapons attack was promptly blamed on the Syrian government despite a lack of evidence, which ultimately resulted in Trump – and his counterparts in the UK and France – launching 105 missiles into Syrian territory.
As some reports correctly noted at the time, feigning military withdrawal before pushing for greater conflict and military intervention is an established US tactic and was detailed at length in the influential 2009 policy paper, titled: “Which Path to Persia? Options for a New American Strategy Toward Iran.”
That document was published by the influential pro-intervention, neo-conservative Brookings Institution and focused on destabilizing Iran and its regional allies, including Syria.
Another reason to doubt the likelihood of the withdrawal becoming reality is that even Trump’s “confirmation” on Twitter does not amount to a confirmation of a full military withdrawal from Syria.
Indeed, in July, Trump’s National Security Adviser John Bolton stated that US troops would remain in Syria until what he alleged the “Iranian menace” – not Daesh — was removed from the war-torn country, a statement that later became official administration policy in September, when administration officials stated that the US’ presence in Syria would be “indefinite” and aimed at containing Iran’s influence in the country.
This marked a shift in the US “official” reason for occupying Syrian territory from combating Daesh to containing Iran. Iranian military advisors are present in Syria at the behest of the Syrian government, and Iran has stated it will remain in the country until asked to leave by Syria, and no other entity.
Furthermore, given Israel’s influence on Trump’s Middle East policy and Israel’s push towards what it alleges containing “Iranian influence” in Syria, Trump’s plan to withdraw over Washington’s supposed defeat of Daesh could well never materialize if it is opposed by Tel Aviv.
Yet, an NBC report in October claimed that the Trump administration was seeking to combat “Iranian influence” in Syria via a new policy that would “emphasize political and diplomatic efforts to force Iran out of Syria by squeezing it financially.” The report went on to note that this new strategy “would withhold reconstruction aid from areas where Iranian and Russian forces are present” and would also involve the US imposing “sanctions on Russian and Iranian companies working on reconstruction in Syria.”
Thus, the announcement of a US troop withdrawal from Syria may mark the beginning of the implementation of the administration’s new Syria strategy, aimed at economic and diplomatic punishment as opposed to military occupation.
If and when the dust settles, a US pullout from northeastern Syria is unlikely to translate into the return of the territory to the Syrian government, but instead the occupation of the very same territory by the Turkish military.
Late last month, Turkish President Rajab Tayyeb Erdoghan stated that the US must choose between its relationship with Turkey or its Kurdish-dominated military proxy in Syria, the Syrian Democratic Forces (SDF), which Turkey considers to be terrorists owing to their links to the Kurdistan Workers’ Party (PKK).
Erdoghan’s ultimatum came after US Secretary of Defense James Mattis announced on November 22 that the US would be setting up observation posts on the Turkish-Syrian border in order to assuage Turkish concerns about the SDF. However, the move did nothing to alleviate Ankara’s concerns and instead provoked an angry response from Turkish officials, culminating in Erdoghan’s ultimatum.
Then, earlier this month, Erdoghan stated during a televised speech that Turkish troops would launch a military operation east of the Euphrates into the US-occupied portion of Syria in order to target the SDF. Pentagon officials called the Turkish invasion plan “unacceptable” and said that it would put US troops in harm’s way.
If US troops do withdraw from Syria, the move would pave the way for the Turkish military to attack the SDF, which would no longer be militarily protected by the United States. This would allow Turkey to become the new occupying force in northeastern Syria, an area that contains the majority of Syria’s oil and gas potential as well as most of its freshwater and agricultural resources.
Such a pass-off between occupying powers already has a precedent in Syria. In March, the US withdrew support for the SDF in the Syrian city of Afrin, which is currently occupied by the Turkish military and associated proxy forces, including the “Free Syrian Army”. Following the Turkish invasion and occupation of Afrin, Turkish media noted that Turkish operations in Syria would not be confined to Afrin, as talk of a Turkish operation targeting nearby Manbij soon proliferated. The US and Turkey have been conducting joint patrols in the area around Manbij since last month.
Erdoghan has long sought to occupy Syrian territory, though his “official” reason for targeting northeastern Syrian has been the presence of US-backed Kurdish separatists in the region.
However, Erdoghan has also made his ambition to “rebuild” the Ottoman Empire, which once included much of Syria’s current territory, no secret. This suggests that any large-scale Turkish occupation of Syria may instead serve Erdoghan’s expansive ambitions.
Indeed, as Erdoghan stated in a 2016 speech: We [Turkey] cannot be trapped inside 780,000 [square] kilometers [Turkey’s total area]. For our physical borders are different from the borders of our heart. Our brothers in Mosul, Kirkuk [in Iraq], in Al-Hasakah, Aleppo, Homs [in Syria], Misrata [in Libya], Skopje [in the Republic of Macedonia], Crimea [in the Russian Federation] and the Caucasus might be outside our physical borders, but they are all inside the borders of our heart.”
If the recent claims of an imminent US troop withdrawal from Syria do materialize, it will show that the US is more interested in preventing the return of the territory it is currently occupying to the Syrian government than in any commitment to the SDF, as such a move would most likely result in Turkey succeeding the US as the occupying force of the resource-rich territory.

