Showing posts with label Hindutva. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Hindutva. Show all posts

Saturday, September 14, 2019

Hindu Fascism on Steroids

Democracy underwriting fascism all over the world
Zafar Bangash
Fascism has consumed the collective psyche of Hindus in India. One would be hard pressed to find many Hindus who do not subscribe to this demonic ideology. If there are divergences, these are only in approach: those who are determined to fully implement this racist ideology with all the horrifying consequences immediately and those that would adopt a more gradual approach.
Narendra Modi, Amit Shah, (Home Minister in Modi’s regime), and others of their ilk are the torchbearers of this demonic ideology. They are in power and now have the capacity to implement this dangerously racist ideology. Their immediate targets are India’s 175 million Muslims but other minorities — Sikhs, Dalits, and Christians — are also not immune from their genocidal hatred.
Muslims are targeted for two main reasons: they are considered “outsiders” or being originally Hindus before their conversion to Islam during the 1,000-year Muslim rule and that Muslims are beef-eaters. Since Hindus worship the cow considering it as their “mother,” Muslims must, therefore, be slaughtered for eating beef. That such ideas are propounded, much less accepted, in the 21st century speaks volumes for what is wrong with the world today.
Both arguments can be easily refuted. Muslims are not outsiders in India. How many thousands of years must a people live in a land before they are accepted as indigenous? If one were to accept the Hindu fascists’ logic, all Europeans would have to leave North America, Australia, and New Zealand. Such absurd notions must be resisted with the full force of logic. Muslims have given much to India including the Taj Mahal, one of the wonders of the world. Hindu fascists however have had the Taj Mahal removed from the list of tourist attraction places. It does not alter history.
As for the beef-eating charge, yes Muslims eat beef, so do Christians but the $4 billion/year Indian beef export business is controlled by Hindus, not Muslims. If the Hindu fascists really care for the cow, they should go after Hindu businessmen, not lynch poor defenceless Muslims. Some have been set on fire; others have been hacked to death while Muslim women have been raped, at the instigation of BJP leaders.
It is, however, important to reveal the origins of India’s fascist movement and how it poses a threat to the safety and security of people everywhere, not just Muslims. The organization that spearheads the fascist movement in India is called Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS). It was established in 1925 and today has branches in many parts of the world, including Canada. Its core ideology is to declare India a Hindu nation in which there is no room for religious minorities. It goes further; they call themselves the “Aryan race” — a superior breed — that came from the northwest thousands of years ago and pushed the dark-skinned native Dravidian population south.
Skin complexion is a major obsession in India; lighter complexion is considered superior. Not surprisingly, billions of dollars are spent on facial creams that are supposed to turn one’s skin white. On skin color test, Modi, Amit Shah, and other obnoxious creatures in the ruling Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) would not pass muster.
But it is the politico-religious ideology of RSS that is of grave concern. It believes in Hindutva (the Hindu nation) and insists non-Hindus must either convert to Hinduism or leave India. As part of this campaign, four million Muslims in Assam who had lived there for centuries have just been disenfranchised as citizens. This is the tip of the iceberg.
The RSS has six million members throughout India. They receive military training on a daily basis starting early in the morning. Nathuram Godse, the person who shot and killed Karamchand Gandhi (aka Mahatma Gandhi) in 1948 had close links to the RSS. The group has affiliate bodies such as the BJP, labor groups, student bodies, the police and paramilitary forces, Bollywood actors/actresses, etc. that bring its support base to hundreds of millions of people.
Israeli and Indian PMs, Netanyahu (left) and Modi, embrace on the former’s state visit to New Delhi in early-2018. The Zionist war criminal routinely accuses Islamic Iran of inciting another holocaust, yet anxiously runs a bromance with a partner in crime who does little to conceal the fact that he came up through the ranks patterning his rise on Hitler and the Nazis.
The Hindu fascists commonly display Nazi swastikas. They can be seen on shop fronts, pool parlors, markets, homes, temples, vehicles, notebooks, and even property documents. Their obsession and adulation of Nazi insignia has made it even to the internet. It is common to find such slogans as “Hari Om Heil Hitler,” on Facebook next to images of Hitler. Such images are juxtaposed with slogans of “Aum, Hail Aryan, Hail Aryavart,” (“Hail Aryans, Hail Land of the Aryans”). Hitler is openly proclaimed a great leader: “Jai Shree Ram, Heil Hitler” (“Hail Shree Ram, Heil Hitler”), “Nazi the great.” YouTube videos titled “Adolf Hitler, The Greatest Story Never Told,” have garnered over 100,000 hits.
A popular Indian web portal, rediff.com, declares “Hitler was great.” One comment on a YouTube channel run by NewsX, a 24-hour English-language news television channel in India said, “I too love Hitler and am one of his biggest fans! Hail Hitler!” There are also Indian Whatsapp groups discussing Hitler’s “positive contributions.”
Hindu fascists have internalized Hitler’s brand of racism and given it a distinctly Indian flavor, authenticated with a combination of ethnic hatred and Hindu nationalism. The result is the RSS and BJP.
Modi joined the RSS in 1970. Employed by the Gujarat Transport in its teashop, his duties included sweeping the floor (pictures of Modi sweeping the floor are available). His lowly origins — India is a deeply caste-ridden society in which there is rigid hierarchy of castes; Brahmins sit at the top of the caste pyramid while Shudras at the bottom and Dalits even below that — found an outlet in the RSS with its emphasis on Hindu supremacy and hatred of the “other” (in India’s case, Muslims).
Adulation of Hitler has been included even in school textbooks. Hitler’s “achievements” are extolled. In 2004, the Gujarat State Board published school textbooks portraying Hitler as a “hero.” They also glorified fascism. Modi was then the state chief minister. In tenth-grade social studies textbook there are chapters on “Hitler, the Supremo,” and “Internal Achievements of Nazism.”
In order to make absolutely clear where these Hindu fascists draw their inspiration from, in the section on the “Ideology of Nazism” the textbook says, “Hitler lent dignity and prestige to the German government. He adopted the policy of opposition towards the Jewish people and advocated the supremacy of the German race.” Social studies textbooks in the southern state of Tamil Nadu are even more explicit. The 2011 textbooks have chapters glorifying Hitler, praising his “inspiring leadership,” “achievements,” and how the Nazis “glorified the German state” so, “to maintain a German race with Nordic elements, [Hitler] ordered the Jews to be persecuted.”
Hitler’s glorification is not confined to textbooks, disturbing as it is. Bal Thackeray, leader of the Hindu extremist outfit Shiv Sena that is closely linked to the RSS, said in 1967 “It is a Hitler that is needed in India today.” He urged Hindus to form suicide squads to kill Muslims. And he is absolutely explicit about it. “There is nothing wrong if Muslims are treated as Jews were in Nazi Germany,” he said in an interview with Time magazine in 1993. He went on, “If you take Mein Kampf and if you remove the word Jew and put in the word Muslim, that is what I believe in,” he said. Modi is implementing this hate-filled ideology since his election as prime minister.
English translation of Hitler’s Mein Kampf is extremely popular in India. Most mainstream publishers have printed tens of thousands of copies that are readily available even at airport bookshops. This is the template for Hindu fascists’ persecution of Muslims in India today.
The above information is in the public domain. It could not have escaped the hawkish eyes of pro-Israeli Zionists. Yet the Zionists are deafeningly silent about India’s anti-Semitic writings and policies. The Zionist State of Israel considers Modi a close friend and ally. He became the first Indian leader to visit Israel where Benjamin Netanyahu welcomed him warmly and embraced him.