Monday, April 02, 2018

Resisting Imperialism and Zionism


Takfir: a strategic asset for Muslim enemies

Zafar Bangash

Imperialists and Zionists (in recent days joined by Hindu Nazis and Wahhabi obscurantists) have plagued the world for most of the last century. While couching their nefarious designs in beguiling language, their methods are shockingly brutal.
The imperialists use a number of tools to achieve their nefarious agenda in countries where they deem the government troublesome or unyielding. Some of the methods used in the past can be identified:
1. CIA/MI6-engineered military coups including the assassination of leaders refusing to comply with imperialist-Zionist demands;
2. Direct military invasion and occupation of a targeted country (usually one that has little capacity to fight back and win);
3. Use of sanctions to cripple a country’s economy, and more recently;
4. The creation, arming and support of terrorist proxies.
In the past, the imperialists’ preferred mode of operations was to engineer a military coup against a “troublesome” foreign leader resulting invariably in his assassination (Prime Minister Liaquat Ali Khan, Pakistan, 1951; President Jacobo Arbenz, Guatemala, 1954; President Ngo Dinh Diem, South Vietnam, 1963; President Salvadore Allende, Chile, 1973). Even if the leader was not killed (Mohammad Mosaddeq, Iran, 1953; President Sukarno, Indonesia, 1966), the country was taken over and controlled by the military, either directly or indirectly, to serve the political, economic, and strategic interests of imperialism. Given that in most post-colonial independent states, civil institutions, unlike the military, are not stable or strong, the imperialist powers — the US, Britain, France, etc. — have always cultivated and maintained close links with militaries in these states and operate through them.
In some instances, direct military action has also been resorted to. Vietnam in the 1960s and in recent times Afghanistan, Iraq, and Libya are examples of this type of intervention (the imperialists and their allies are still in Afghanistan but have failed to subdue the resistance). After their bitter experiences in Iraq, Libya, and Syria, the imperialists and their allies have changed tactics. They have now resorted to creating local proxies such as takfiri terrorist groups to embroil Muslims in internal problems. The takfiris are the Muslim world’s equivalent of the death squads the US had unleashed in the 1970s in Guatemala, El Salvador, and other Latin America countries, but with a religious twist.
The creation and support of the takfiris has served two purposes. First, it created a pretext for imperialist powers to justify to their gullible publics that there is an “external threat” to their existence and military action is necessary to confront it (fight them there before we have to fight them here!). Second, the creation of such groups divides Muslims along sectarian lines thereby weakening Muslim societies.
In the past, Muslims belonging to different schools of thought did not face any major problems in dealing with their differing interpretations and understanding of Islam. Why these have become such contentious issues today leading to wars and killings can be properly understood only if we consider the forces supporting them.
In 1997, a group of neoconservatives comprising hardcore Zionist Jews and Christian fundamentalists in the US produced a manifesto titled, “Project for the New American Century” (PNAC). It was broad in its sweep and brazen in its declarations. The document set out an agenda for the US, whose principal aim at the time was to “deter rise of new great-power competitors.” It called for establishing “Four Core Missions for US military forces. These were identified as:
1. Defend the American homeland;
2. Fight and decisively win multiple, simultaneous major war engagements;
3. Perform the “constabulary” duties associated with shaping the security environment in critical regions;
4. Transform US forces to exploit the “revolution in military affairs.”
These “core missions” would be achieved by making “sufficient force and budgetary allocations” for the US military. In order not to leave any ambiguity or create misunderstanding, the neocons spelled out the purpose of the mission. It was to “defend key regions of Europe, East Asia, and the Middle East and to preserve American preeminence” (emphasis added).
The regions identified in the PNAC document as far back as 1997 have subsequently experienced major upheavals from Ukraine and Southeast Asia to the Muslim East. For the purposes of this article, we will confine our discussion to the Muslim East.
In order to achieve their nefarious agenda, the neocons had also called for a “Pearl Harbor type” attack on the US mainland to convince war-weary Americans to support endless wars. This came about in what is referred to as the attacks of 9/11. While the official version of 9/11 has been widely discredited, we will not detain ourselves with its minute details, and who knew what and when in the US establishment. What is important for our purpose is that these attacks were used to launch the neocons’ agenda of endless wars.
The neocons had already ensconced themselves in important positions within the George W. Bush regime. Some of these figures can be named: Dick Cheney (Vice President), Donald Rumsfeld (Secretary of Defence), Paul Wolfowitz (Undersecretary of Defence), Richard Perle (Chairman of the Defence Policy Board), William Kristol (editor of the rightwing Zionist magazine, Weekly Standard), and a host of other Zionist neocons.
About a week after the 9/11 attacks, General Wesley Clark, retired four-star US army general and Supreme Allied Commander of NATO forces in 1999, revealed that he had gone to the Pentagon to meet top officials. After meeting Rumsfeld and Wolfowitz, Clark went downstairs “just to say hello to some of the people on the Joint Staff who used to work for me, and one of the generals called me in.”
According to Clark, the general told him, “We’ve made the decision we’re going to war with Iraq.” When he asked whether some information connecting Íaddam Husayn to al-Qaeda had been found, Clark was told, there was nothing new that way. “They just made the decision to go to war with Iraq,” the general told Clark and said, “I guess it’s like we don’t know what to do about terrorists, but we’ve got a good military and we can take down governments.” Then he said, “I guess if the only tool you have is a hammer, every problem has to look like a nail.”
Clark then listed seven countries the US was going to “take down” in five years, according to the general he met in the Pentagon, “Iraq, then Syria, Lebanon, Libya, Somalia, Sudan and, finishing off, Iran.”
What has transpired since 9/11 in the Muslim East shows that the neocon agenda is on track. The Ba‘thist regime of Íaddam Husayn was overthrown in Iraq (2003) and the dictator subsequently hanged (December 2006) — a fate he richly deserved — but Iraqi society has also been fragmented. A country where sectarianism was not an issue suddenly became the most pressing problem resulting in immense sectarian violence. A group calling itself al-Qaeda in Iraq emerged in 2004 ostensibly to fight the American occupation but in reality to advance the US agenda as did the original al-Qaeda that had operated in Afghanistan prior to the October 2001 American invasion. Many Muslims in their innocence believe Osama bin Laden was fighting the Americans. This may have been true after the Soviet forces withdrew from Afghanistan (and even that is doubtful) but prior to that date he was working with the Americans. In December 1989, for instance, Osama was brought in a CIA plane from Afghanistan to Pakistan where the Pakistani politician Imran Khan met him at the US Embassy in Islamabad.
Since the US invasion and occupation of Afghanistan (2001) and Iraq (2003), other countries on the Pentagon’s list have also undergone major upheavals: Somalia, Sudan, Libya, Lebanon (to a limited extent), and Syria. True, the imperialists and Zionists have not succeeded completely in their nefarious agenda but this was not for lack of trying. If Libya has been an unmitigated disaster for them, Syria has also not been a roaring success.
The reason for targeting Syria to overthrow the government of Bashar al-Asad was related to the resistance front against Zionist Israel. It is through Syria that help can be sent to Hizbullah as well as to the Palestinians. If Syria were taken out of the equation, the resistance front would be seriously undermined. It is not surprising why so much effort was invested in overthrowing al-Asad and destroying Syria.
The imperialists, Zionists, and their Arabian allies have partly succeeded in achieving their goal: Syria’s destruction. The ultimate objective of these moves was to weaken and undermine the Islamic Republic of Iran as a major pillar of the resistance front as well as a model for independent existence free from the political architecture imposed by the imperialist powers — the victors of the Second World War. The Islamic Revolution offers an example to all oppressed peoples worldwide to stand on their feet and not surrender to global bullies: the imperialists and Zionists. It is this example of independence and steadfastness based on self-respect and dignity that the imperialists and Zionists want to undermine and ultimately destroy because its continued existence and growing power would end their exploitative policies.
Even while decrying the lies and distortions of the Western corporate media, many Muslims have naively fallen for the West’s propaganda, especially about Syria. Al-Asad need not be one’s favorite ruler but the fact is that the alternative facing the Syrian people is so horrendous that they would rather stick with him for now. Regrettably, some Muslims have also become victims of sectarian propaganda that is churned out by countries like Bedouin-ruled “Saudi” Arabia that has now become an open ally of Zionist Israel.
We must also address the question of why the imperialists chose takfiri groups for this purpose. Having tasted the bitter fruit of nationalism, socialism, ba‘thism, berberism and many other -isms, Muslims realized that the solution to their problems lies not in adopting alien ideologies but in returning to the teachings of Islam. Muslims have witnessed fraudulent independence granted by the departing colonial powers. It has been a cruel hoax. Only the Islamic Revolution offers genuine independence and its example has inspired groups and peoples worldwide especially in Lebanon (Hizbullah), Palestine (Hamas and Islamic Jihad) as well as in South America. In fact, prior to the Islamic Revolution, the Palestinian struggle was stuck in the nationalist mould; it posed no threat to the Zionists but caused immense damage to the Palestinian people and cause. In late-1987, when Islamic Jihad and Hamas emerged on the scene, it led to the first Intifadah in Palestine. The Palestinian struggle was brought over to its natural Islamic mode. Islamic resistance in Palestine has achieved notable successes against the Zionist occupiers since then.
It is the resistance front that the imperialists and Zionists fear and therefore, want to undermine. Developments in the region, however, show that the resistance front is getting stronger while the conspiracies of the enemies of Islam are being exposed and defeated, “The enemies [of Allah] plot and plan, and Allah also plans; and Allah is the best of planners” (3:53).