Wednesday, September 04, 2019

Modi’s Dangerous Escalation in Kashmir

India officially and permanently rescinds Kashmir’s special status

Zafar Bangash
Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s illegal and highly provocative move to abrogate articles 370 and 35A of the Indian constitution has brought India and Pakistan to the brink of war. Modi unilaterally abolished Jammu and Kashmir’s autonomous status whose ultimate fate is to be determined through a referendum as called for in a number of Security Council resolutions. When asked by the New York Times (NYT) whether he would hold a dialogue with Modi, Pakistani Prime Minister Imran Khan rejected this saying his repeated peace overtures have been misinterpreted as a sign of weakness. He called Modi a “fascist” and a threat to world peace (August 21).
Aware that the move would evoke strong reaction from the Kashmiris, the Modi regime arrested or put under house arrest all political leaders including those who had for decades collaborated with India. All eight million Kashmiris were also imprisoned in their homes. At the time of compiling this article, the lockdown has continued.
There are wider implications of Modi’s dangerously provocative act but first let us consider what the Kashmiris are going through. The entire state of Kashmir has become a vast concentration camp. Hundreds of thousands of heavily armed Indian occupation troops are enforcing a 24/7 curfew. Barbed wires and metal gates barricade deserted streets manned by heavily armed soldiers. This is the new reality in Kashmir, especially Srinagar, the capital city. Troops have orders to shoot on sight. The trigger-happy Hindu troops filled with anti-Muslim hate, eagerly kill unarmed Kashmiri civilians. There are several laws that provide them legal cover from prosecution.
Internet and other forms of communications with Kashmir have been shut. Newspapers, television and radio channels are all blocked. The Kashmir Valley has been cut off from the rest of the world prompting Genocide Watch to issue on August 22 a “Genocide Alert” for Indian occupied Kashmir.
Stating that “Genocide Watch’s Ten Stages of the genocidal process are also far advanced,” the group called “upon the United Nations and its members to warn India not to commit genocide in Kashmir.”
Genocide Watch’s warning came on the heels of fears expressed by President Sardar Masood Khan of Azad Jammu and Kashmir on August 20 that genocide may be under way in Indian occupied Kashmir. On August 22, nine Indian opposition leaders also expressed similar fears. Further, they criticized the Indian media for parroting Modi regime’s propaganda without accurately reflecting the reality in Kashmir.
President Masood Khan of Azad Kashmir also pointed out that more than 6,000 Kashmiris had been picked up from their homes since August 5. And in clear violation of International Law and the Geneva Conventions most of the kidnapped detainees have been transferred to prisons in India.
Syed Ali Shah Geelani, the 89-year-old veteran Kashmiri leader had sent out an “SoS” message on his twitter account urging people worldwide to prevent the planned genocide of Kashmiris immediately after India imposed a clampdown. He called upon Muslims everywhere to come to the aid of their Kashmiri brethren.
Since 1989, Indian occupation troops have murdered more than 95,000 Kashmiris. Rape of women is also used as an instrument of war. Thousands of Kashmiri youth have simply disappeared. Use of pellet guns has resulted in thousands of children being blinded.
Organizations such as Human Rights Watch, Amnesty International as well as the UN High Commission for Human Rights (UNHCHR) have documented Indian state crimes against innocent Kashmiris. The UNHCHR’s latest report was released on July 8, 2019.
On August 22, five UN rights experts released a joint statement in Geneva. “The shutdown of the internet and telecommunication networks, without justification from the Government, are inconsistent with the fundamental norms of necessity and proportionality,” they said. Describing the blackout as “a form of collective punishment of the people of Jammu and Kashmir, without even a pretext of a precipitating offence” the UN experts said. “We remind the Indian authorities that the restrictions imposed by the Indian Government are intrinsically disproportionate, because they preclude considerations of the specific circumstances of each proposed assembly.”
The UN experts said they were deeply concerned by reports that security forces were conducting night raids on private homes leading to the arrests of young people. “Such detentions could constitute serious human rights violations,” they said. “The allegations must be thoroughly investigated by the authorities, and, if confirmed, those responsible must be held accountable.
“We are gravely concerned about allegations that the whereabouts of some of those detained is not known as well as the general heightened risk of enforced disappearances, which may proliferate against the backdrop of mass arrests and restricted access to the internet and other communications networks,” added the experts.
The fears by UN experts as well as political figures were expressed against the backdrop of the deployment of tens of thousands of additional Indian troops to what was already the most militarized region in the world. Despite such deployment, the people of Kashmir have not been cowed down. They resisted the illegal occupiers at the first opportunity. When the occupation forces relaxed curfew in a few areas to allow people to offer Friday prayers, almost instantaneously, tens of thousands of people poured into the streets denouncing the occupiers. This is not likely to end and may result in a bloodbath of the Kashmiris.
Modi’s colonization of Kashmir has raised tensions with Pakistan that has demanded not only the reversal of the illegal move but that Jammu and Kashmir’s fate must be determined through a referendum. At least 18 Security Council resolutions affirm this. It was India that took the matter to the UN Security Council in 1948 as Indian forces were on the verge of being driven out of the Muslim majority state of Jammu and Kashmir.