References

1: Project for the New American Century document.
2: ibid. p.2.
3: General Wesley Clark interview with Ami Goodman on Democracy Now Radio Program, March 2, 2007: A full transcript of the interview is also available on Global Research (July 12, 2014) here.
4: Imran Khan’s speech at the New America Foundation in Washington DC, June 17, 2009.

Tuesday, February 21, 2017

Continuity of Agenda: Destroying Syria Since 1983 By Tony Cartalucci

Syria’s current conflict, beginning in 2011, was the culmination of decades of effort by the United States to subvert and overthrow the government in Damascus. From training leaders of opposition fronts years before “spontaneous” protests erupted across Syria, to covertly building a multinational mercenary force to both trigger and leverage violence thereafter, the United States engineered, executed, and perpetuated virtually every aspect of Syria’s destructive conflict. Enlisting or coercing aid from regional allies, including Saudi Arabia, Qatar, the United Arab Emirates, Turkey, Jordan, and Israel, Syria found itself surrounded at its borders and buried within them by chaos. “Bringing Real Muscle to Bear Against Syria” But recently revealed CIA documents drawn from the US National Archives portrays recent efforts to undermine and overthrow the Syrian government and the Syrian conflict’s relationship with neighboring Lebanon and its ally Iran as merely the most recent leg in a decades-long campaign to destabilize and overturn regional governments obstructing US interests. A 1983 document signed by former CIA officer Graham Fuller titled, “Bringing Real Muscle to Bear Against Syria” (PDF), states (their emphasis): Syria at present has a hammerlock on US interests both in Lebanon and in the Gulf — through closure of Iraq’s pipeline thereby threatening Iraqi internationalization of the [Iran-Iraq] war. The US should consider sharply escalating the pressures against Assad [Sr.] through covertly orchestrating simultaneous military threats against Syria from three border states hostile to Syria: Iraq, Israel and Turkey.
The report also states: If Israel were to increase tensions against Syria simultaneously with an Iraqi initiative, the pressures on Assad would escalate rapidly. A Turkish move would psychologically press him further. The document exposes both then and now, the amount of influence the US exerts across the Middle East and North Africa. It also undermines the perceived agency of states including Israel and NATO-member Turkey, revealing their subordination to US interests and that actions taken by these states are often done on behalf of Wall Street and Washington rather than on behalf of their own national interests. The War in Syria Was a US Intervention Since “Day One″ Also mentioned in the document are a variety of manufactured pretexts listed to justify a unilateral military strike on northern Syria by Turkey. The document explains: Turkey has considered undertaking a unilateral military strike against terrorist camps in northern Syria and would not hesitate from using menacing diplomatic language against Syria on these issues. Comparing this signed and dated 1983 US CIA document to more recent US policy papers reveals a very overt continuity of agenda. Decades-Spanning Continuity of Agenda The corporate-financier funded policy think tank, Brookings Institution, published a 2012 document titled, “Saving Syria: Assessing Options for Regime Change” (PDF), which stated: Some voices in Washington and Jerusalem are exploring whether Israel could contribute to coercing Syrian elites to remove Asad. The report continues by explaining: Israel could posture forces on or near the Golan Heights and, in so doing, might divert regime forces from suppressing the opposition. This posture may conjure fears in the Asad regime of a multi-front war, particularly if Turkey is willing to do the same on its border and if the Syrian opposition is being fed a steady diet of arms and training. Such a mobilization could perhaps persuade Syria’s military leadership to oust Asad in order to preserve itself. Just as the CIA sought to covertly apply pressure on Syria via Iraq, Israel, and Turkey in 1983, it seeks to do so today. Instead of to simply reopen a pipeline perceived as vital to the Iraqi war effort vis-a-vis Iran in the 1980s, the goal now is regime change altogether. It should be noted that, in addition to the 1983 CIA document, US support for violent subversion in Syria during the 1980-1988 Iran-Iraq War also included the 1982 Muslim Brotherhood uprising and its subsequent defeat by Syrian forces within Syria – an almost verbatim analogue to the 2011 unrest that led to the current Syrian conflict – also organized and carried out by US-backed elements of the Muslim Brotherhood. It should also be noted that while the 2011 conflict in Syria began under the administration of US President Barack Obama – according to Pulitzer Prize-winning journalist Seymour Hersh’s article, “The Redirection: Is the Administration’s new policy benefitting our enemies in the war on terrorism?” – planning, training, and staging began at least as early as 2007 under the administration of US President George Bush. A concerted, continuous conspiracy to manipulate events across the Middle East and North Africa and project American hegemony throughout the region spanning now seven US presidencies is perhaps the most telling evidence that deeply rooted special interests – a deep state – not America’s elected representatives, crafts and executes US policy at home and abroad. Power is Held by Unelected Special Interests, Not Elected Representatives The notion that the recently elected US president, Donald Trump, can, is willing to, or is able to suddenly oppose the immense corporate-financier interests driving a concerted conspiracy spanning three decades lacks any basis in fact. In reality, those who President Trump surrounded himself with both during his campaign for the presidency and upon assembling his cabinet, are among the very conspirators behind this decades-long agenda. For those who find themselves targets of US subversion and aggression, both overt and covert, understanding the deep state and the corporate-financier interests that comprise it driving these agendas is essential. Devising a means to expose, isolate, and otherwise disrupt the unwarranted power and influence they wield – rather than dealing with their political proxies in Washington – is the only way to balance the currently lopsided equation of global power. For the American people and citizens of nations beholden to American interests, understanding that change will only come when the corporate-financier interests that constitute the deep state are confronted and decentralized, and not through elections involving proxies wholly beholden to the deep state, will be the first step toward taking back national institutions and resources hijacked by these special interests. Tony Cartalucci, Bangkok-based geopolitical researcher and writer, especially for the online magazine “New Eastern Outlook”.

Friday, March 11, 2016

Desert storm engulfs Bani Saud

By Tahir Mustafa

The desert is harsh and unforgiving. Those caught in it have little chance of survival unless they have proper provisions: water, food and a sense of direction.
The Bani Saud clan that has ruled the Arabian Peninsula since being installed in power by the British in 1925–1926, are beginning to see the desert storm gather around them but they seem to have little clue as to how to escape its devastating consequences. People of the desert, Bani Saud have gone soft spending their lives in air-conditioned palaces consuming large quantities of alcohol together with gorging enormous amounts of food. Not surprisingly, one can hardly find a single member of the clan without a huge protruding belly, the direct result of over-stuffing.
To be fair to them, other Arabian rulers are little better but the problem with Bani Saud is that they display behavioral traits that are hastening the end of their miserable existence. They are extremely arrogant, treacherous, lazy, and completely incompetent. Add to that their barbarism and one can see why their shelf life is coming to an end.
One does not have to dig too deep into history to find evidence for their completely insane policies. Where others would exercise caution, Bani Saud plunge headlong into problems. Take Yemen; for a year now, the Saudis have been bombing the poorest country in the region. Apart from killing thousands of innocent civilians, destroying the country’s infrastructure and causing a humanitarian disaster, they have achieved little in terms of their objectives.
The Saudi army is made up of rank amateurs that cannot even tie their shoelaces properly, much less fire a gun straight. Like the 10 million workforce they have hired from such poor countries as Pakistan, India, Sri Lanka, Bangladesh, and the Philippines, they think they can hire mercenaries to do the fighting for them as well. But Bani Saud are finding it a tough sell. Their traditional sources — Pakistan, Egypt, et al. — have balked at providing troops in what they perceive as the Yemeni quagmire. Bani Saud are now stuck there. They have had to rely on mercenaries from Sudan, Senegal, and even Colombia and Argentina in South America (actually the UAE has hired these mercenaries) to fight for them in Yemen. Blackwater mercenaries fled from West Ta’iz last month after coming under relentless attacks from the lightly armed but highly motivated Ansarallah fighters.
The Ansarallah revolutionary fighters of Yemen have given a good account of their skills and not only killed many Saudi and Emirati troops but also captured or destroyed several Saudi military bases near the border with Yemen. The Ansarallah have also captured military equipment from fleeing Saudi soldiers. If Yemen has been a colossal failure of Saudi policy — actually that of Muhammad bin Salman, the Kingdom’s defence minister and deputy crown prince but in reality the de facto king because his 80-year-old father, Salman is virtually incapacitated suffering from dementia and other ailments — Syria has been an even greater disaster. To be fair, the father and son duo inherited the Syrian mess from previous King Abdullah but there is nothing to prevent Bani Saud from stopping these wars instead of continuing to dig themselves deeper into the hole.
For nearly five years, Bani Saud and their court preachers have indoctrinated, financed and then unleashed takfiri terrorist monsters on Syria. The mercenaries have been recruited from Saudi Arabia, Chechnya, Pakistan, Egypt, Algeria, Morocco, Tunisia, and also many European countries where disgruntled Muslim youth — men and women — have been lured into the takfiri web in Syria from which there is no escape.
The aim was to overthrow the government of Bashar al-Asad and replace it with a takfiri-salafi state aligned with Saudi Arabia. The takfiri project has also had the support of regimes in Washington, Tel Aviv, Ankara, and Doha. This grand conspiracy against al-Asad’s government has been frustrated with help from Hizbullah, Islamic Iran, and Russia. Realizing their failure in overthrowing it militarily, the US has opted for diplomacy and negotiations but the aim of regime change has not been amended. The imperialists and their allies continue to harp on the mantra, “Asad must go.” They are even blaming Russia for backing al-Asad and, therefore, prolonging the conflict in Syria as if al-Asad’s departure would satisfy the head-choppers and organ-eaters, and bring peace to Syria.
At one level, the imperialist-Zionist project has been successful: Syria as a state has been rendered ineffective. This was one of the major aims of the Zionists and their neocon allies in Washington: “to secure the realm” (meaning Zionist Israel) as spelled out in the Project for the New American Century document (1997). In an interview with CNN’s Fareed Zakaria in Davos on January 21, 2016, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu alluded to this when he said the best option for Syria would be “benign Balkanization.”
Bani Isra’il and Bani Saud are on the same page in Syria and their secret alliance has now exploded into the open. They both want to destroy Syria, failing that, to weaken it so much that it would not be able to offer much help to the resistance front comprising Hizbullah, Iran, Iraq, and the Palestinian resistance groups.
The Saudis have always used their checkbook to achieve their nefarious designs. This has been their favorite mode of operation both at home and abroad. Of late, however, this option has been severely constrained. This is again the result of their ill-conceived policies, such as flooding the market with oil to hurt Russia and Iran. While the two countries have been somewhat affected, the impact of falling oil prices has been much more significant on the Saudi economy. It is dependent on oil for 90% of its revenues. With its war on Yemen costing $6 billion/month (Bruce Reidel: Al-Monitor, December 28, 2015), the Saudis have had to dip into their reserves. The 2016 budget has a deficit of $98 billion and the International Monetary Fund (IMF) estimates that Saudi reserves would be wiped out in five years.
Low oil prices have also affected Bani Saud allies such as the United Arab Emirates (UAE), Kuwait, and Qatar. They have complained that their economies are being hurt as a result of policies formulated in Riyadh in which they have little input, much less control.
It is, however, at the domestic front that Bani Saud now face a serious challenge. Their contradictions have caught up with them. The December 28, 2015 decision by the Saudi cabinet chaired by the ailing King Salman (but in reality presided by his upstart son Muhammad) to impose new fees on numerous services and the lifting of subsidies on other goods, notably petroleum derivatives, caused panic among the people. The following day, there were long line-ups at gas stations — something unheard of in the medieval Kingdom — because the price of gasoline was to go up by 40% on January 1.
Saudi Finance Minister Ibrahim al-Assaf caused further grief when he told Al-Hayat newspaper on December 29, “Saudi Arabia will gradually apply a value-added tax of 5% as of the beginning of 2016.” Bin Salman (BS for short) is the one making all the decisions whether related to foreign, military, political, or economic policy. He has already made a mess of things in Yemen and his half-baked proposal for a military alliance of 34 countries to fight terrorism, quickly turned into a joke when a number of countries supposedly in the alliance expressed surprise at being included. Others, notably Algeria, Iraq, Iran, Afghanistan, and Oman were pointedly kept out, the first four most intimately involved in fighting terrorism.
Bin Salman was cagey in his interview with the Economist on January 4 denying that any taxes had been imposed, other than the 5% value-added tax on accessories, soft drinks, and cigarettes. When the Economist persisted, asking whether more taxes can be imposed without increasing the people’s representation in the decision-making process (there is none at present) Bin Salman responded in a manner revealing how detached he is from reality. “Again, one thing is not related to the other. This is not a decision from the government against the people.” The government, he claimed, represents the people and does not make decisions about reforms without conducting “workshops” that include a variety of citizens.
How does the government or the ruling Bani Saud family represent the people? Have the people ever been given an opportunity to express their views on any matter, much less one of choosing the ruler? After ‘Abd al-‘Aziz ibn Saud, power has passed from one of his sons to the next in line. The people have no say in this at all. Further, there is no input from the people on any policy matters. In 2009, when a group of academics requested — yes requested — then Interior Minister Nayef ibn ‘Abd al-‘Aziz to establish a committee to oversee human rights violations, they were all promptly arrested and most of them are still in prison. There are in fact nearly 40,000 political prisoners in the desert Kingdom, most held on such charges as asking for respect for basic human rights and dignity.
But what are these “workshops” that Bin Salman was talking about: are they some kind of teaching sessions in which people are treated as students and told what to think? Who is invited to these “workshops” and who decides whether a person should be invited or barred? His “royal highness” did not provide any answers. Perhaps he has never heard of the expression: no taxation without representation.
Hitherto, this was the case in the desert Kingdom. The regime did not impose any taxes because there was plenty of money earned from oil sales. People’s loyalty could be bought. Saudi citizens went to school and then university, all expenses paid, at the end of which a job waited for them. If and when they went to the office, they would drink endless cups of coffee served to them by foreign expatriates — Indians, Pakistanis, Filipinos, etc. — and the Saudis would simply collect a paycheck at the end of the month.
With this arrangement, Bani Saud felt they could get away with it since people did not pay any taxes. Instead, their financial needs were taken care of. Those in need and able to get through the elaborate ring of security erected around the king’s court, could petition the “merciful and benevolent” king for some bakhsheesh. The ones who made it to the inner sanctum were never turned away empty-handed even if the courtiers demanded sycophantic rants from supplicants before they were thrown some crumbs.
This is no longer the case. The coffers are running dry. Dissatisfaction is rising and people are no longer willing to put up with decisions in whose formulation or implementation they have had no input but whose consequences they must suffer. People are no longer willing to accept that power and wisdom flow from the loins of Bani Saud alone.