Indian shock troops, masquerading as policemen, assault Kashmiri protestors rallying against the serial violation of their human and natural rights just because they happen to be the only Muslim majority region in what is falsely claimed to be an integral part of India. Despite Kashmir’s special status (insofar as India’s constitution is concerned), which was supposed to protect the property rights of the indigenous Muslims of the region, the demographic gerrymandering of the embattled area has now been proceeding apace for the better part of five decades; as with the “only democracy in the Middle East,” a page out of Israel’s playbook, the desire was to create a Hindu majority through terrorism, authoritarian repression, forced expulsion, and ethnic cleansing — and then hold the much called-for referendum when accession into India would be a fait-accompli with mostly Hindus casting ballots.

India’s UN move stalled the Kashmiris’ advances backed by Pashtun tribesmen in aid of their Kashmiri brethren and the Pakistan army. India pledged that a referendum will be held and it would respect the wishes of the people. Initially, Indian rulers publicly made such pledges but as India tightened its grip on Kashmir, it started to backtrack culminating ultimately in Modi’s illegal act of August 5.
Shelling and exchange of gunfire on the Line of Control in Kashmir has intensified resulting in several civilians being killed on the Pakistani side. Pakistan is constrained in its response because people on both sides of the ceasefire line are Kashmiri Muslims. It cannot fire indiscriminately, unlike Indian troops who feel no compunction in killing civilians. India has also used banned cluster bombs.
Both India and Pakistan are nuclear-armed. While the two countries have pledged to not resort to “first-use policy,” the August 8 statement by India’s Defence Minister Rajnath Singh that India may not abide by this policy is a dangerous escalation of an already tense situation. Singh, like his boss Modi, is a Hindu fascist. They have unleashed millions of their fascist followers on innocent Muslims throughout India, killing and torturing men and raping women (see article about Hindu fascism in India in this issue).
Should a war break out between the two countries, it would be catastrophic not only for the region but the entire world. There is serious risk of the use of nuclear weapons, even if tactical, that could quickly escalate into something much bigger. The very thought of using nuclear weapons is horrifying.

Stone throwing Kashmiri women join the struggle to send a clear message to Indian colonial forces that all efforts to subdue the people will be met with stiff resistance.

Despite little concern shown by Western regimes, there has been much media coverage about recent developments in Kashmir. On August 23, the New York Times rubbished Indian claims that there was calm in Kashmir. “Our cameras tell a different story,” wrote the Times. This is quite interesting. Developments adversely affecting Muslims are seldom highlighted in the media unless it serves the West’s political interests (plight of Uighurs in China, for instance) or there is little cost involved (Ro-hingya refugees). This is not to suggest that such media coverage in not welcome. It has helped bring the Kashmir issue back to limelight after remaining dormant for decades. For the first time in 50 years the Security Council also held a session about Kashmir on August 16. While nothing earth shattering emerged from the closed-door meeting, there was at least discussion of Kashmir and reiteration of the fact that the dispute is still alive and has to be resolved through relevant Security Council resolutions.
Unfortunately, much of the Muslim world has also ignored the plight of the Kashmiris with some Arabian rulers — Saudi Arabia and the United Arab Emirates (UAE) — openly siding with India. As India brutalized the Kashmiris, Saudi Arabia announced a $75 billion investment in India. Tiny UAE welcomed Modi to Abu Dhabi on August 23 to confer on him the Emirates’ highest civilian award. One wonders what these Bedouins think: have they no shame? Certainly, they have no self-respect or dignity.
But Kashmir’s future was never dependent on these shameless puppets of imperialism and Zionism. The Arabian despots have abandoned the Palestinians, so it would be unrealistic to expect them to support the Kashmiris. It is the committed Muslims who will support the struggle to liberate Kashmir.
Modi and his fascist henchmen will likely regret usurping Kashmir. Like a fish-bone it will get stuck in his throat that he can neither swallow nor throw out.
 

Zafar Bangash

Tuesday, September 03, 2019

Rise of Fascism

Editor


It was bad enough to have nasty creatures like Benjamin Netanyahu and Donald Trump in power. Add to that such other obnoxious creatures as Narendra Modi, Muhammad bin Salman, and Boris Johnson, and we truly are in the age of vicious monsters.
There are others in Europe, Latin America, Asia, and Africa but our concern is with the evil trio comprising rulers of the US, Zionist Israel, and Hindu India because they affect Muslims directly. We must also add to this list Muhammad bin Salman, appropriately dubbed “Mr. Bone Saw” after he ordered the dismemberment of Jamal Khashoggi’s body in the Saudi consulate in Istanbul last October.
What they all have in common is their extreme hatred of Islam and Muslims. Netanyahu has been murdering Palestinians — Muslims and Christians — for decades. He makes no bones about it. As soon as Trump was elected president in 2016, he banned people from several Muslim countries branding them a threat to the United States. That the US has murdered more than five million Muslims since 2001 is a trifling matter.
And now we have Modi, the Hindu fascist who was first elected prime minister of India in 2014, after presiding over the coldblooded murder of more than 2,000 Muslims in Gujarat in February 2002. He was Gujarat chief minister at the time. This was the right qualification to become India’s prime minister. He has emerged from the ranks of the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS), a Hitlerite organization with a Hindu twist. Its avowed aim is to turn India into a Hindu state where there is no room for any other religious groups, especially Muslims.
And Muhammad bin Salman has made sure that anyone even mildly oriented toward Islam or opposed to his idiotic policies is killed. Scores of religious scholars are languishing in Saudi Arabia’s notorious prisons where they face the death penalty. Why? Because they prayed for reconciliation and unity among Muslims!
These monstrous thugs are also closely aligned with each other. Trump, Modi, Netanyahu and Bin Salman are all bosom pals. Their reasons may be different. For instance, Trump embraces the Zionist thug because he knows the Israeli lobby in the US can help him get re-elected next year. He is the lobby’s slave.
Trump embraces Bin Salman because he wants the Bedouin’s wealth. He has made no secret of this. Netanyahu and Modi embrace each other because of their shared hatred of Muslims. Besides, India is the largest purchaser of weapons from Israel. And now Bin Salman has also embraced the Hindu — yes, imagine the Wahhabi obscurantists that brand other Muslims as kafirs but have no problem embracing idol worshipers like Modi as a friend and ally. What does Bin Salman want from Modi? The medieval kingdom has just announced investment of $75 billion in India, at a time when Modi has launched a genocidal war on Muslims in Kashmir. Bin Salman is not going to lose any sleep over it.
There is a common misconception that India is an emerging power. It is nothing of the sort. Here is why. A number of Indian banks have either gone bankrupt or are on the verge of doing so. Hindustan Aeronautical Limited (HAL), India’s flagship aeronautical company, has a debt of more than $75 billion and is on the verge of bankruptcy.
During Modi’s first run for prime minister in 2014, he had said 550 million people in India do not have toilets. He promised to build 10 million toilets in his first term. He failed to fulfill this pledge as he did providing jobs for tens of millions of unemployed Indians. More than 400 million Indians live in absolute poverty earning less than $1/day. Hundreds of millions have no shelter. Entire families live on sidewalks or in sewers.
Far from addressing these pressing economic problems, Modi has embarked on an anti-Muslim crusade. There is nothing like stoking hatred of “the other” to arouse the jingoistic tendencies of the masses. And with the exception of Saudi Arabia, the other three — the US, Israel, and India — claim to be democracies. This is what democracy delivers. Adolf Hitler had also come to power by winning an election.

Tuesday, August 27, 2019

Why India’s Hindu nationalists worship Israel’s nation-state model

India’s Hindu nationalists and the Israeli right have a remarkable mutual affinity. Binyamin Netanyahu welcomed Narendra Modi to Israel in 2017 with these words: “Prime Minister Modi, we have been waiting for you for a long time, almost 70 years … We view you as a kindred spirit.”
The two premiers, both battling for re-election in spring 2019, share a warm rapport, and regularly refer to each other on Twitter as “my friend Narendra” and “my friend Bibi.”
The Modi-Bibi bonhomie rests on much more than personal chemistry, or even the Israeli military-industrial complex’s significant role in servicing Indian needs. It is rooted in the profound admiration of generations of Hindu nationalists for Zionism and its product, Israel, whose model of nation-state they seek to emulate in India.
Indian secularists often claim that the Hindu nationalists intend to turn India into a Hindu version of Pakistan. This is not wrong. Just as Pakistan founder Muhammad Ali Jinnah’s politics fused religion, nation and state, so does “Hindutva”, the political ideology of Hindu nationalism born in the 1920s.
But the Pakistan analogy is limited. For more than 60 years, Pakistan has been a state dominated by the military. India is a highly evolved democracy. It has always been inconceivable that an equivalent of Zia-ul Haq, the Islamist military dictator who ruled Pakistan from 1977 to 1988, could appear in India and “Hinduise” the state. The intent of Hindu nationalism to remake India therefore needs to be pursued, and accomplished, in a way compatible with a democratic polity.
The prototype exists of a form of state which is simultaneously democratic and supremacist: Israel. Israel was a self-described “Jewish and democratic state” until July 2018, when the right-wing majority in its parliament narrowly won a vote to further tighten Israel’s identity to “the nation-state of the Jewish people, which respects the rights of all its citizens”. The revision reflects the ascendancy of hardliners and extremists in Israeli politics.