Thursday, February 25, 2016

Saudi Arabia: On the Brink of Disintegration




55345345The chaos, which its diabolical authors have brought to a number of Arab countries cynically calling it “the Arab Spring”, demonstrates that the process has not been completed and yet some other Middle East countries will fall under its bloody millstone. Arising quite suddenly in Tunisia (that more or less successfully escaped the spring winds), the chaos, backed up by the Western armed forces, moved to the formerly prospering Libya, which, currently, has ceased to exist as a whole state having fallen apart into three separate regions – Tripoli, Cyrenaica and Fezzan. The latest news reported by the global media evidence that the terrorist organisation, the Islamic State (IS), is planning to turn the Libyan territory in its own “jumping board” for penetrating and attacking European countries. In the north of Africa, only Egypt has held its ground; due to the enormous political experience of the Egyptian people and the determination of its army, it managed to remedy the situation in the very heart of the Arab world.

The situation is even worse in the Persian Gulf region where Bahrain at some point was occupied by Saudi troops, and that alone helped to suppress the violent riots of the Shiah who, according to different estimates, comprise over 70 to 80% of the population. But the fire of the riots is not extinct and from time to time its sparks serve as a reminder by burning Manama suburbs.

The situation is awful in Afghanistan, Iraq and Syria. The first two states fell victim to unprovoked aggression on the part of the USA, resulting in the loss of national identity and destruction of infrastructure. As the proverb goes, one fool makes many, and the leaders of Saudi Arabia, blinded by their incredible wealth and incorrect analysis of the situation in the region, wished to establish a regime in Damascus, which would be obedient to them. Until now, the Syrian people have been in hell fighting with countless mercenaries and defending their right to live and solve their own problems on their own, Syrian soil. The country is divided into parts, many cities and settlements have been demolished, several million Syrian nationals have left their homeland and are seeking asylum in other countries. But the Riyadh Wahhabi leaders are still not satisfied with that, and their task is to establish their own regime in Damascus, which would be obedient only to them, no matter if Syria continues to exist as a single state or is divided into several “subcomponents”.

However the logic of the history of the so-called “Arab Spring” is as follows: the point currently at issue is whether Saudi Arabia itself will exist within its previous borders or there will be several states in the Saudi territory, in compliance with the map of former lieutenant-colonel Ralf Peters. In this regard, it should be recalled that in June 2006 Ralf Peters, retired lieutenant-colonel working in the US National Military Academy, published prospective borders of the national states of the Greater Middle East in his article “Blood Borders” in the Armed Forces Journal. R.Peters’ last assignment was to the Office of the Deputy Chief of Staff for Intelligence in the US Department of Defense. He is one of the most well-known Pentagon authors and has published numerous works on strategy in US military and foreign policy editions. Though the aforementioned map does not reflect the Pentagon’s official point of view, it was used in educational programs for senior military officers of the NATO Defense College and could be quite easily used, alongside other maps, by the National Military Academy and military specialists in the sphere of planning.

At this very complicated period of its existence, possibly the most dangerous one since the moment when Saudi Arabia was created by Abdulaziz ibn Abdul Rahman ibn Faisal Al Saud (Ibn Saud), its current leaders do not display any skills, far-sightedness and political thinking. Moreover, they are doing everything possible in order that the earlier artificially created monarchy could be divided into several parts. Evidently, due to feeble mind and old age, the current Saudi King Salman ibn Abdulaziz Al Saud and his son Mohammad bin Salman Al Saud, the youngest Minister of Defense in the world, have been involved in three wars simultaneously or, as one may say, have begun a three-front war.