Affinity for Zionism and Israel

Successive generations of Hindu nationalists – from Vinayak Damodar Savarkar (1883-1966), who coined and elaborated the Hindutva concept, to Modi today – have professed a deep affinity for Israel. Savarkar wrotein the 1920s: “If the Zionists’ dreams are ever realised – if Palestine becomes a Jewish state – it will gladden us almost as much as our Jewish friends.”
In late 1947, Savarkar was very upset when the Indian delegate in the UN General Assembly argued for a binational Arab-Jewish state in Palestine and voted against the proposal to partition Palestine into a larger Jewish state and a smaller Arab state.
Madhav Sadashiv Golwalkar (1906-73), who steered the Hindu nationalist movement in post-independence India as the chief of the volunteer organisation Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS), wrote in the late 1930s that the Zionist movement exemplified his own “five unities” framing of Indian nationhood: “The Jews had maintained their race, religion, culture and language, and all they wanted was their natural territory to complete their nationality.”
Israel: model for a type of ethnic democracy. Nina Mikryukova/Shutterstock

Ethnic democracy as the shared ideal

It is Jewish Israeli scholars who have explicated the paradigm of “ethnic democracy”, using the case of their own country. One such scholar, Sammy Smooha defined ethnic democracy as “an alternative non-civic form of democratic state that is identified with and subservient to a single ethnic nation.” He said this is “best exemplified by Israel”, which is “based on Jewish and Zionist hegemony and the structural subordination of the Arab minority” – who are currently 20% of the population of the Jewish state. Propelling this is an ideology, Smooha says, that “makes a crucial distinction between members and non-members of the ethnic nation”. Non-members are seen as undesirable and threatening – as agents of biological dilution, demographic swamping, cultural degeneration, security risks, and even as a fifth column for enemy states.
This is the typical Hindu nationalist perspective on India’s Muslims who, at just under 15% of the population, are India’s largest religious minority.
The distinction made between members and non-members of the nation underlies a very controversial amendment to India’s citizenship laws that has been strongly pushed by Modi’s Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) government since 2016. The proposed legislation would confer Indian citizenship on members of designated religious minorities (Hindus, Sikhs, Christians, Buddhists, Jains, Zoroastrians) from three Muslim-majority countries in India’s neighbourhood – Bangladesh, Pakistan and Afghanistan – who have settled in India without legal status.
A protest in Assam against India’s citizenship bill in late January 2019. EPA
So, Hindus and other non-Muslims from these countries would have a fast track to Indian citizenship, the argument being that they are victims of religious persecution. The proposed law is, in a more limited scope, analogous to the Israeli policy of promoting migration of Jews from across the world to Israel. It sends an unmistakable signal of who are preferred as citizens and who are viewed as undesirables.

India as a clone of Israel?

Ethnic democracies do not totally exclude or disenfranchise the citizens viewed as undesirables. Israeli Arabs are entitled to cultural and religious rights. Arabic is officially recognised (though the July 2018 revision asserted the primacy of Hebrew), and usually around 10% of the Knesset’s members are Israeli Arabs. Still, a range of formal and informal policies ensure that the Arab community mostly remains ghettoised in deprived enclaves, relegated to what is in effect second-class citizenship.
Israel is not the only example of an ethnic democracy. There is Sri Lanka, where the post-colonial state was captured by majoritarian Sinhala-Buddhist nationalism from 1956 onward. There is Croatia, since 2013 a member-state of the European Union. It proclaimed independence in 1991 as: “The national state of the Croatian people, and a state of other nations and minorities who are its citizens.”
What ethnic democracies do is to create a de facto but very real hierarchy of citizenship, in which some are full, first-class citizens and others are second class – at best. The current Hindu nationalist movement is remarkably faithful to the ideological creed laid down by its pioneers Savarkar and Golwalkar eight decades ago. In 1938, Savarkar declared that “the Hindus are the Nation in India and the Moslem minority a community” just as “the Turks are the Nation in Turkey and the Arab or the Armenian minority a community.” Golwalkar wrote in 1938: “The non-Hindu people of Hindustan … may stay in the country, wholly subordinated to the Hindu nation.”
The type of “democratic” state exemplified by Israel – and not Pakistan – is the model the Hindu nationalist movement, led by its core RSS organisation, aspires to establish in an Indian variant. But will its vision prevail? It’s far from certain that a 1.3 billion-strong country, defined culturally by multiple identities and politically by cross-cutting cleavages, can be turned into a giant-sized version of Israel, Croatia, or Sri Lanka.

Thursday, December 13, 2018

From Bombay to Bulandshahr

Hindutva has emerged as the clear and present danger to Hinduism and silence is not an option for the sane majority
Aijaz Zaka Syed
So this is how the cookie crumbles. Who would have thought India would find itself at this dangerous crossroads so early in its democratic journey after all those historic sacrifices offered by the founding fathers for freedom! They gave the country a fine Constitution and great institutions that have truly been the envy of the world.
All that is now under assault, with one democratic and constitutional institution after another being systematically assailed or undermined from within.
What happened this week in Bulandshahr, a sleepy district of Uttar Pradesh less than 81 kilometres from Delhi, should come as a wake-up call to all Indians, especially the sane and sensible majority of Hindus of this country in whose name this obscene dance of death and rape of institutions has been going on. What law and what rule of law when the custodians of law themselves can be killed and dragged through the streets like wild animals! We should all be afraid, very afraid, of what the future has in store for us.
And the chief minister of India’s largest state of 205 million people (the combined population of Britain, France and Germany) is happily campaigning for the BJP down South promising the safety and security of the kind that he has been presiding over in UP.
Even when the saffron-robed chief minister returned to Lucknow, his first priority was administering “severest punishment” to the “cow killers”, not justice for the valiant sub-inspector of police Subodh Kumar Singh who was killed in the line of duty! One is not sure whether to laugh or cry over the state of the nation.
So this is how the blessed Hindu Rashtra is ushered in. The idea of a secular and democratic India must be ripped to pieces first.
But this dismantling of the Idea of India hasn’t happened overnight. It has taken the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh, the mothership of Hindutva, nearly a century to capture all levers of power. It rules the roost today and is truly the master of all it surveys. Even the media, the so-called fourth estate, is now firmly in its pocket. The watchdog of democracy has become the lapdog.
This slow implosion of the largest democracy has happened on the watch of secular political parties, including the Congress, the party that led the freedom movement and was once considered the natural party of governance.
However, instead of confronting these forces of darkness, the grand old party thought it best to look the other way or even subsume and ‘integrate’ them. Today, the saffron clan has the temerity to promise a ‘Congress-free India.’ Call it poetic justice or whatever.
When many genuine well-wishers of the nation warned against the spectre of religious fascism and the dangers of wanton, wilful destruction of secular and democratic institutions of the country, their desperate forebodings fell on deaf ears.
The silent majority refused to see Hindutva for what it is – a dangerous supremacist fascist ideology inspired by the European fascists and Nazis. Their view of religious minorities and Dalits, the low-caste Hindus, is little different from what the Nazis thought of the Jews and gypsies. That minorities, especially Muslims, belong in Auschwitz-like gas chambers or Pakistan, its equivalent, in their view.
Yet the RSS and its many avatars and their dangerous antics have at best been viewed as a minor nuisance even after the assassination of Gandhi at their hands.
Using faux religiosity and emotive issues like Ayodhya and presenting themselves as the protectors of Hindu interests, and most importantly, by creating an absurd persecution complex in the Hindu majority, the Parivar has steadily expanded its malevolent presence across the country.
By painting a vulnerable and dispossessed minority as the enemy and blaming it for the Partition and other “historical wrongs”, it has succeeded in poisoning successive generations of Indians.
The shocking scenes of hate and hysteria that we saw this week in Bulandshahr are a result and manifestation of years and decades of hatemongering and brainwashing with the help of imaginary issues and angsts like cow slaughter, love jihad and the multiplying ranks of Muslim. The majority has somehow been persuaded that it is being victimised in its own land despite its overwhelming numbers.
The thing about hate is, it destroys everything in its path. It does not distinguish between friends and foes. Anger is an acid that can do more harm to the vessel in which it is stored than to anything on which it is poured, as Mark Twain would put it.
The forces of chaos that the BJP and RSS have unleashed now threaten to destroy the very country that they claim to champion. And it is not just the Muslims and other minorities who find themselves at the receiving end. Subodh Kumar Singh, the Bulandshahr cop, was a proud Hindu, a Rajput at that. What was his crime other than doing his duty of keeping peace and upholding the rule of law?
By the way, it is the same brave cop who had probed the lynching of Mohammed Akhlaq in Dadri, the first case of cow terror and had earned the wrath of the saffron brigade for his audacity to confront them.
What was the crime of Hemant Karkare, for that matter? The top Mumbai cop and head of Maharashtra anti-terrorism squad, who had been probing the saffron terror plot, was conveniently eliminated during the chaos of 26/11 terror attacks.
But when you normalise hate, routinise violence and instead of holding murderers, rioters and hatemongers to account reward them with the highest offices in the land, this is what happens. The distinction between the right and wrong vanishes in no time. Innocence dies unwept.
When crimes against humanity go unpunished and lofty principles like justice and rule of law — essential for a civilised society — are reduced to meaningless words, you virtually open the gates of hell and invite all that is evil and corrupt.
If anyone thought this hateful ideology only targets minorities and is on the side of the Hindus, they had better think again. When they destroy a society and corrupt its core institutions as has been happening in India – from the judiciary to universities, from security forces and Central Bureau of Investigation to Election Commission and the Reserve Bank of India – it is not just the minorities alone who will suffer. When the Idea of India is destroyed, the silent majority will be the biggest loser.
Ten years ago, in the wake of 2008 terror attacks on Mumbai, I had warned the Muslims that this was no time to hide. I implored the faithful everywhere to speak up forcefully and effectively against extremism and extremists in their ranks.
Just as the extremism of groups like Al Qaeda and ISIS once posed — and still does — a potent threat to Islam and its followers, the Hindutva terror has emerged as the greatest danger to the great religion of Hinduism and its peaceful, magnanimous followers.
This onward march of Hindutva fascism can be stopped in its tracks only when the silent majority of Hindus rise up in revolt against extremists in their ranks and say enough is enough. Just as the Muslims have. Silence is no longer an option for the sane majority.
Aijaz Zaka Syed is an award-winning journalist and editor. 

Sunday, November 04, 2018

The ugliness behind long-standing anti-Muslim bias in India

By SAIF AHMAD KHAN



 As 2017 comes to a close one can’t afford to overlook the unprecedented rise in anti-Muslim sentiment across India. On one hand, Hindutva has become an unstoppable political force with successive electoral victories under the combined leadership of Prime Minister Narendra Modi and Amit Shah, president of the ruling Bharatiya Janata Party. However, on the other hand, the saffron surge has coincided with a spike in cases of cow extremism.
Based on outright lies, Hindutva cow extremists have found excuses to butcher persons belonging to the Muslim community. Apart from that, certain forces have stoked the rumor of “love jihad” to such an extent that sections of the news media are treating it as a gospel truth despite no substantial evidence.
On top of it all, Indian Muslims (much like their counterparts elsewhere) have to bear the tag of potential terrorists because of the horrendous activities of Islamist terror groups like Islamic State and al-Qaeda.
It is a matter of record that some young Muslims are being actively harassed and falsely implicated in terror-related cases. Undoubtedly, the state should have zero tolerance of terrorism, but framing of innocents is an abhorrent activity that government agencies must be ashamed of.
The countrywide bias against Muslims is not a new phenomenon, though. Individuals responsible for shaping and nurturing India in the 19th, 20th and 21st centuries have shared such anti-Islam views.