It is common knowledge backed by history, for example if we look at the history of Europe, that a state may succeed only if it leads one war and it will lose on two fronts. In 1870-1871, Prussia (Germany) only crushed France and imposed on it heavy war indemnity taking military actions on one front. However, during the World War I and World War II, Germany, which was already united by these times, undertook military actions on two fronts and was heavily defeated in both wars, with the impacts of those losses visible to this today. We might be absolutely astounded by the unreasonable behavior of the present Chancellor of Germany, Angela Merkel – if we were unaware of the fact that the German territory is still occupied by American troops and many American military bases are located there.

But it seems that Europe is too far from Saudi Arabia as the present Saudi leaders do not know the rudiments of history. Not surprisingly, due to this very fact they have got involved simultaneously in three complicated and cruel wars. The first war is, of course, the Syrian conflict, which has occurred and is being continuously fomented by the Saudis, who have spent hundreds millions of dollars on the creation and generous financing of terrorist groups such as the Islamic State, Jabhat al-Nusra, al-Qaeda, etc. At first glance, it may seem strange that these terrorist organisations just occasionally subject the Saudi regime to mild criticism for derogation from the norms of “real Islam”, but they do not go any far than that. For some reason, the terrorists do not take any military actions against the Saudis, though the terrorists, tempered in battle, need no more than three days to quickly cross the desert regions near the Saudi-Iraqi border in their Toyota trucks and occupy the main oil-bearing region of Al Hasa on the Persian Gulf shore. However that does not happen and the terrorists, for no reason whatsoever, do not leave the Syrian and Iraqi territory and prefer to die as a result of effective bombing by the Russian Military and Space Forces. Evidently, the Saudi leaders have generously sponsored not only the terrorists’ military activities but their death as well. But, given the low oil prices, the Saudi treasury will run empty earlier or later, and what will the enraged terrorists do then?

The second Saudi Arabia front comprises the unsuccessful military actions in Yemen where barefoot Houthis rebels are not only putting up adequate resistance to the Saudis and their satellites but also inflicting significant damage on them. This being the case, when the rebels are armed with rifles alone. Since March 26, Saudi Arabia, supported by military air forces of Bahrain, Qatar, Kuwait and the United Arab Emirates, has been carrying out a military air operation against the rebels using the most advanced arms supplied from the United States. The coalition was also joined by Egypt, Jordan, Morocco, and Sudan. According to UN data, 2,795 civilians died and 5,324 were wounded during escalation of the conflict. At that, Riyadh is widely using the USA banned weapons – cluster bombs. This was reported by the American organisation, Human Rights Watch, which insists on conducting a most thorough international investigation of the fact.

Experts are asking quite a reasonable question: what will happen when Iran supplies modern weapons to the rebels (as all the Saudi media are loudly sounding the alarm of these prospects). It will happen, sooner or later. In these circumstances, Yemen will easily regain the disputed territories that now form part of the Saudi provinces Najran, Jizan and Ha’il. Therefore, all the southern part of the modern Saudi Arabia will become the territory of Yemen, as was in the old times, and that might serve as the catalyst for disintegration of the whole kingdom.

The third front, on which the Saudis are fighting without any success, is the ill-thought-of tactics of decreasing oil prices. In this case, the Riyadh leaders blinded by their wealth and seeking to take possession of the whole of the global market, decided to oust the major oil-producing states like the USA, Russia, Iran, Venezuela, Nigeria, Norway from the market. As the time goes on and the competitors do not leave the oil market, the world is gradually becoming accustomed to low prices. But this, firstly, has struck a blow to the finances of Saudi Arabia, originally regarded as “the fat cat”. Now its economy is beginning to experience certain difficulties caused by the low prices, the enormous expenses of making war in Syria and Yemen and expenses of supporting large social payments and subsidies. There is a strain on the balance of payments and spending of state funds. The things have gone so far that there are rumours of privatization of the “sacred cow” – Saudi Aramco, the major donor of the economy.

It would seem that in these conditions, cutting external and non-core expenses (military operations expenses, financing terrorist organisations) and focusing on the economy would be a solution. However, the Saudi leaders, taking the bit between their teeth, are seeking a solution in yet new adventures. Some media reported that Saudi Arabia has taken the decision to start a land operation in Syria in the nearest future without waiting for the support from the other allies, as brigade General Akhmed al Asiri informed. This would be the case while the Saudis haven’t even succeeded in Yemen.

It is possible that Washington is deliberately drawing the Saudis into all kinds of adventures in order that changes in the state structure in the Arab Peninsula will occur sooner. There are up to $ 1 trillion worth of Saudi Arabia state funds stored in American banks, plus about half trillion dollars of private deposits. If Saudi Arabia falls apart it is almost impossible that any Saudi nationals will dare to make financial claims against Washington. The people who will be heads of the new states will be undoubtedly grateful to the United States and will need their assistance and supervision. For example, if the representative of the Hashemite delegation, the now ruling King of Jordan Abdallah II heads Hejaz, as his ancestors did for many centuries, and becomes the Custodian of the Two Holy Mosques, he will evidently retain good feeling towards Washington and its rulers.

Beyond any doubt, the new adventures and ill-conceived external and domestic initiatives, where the authorities resort to repressions and numerous executions in order to calm down the people, only serve to draw the historical outcome and the “Arab Spring” in the Arab Peninsula closer. It is possible that we will be witnesses to the situation where the last son of the great ibn Saud, who in olden days created Saudi Arabia, will become the last king of the desert monarchy in the Arab Peninsula.

Victor Mikhin, corresponding member of the Russian Academy of Natural Sciences, exclusively for the online magazine “New Eastern Outlook.”
https://journal-neo.org/2016/02/24/saudi-arabia-on-the-brink-of-disintegration/

Tuesday, July 02, 2013

The Ummah’s tragedy: court ulama

By Zafar Bangash
The ulama are supposed to be inheritors of the Prophets but only if they adhere to the divine commands. When they fall for worldly temptations, they become a curse. This is what appears to have happened to Shaykh Yusuf al-Qaradawi, a well-known alim, who has now joined the hate-spewing Saudis in spreading sectarianism. ‘Ulama are supposed to be successors to the Prophets (Å). Since no more prophets will come to guide humanity, the role of the ‘ulama has assumed great importance. If they adhere to the Qur’an and the Sunnah, they are a blessing for the Ummah; should they fall for temptations of the dunya, they become a curse. Who is unaware of the Pakistani politician Fazlur Rahman, a Deobandi maulana, whose antics and corruption are legendry? They have caused havoc in Pakistan. But in the hierarchy of ‘ulama, Fazlur Rahman is a minor figure. Much more serious is the role of figures like Yusuf al-Qaradawi, the Egyptian ‘alim who has a television program on the Qatari-owned al-Jazeera with a following of some 60 million people worldwide. At a rally in Doha, Qatar on June 1, Shaykh al-Qaradawi called upon “Sunni” Muslims from around the Muslim East to go to Syria and fight against Hizbullah, which had joined the battle for Qusayr in support of Syrian government forces. Al-Qaradawi alleged that “the Shi‘is [meaning Iran and Hizbullah] wanted to exterminate the Sunnis.” He went on to denounce Hizbullah as the “Party of Shaytan [Satan].” Not surprisingly, the Saudi Grand Mufti, Shaykh ‘Abd al-‘Aziz Aal al-Shaykh welcomed al-Qaradawi’s call since Saudi Arabia is in the forefront of fomenting sectarianism in the Ummah. This is the only game they know and since the Saudi rulers and court ‘ulama cannot justify on the basis of Islamic principles their illegitimate rule over the Arabian Peninsula, they want to entangle Muslims in disputes that dissipate their mental and physical energies. One is constrained to ask, when did the Saudis or Shaykh al-Qaradawi ever call upon Muslims in the Muslim East or anywhere else to go to Occupied Palestine to help liberate their Palestinian brothers and sisters from decades of Zionist oppression and occupation? Iran, Hizbullah and Bashar al-Asad’s government are the only players that have confronted US-Zionist hegemony in the region. While every Muslim, indeed every human being that cares for human rights and dignity must support the legitimate aspirations of the Syrian people, the issue is no longer about their rights. Thousands of mercenaries from neighbouring countries backed and armed by the Saudi, Qatari, Jordanian, Turkish, American and Zionist regimes have flooded into Syria to advance the imperialist-Zionist Anglo-Wahhabi agenda. Their aim is to undermine the resistance front against imperialist-Zionist hegemony. When their direct military assault failed, they unleashed sectarianism to divide Muslims in a conflict that has already claimed thousands of lives in Syria. Shaykh al-Qaradawi has lent his considerable weight to this perfidious campaign. As Dr. Chandra Muzaffar, President of the International Movement for a Just World, Malaysia, wrote, “He was among the earliest public figures to endorse NATO’s airstrikes over Libya. In the middle of last year he even opined that if the Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) came back today, he would support NATO. This earned him the derisive moniker ‘NATO Mufti’ among some Arab commentators.” Imagine a noted Muslim scholar maligning the noble Messenger (pbuh) in this manner! Contrast this with the joint appeal by former Malaysian Prime Minister Dr. Mahathir Mohamed and former Iranian President Mohammad Khatami in May calling for an end to sectarian fighting and killings.
Regrettably, Muslim history is replete with examples of some scholars standing against injustice while others endorse it. Soon after the Khilafah was subverted into monarchy, the Umayyad and ‘Abbasid rulers punished those scholars — Imams Abu Hanifah, al-Shafi‘i and Ahmad ibn Hanbal — who refused to endorse their illegitimate rule, but those who went along with the corruption were richly rewarded with worldly goods and positions (read that: hush money). Shaykh al-Qaradawi and many in the Arabian Peninsula have also succumbed to the lure of political partronage from those who prefer to make tawaf around the White House instead of the Ka‘bah. Living in palatial homes lined with carpets and plush sofas and a bevy of servants at their call, these scholars have forgotten the Islamic duty of al-amr bi-al-ma‘ruf wa-al-nahy ‘an al-munkar. Instead, they are actively promoting munkar. Neither the Saudi nor Qatari rulers are legitimate; they have usurped power and authority in rebellion against Allah’s (swt) commands and are subservient to the power of global kufr. It is their shameless and treacherous behavior, and not the level of Islamic scholarship, that ought to determine how obedient ordinary Muslims should be to the errant recommendations of scholars who have never acquired a level of comfort with cogently analyzing things that matter. Muslims have paid a terrible price for such faulty thinking in the past and cannot afford any more disasters. Instigating hatred among Muslims to advance the illegitimate rulers’ agenda is not only shortsighted, it is also mean spirited and ultimately disastrous for the Ummah. The blood of innocent Muslims will be as much on the hands of these scholars as it is on those who pull the trigger. Zafar Bangash is Director of the Institute of Contemporary Islamic Thought