Islam and tolerance

The Koran contains several passages exhorting Muslims to respect religious freedom and uphold religious pluralism. “You have your religion and I have mine” is a famous verse (Koran 109:6) that recognizes the need for co-existence.
While Islam is a proselytizing faith, it doesn’t believe in forced conversions, as reflected in Surah Qaf. “You are not there to force them: So remind, with this Koran, those who fear my warning” (Koran 50:45). Nevertheless, it must be clarified here that individuals belonging to the Islamic faith have indulged in the crime of compelling people to embrace Islam by negating the belief in the commandment of “there is no compulsion in religion” as enshrined in the scripture (Koran 2:256).
One must point out that verses promoting religious harmony and toleration are not restricted to the chapters revealed in the Meccan period when the Muslims were a persecuted minority. In Medina, the Muslims developed into a powerful force to reckon with as Prophet Muhammad presided as the head of state. But the essence of religion pluralism furthered by Islam did not change.
Premised on the reprehensible atrocities of temple destruction committed by select Muslim emperors, some like to paint Muslims as a temple-ransacking race, contrary to Islam’s eternal teaching of safeguarding places of worship. “If God did not repel the aggression of some people by means of others, cloisters and churches and synagogues and mosques, wherein the name of God is much invoked would surely be destroyed” (Koran 22:40).
It is inappropriate to hold the current generation of Muslims responsible for the intolerant actions of certain Muslim kings that took place centuries ago. By this logic, should the entire Hindu community be considered guilty for the 500 Muslim religious monuments destroyed during the 2002 Gujarat riots? It should certainly not be so, because a proposition of this kind is an insult to the word “logic.”
We must realize that forced conversions and temple desecration under the reign of Muslim emperors are not the only things that history consists of when there is evidence that Muslim kings also extended grants to Hindu temples. Therefore, truth lies somewhere in between and it is needless to add that whosoever destroyed temples and forced people to give up on their faith was acting contrary to Koranic commandments.
In Surah Al-Hajj, a great amount of importance is attached to respecting the different modes of worship. “We have appointed for every community ways of worship to observe. Let them not dispute with you on this matter. Call them to the path of your Lord – for surely, you are rightly guided” (Koran 22:67).
An identical set of messages transmitted in Surah Al-Baqarah and Surah Al-Maidah are also worth recalling. The former proclaims, “The believers, the Jews, the Christians and the Sabaeans – all those who believe in God and the Last Day and do good deeds – will be rewarded by their Lord; they shall have no fear, nor shall they grieve” (Koran 2:62). The other Surah echoes more or less the same doctrine: “Believers, Jews, Sabaeans and Christians – whoever believes in God and the Last Day and does what is right – shall have nothing to fear nor shall they grieve” (Koran 5:69).

Charge of intolerance

Although religious pluralism is an important theme in the Koran, a few Indian icons who have enjoyed the status of demigods for decades have found nothing except violence and hatred in Islam. The example of Swami Vivekananda, who represented India at the World Parliament of Religions (1893) and whose birthday is celebrated as National Youth Day, is a case in point.
As per Vivekananda, it was the Muslims who “brought murder and slaughter” to India as “the Hindu religion never persecutes.” Given the blatant anti-Muslim messaging underlying the statement, one can’t stop wondering why Vivekananda made such a factually inaccurate statement when caste atrocities have been around for centuries andtemple desecration was in fact carried out by Indian Hindu emperors as well who were not merely content with military victories over rival Hindu kings.
Not just that, the large-scale persecution of Buddhists at the hands of Hindu extremists during the days of Pushyamitra Shunga (who wrested power from the Maurya Dynasty) is also an undeniable reality.
But Vivekananda decided to overlook all of that and conveniently pin the entire blame of fanning violence in India on the Muslims.
“That race which is bound down to itself has been the most cruel and the most wicked in the world. There has not been a religion which has clung to this dualism more than that founded by the Prophet of Arabia, and there has not been a religion, which has shed so much of blood and been so cruel to other men. In the Koran, there is the doctrine that a man who does not believe such teachings should be killed; it is a mercy to kill him,” said Vivekananda, equating Muhammad’s teachings with “fanaticism” and “great evil.”
Vivekananda was not alone in stressing that Islam stood for putting non-Muslims to fire and sword. The Bengali polymath Rabindranath Tagore was not far behind in harboring anti-Islam (and anti-Christianity) views. “There are two religions in Earth which have distinct enmity against all other religions. These two are Christianity and Islam. They are not just satisfied with observing their own religions, but are determined to destroy all other religions. That’s why the only way to make peace with them is to embrace their religions,”claimed Tagore.

Questioning the patriotism of Muslims

In the contemporary age, well-intentioned intellectuals are battling for Dalit-Muslim unity to combat the rise of militant Hindutva politics. Interestingly, the foundation of such an alliance cannot be derived from the philosophy of B R Ambedkar, the father of the Indian constitution, because his views concerning Muslims were not very different from those of the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS).
According to Ambedkar, the brotherhood of Islam was limited to Muslims. He expounded that “there is nothing but contempt and enmity” for those outside of this corporation (read non-Muslims).
Though Ambedkar played a key role in ensuring equality for all Indian citizens, his mind did suspect the patriotism of Muslims. “The allegiance of a Muslim does not rest on his domicile in the country which is his but on the faith to which he belongs. To the Muslim, ibi bene ibi patria [where it is well with me, there is my country] is unthinkable.
“Wherever there is the rule of Islam, there is his own country. In other words, Islam can never allow a true Muslim to adopt India as his motherland and regard a Hindu as his kith and kin,” Ambedkar said.
Now look at the striking resemblance between Ambedkar’s and Atal Bihari Vajpayee’s words when it came to questioning the patriotism of Indian Muslims in his famous article “The Sangh is in my soul”:
Islam has yet to learn the art of existing and flourishing in a country where Muslims are in a minority. They cannot convert the whole of India to Islam. After all, they have to live here. So they have to recognize this fact. And today it has become a matter of grave concern and deep thinking in the Muslim countries.
Because [the Koran] offers no guidance in this regard. It only talks of killing kafirs or converting them to Islam. But they cannot do it always and everywhere. How can they do it where they are in a minority? If they try to do it, a major clash will take place and only the members of the minority will be killed.
Vivekananda, Tagore, Ambedkar and Vajpayee were all united in linking Islam with violence, as if the religion were alien to tolerance, which is not the case.
The existence of ultra-conservative and anti-pluralistic interpretations of certain controversial Koranic verses cannot be denied. However, the stalwarts quoted above erred heavily in presenting these beliefs as mainstream Islam that was subscribed to by Muslims around the world by means of a consensus.
In reality, their interpretation of Islam was similar to and would be agreed by terror groups like ISIS and al-Qaeda, who are responsible for shedding Muslim blood more than that of non-Muslims.
The perennial obsession with questioning the patriotism of Indian Muslims is strange given the contribution lent by Muslims to numerous fields including bureaucracy, business, cinema, diplomacy, education, politics, security and sports in post-independence India. On the contrary, the state has wronged them by doing nothing concrete about their under-representation in the public sector and socio-economic backwardness.
To recall the Sachar Committee Report of the government of India (page 11), “the alleged appeasement” of the Muslims (favorite accusation of the Sangh Parivar) has not led to the “desired level of socio-economic development of the community.”

Attitudes of three major leaders

The illustrious list of individuals who made unbelievably anti-Muslim comments does not end here.
Sardar Patel, India’s first deputy prime minister, who was responsible for spearheading the political integration of the country, once expressed astonishing satisfaction at the loss of Muslim lives. In the aftermath of the Calcutta riots in August 1946, Patel wrote a letter to C Rajagopalachari, last governor general of India, which said, “There is a complete breakdown of safety and order but there is nobody responsible to check the thing. However, this will be a good lesson for the League, because I hear that the proportion of Muslims who have suffered death is much larger.”
Is that how a responsible political leader reacts to riots, by expressing relief at the fact that Muslims comprised a large part of the death toll? We can also not forget the massacre of Muslims in Hyderabad under the watch of Patel and Jawaharlal Nehru, with the latter responsible for burying the Sunderlal Report on the police action in Hyderabad, which is said to have claimed 50,000-200,000 lives.
Let’s face the facts. India has had a long history of distrusting Muslims. Mohandas Gandhi exhibited it when he accused the Muslims of having “as a class developed into a bully” in an article titled “What may Hindus do?”
“Though in my opinion, non-violence has a predominant place in the Koran, the thirteen hundred years of imperialistic expansion has made the Mussulmans fighters as a body. They are therefore aggressive. Bullying is the natural excrescence of an aggressive spirit,” said the article, reproduced in the book What Is Hinduism? (page 21).
Being the most prominent leader of the Indian Independence Movement, it wasn’t expected of Gandhi to write articles based on stereotypes and sweeping generalizations.
Although the Muslims have played a significant part in India’s history, with the Mughal period boasting a nearly 25% share in global gross domestic product and industrial output besides the construction of monuments signifying the excellence of Islamic architecture (Taj Mahal and Red Fort, among others) the likes of Nehru found no merit in them.
“The Moslems who came to India from outside brought no new technique or political and economic structure. In spite of a religious belief in the brotherhood of Islam, they were class-bound and feudal in outlook. In technique and in the methods of production and industrial organization, they were inferior to what prevailed then in India,” Nehru wrote in The Discovery of India (page 267).
In the same book (page 234), he also opined that the passage of the mantle of Islam from Arabs to the Turks and Mongols developed it into a “rigid faith” suited more for “military conquests rather than the conquests of the mind”. Nehru probably forgot that Islam’s real representative is the Prophet Muhammad, who taught that an Arab is to have no superiority over a non-Arab, and managed to conquer Mecca bloodlessly thanks to the might of his spiritual message, which transcended geographical boundaries during his lifetime.
The whole point of citing these statements made by distinguished Indians is to make people realize that the prejudices we face are not anything new. For long, Muslims have been seen as outsiders, and their religion as a violent doctrine that stands for intolerance, murder and killing. Until and unless the Indian society purges itself of such anti-Muslim myths, there is little reason to believe that the bias against Muslims will cease to exist.
Today, it is manifesting itself through the false notion of love jihad, cow extremism and antagonization of Muslim emperors. Tomorrow, the issues may have changed, but the target will remain the Muslim, because he or she is “the other.”