Showing posts with label Iran nuclear deal (JCPOA). Show all posts
Showing posts with label Iran nuclear deal (JCPOA). Show all posts

Wednesday, September 18, 2019

When Will the US and Iranian Leaders Meet?

3222
The key element of the current system of international political, economic and military relations is the ability of the US and Iran to keep the conflict between the two countries from degenerating into direct military confrontation.
Until recently, the Donald Trump Administration had strongly opposed easing sanctions against Iran, instead imposing, somewhat furiously, even more sanctions on that country. In early September alone the US Government introduced economic measures against the country’s space program. The US State Department Special Representative for Iran Brian Hook announced that the US would deal with the so-called Oil for Terror Network, a group of individuals and organizations through which the Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps (IRGC) is engaged in the illegal, from the American point of view, sale of hydrocarbons.
Iran has recently taken additional steps to cancel the nuclear deal concluded by Tehran with a number of world powers in 2015 by pumping gaseous uranium into more advanced uranium enrichment centrifuges. At the same time, Tehran pointed out that in a situation where both the US and the European participants in the nuclear deal cannot guarantee lifting sanctions against the Islamic Republic of Iran as per the agreed plan, Iran would be no longer bound by this international agreement on the nuclear energy research restrictions. Moreover Iran emphasized its technical capabilities for enriching uranium to 20% and above. A number of analysts are even confident that Iran will be able to achieve a level of enrichment close to 90% for weapon-grade uranium.
It should be noted that these measures on the part of Iran had been expected for several days. Tehran promised earlier that it would give up parts of its nuclear deal obligations every 60 days until the European powers found a way to compensate Iran for the economic damage from the US sanctions imposed by the US President Donald Trump’s Administration as part of its policy of exerting maximum pressure on Tehran. In July, Iran already exceeded the limits on the uranium reserves envisaged by the deal, and it unilaterally raised the limit on fuel enrichment from 3.67 to 4.5%. Nonetheless, the country has not yet officially withdrawn from the nuclear deal, unlike the United States.
However, President Trump’s decision to dismiss his National Security Advisor, John Bolton, because of strong disagreements with him on many issues, undoubtedly gives hope that the US-Iranian conflict can be mitigated in the near future.
The New York Times alleges Bolton believed his primary goal was to prevent the conclusion of agreements with America’s enemies. And, against this backdrop, the conflict with Iran, according to the former national security advisor’s entourage, was largely related to the position of John Bolton, for whom Trump’s withdrawal from the nuclear deal with, and the restoration of the US sanctions against, Tehran were the main achievements of his 18-month-long activity in the White House.
Trump himself once said, half in jest, that “if it was up to John, we’d be in four wars now.” And in this regard, the US President clearly meant the possibility of developments unfavorable for the world not only on the Iranian issue, but also on the possible reconciliation with North Korea due to Bolton’s strong condemnation of North Korean missile tests as a violation of the UN Resolutions and his refusal to join Trump when the US President met with the North Korean leader Kim Jong-Un in the demilitarized zone separating the two Koreas. It was Bolton’s policy as a Washington hawk to influence the US President regarding the White House action against the regime of Nicolas Maduro, providing the US support for the Venezuelan opposition leader Juan Guaidó in every way. Bolton’s negative stance on negotiations with the Taliban and his call on President Trump not to make an agreement with the radical Islamic movement, combating which thousands of US soldiers died in Afghanistan, proved important as well: it resulted in Trump’s refusal to try and reach a peace agreement with them.
The 70-year-old John Bolton is considered one of the heavy-weights of the American conservative foreign policy establishment, adhering to a deep skepticism about international treaties, disbelieving in the effectiveness of international organizations and being confident that military power is an essential component of the US foreign policy. However, these principles of John Bolton often not only contradicted President Trump’s position, but also undermined several of his initiatives to find a peaceful solution to certain conflicts.
It is not surprising therefore that a significant number of the US media responded positively to the removal of the irreconcilable hawk from a key position in the White House, since, as many are emphasizing, he was pushing Trump away from peace and diplomacy.
Amidst these developments, the possibility of personal negotiations between the leaders of the United States and Iran to resolve the conflict and ease the anti-Iranian sanctions regime has become increasingly encouraging over the recent days. The most suitable option is to meet face-to-face on the sidelines of the UN General Assembly at the end of September. Still, Washington is emphasizing that whether negotiations will take place or not will largely depends on the Supreme Leader of the Islamic Republic of Iran.
Anyway, what can be discussed and what mutual agreement may be reached in the event of a personal meeting between the two leaders remains questionable.
We must keep in mind that Iran’s position reads as follows: when will the US return to the Joint Comprehensive Action Plan, or simply put, to the nuclear deal? Only then, according to Tehran, can we talk about something else. It is one thing to agree to limit a nuclear program that has never actually pursued the goal of obtaining nuclear weapons. It is a completely different thing though when it comes to surrendering one’s influence and missile power. Iran will hardly go for it.

Valery Kulikov, expert politologist, exclusively for the online magazine ‘New Eastern Outlook’.

Thursday, August 29, 2019

Iran Nuclear Accord: The Third Act is Now Starting

            The first act of the Iran Nuclear Accord took eight years. The backdrop kept changing from Geneva to Vienna but the actors were nearly all the same.  Except for the representative of the European Union it was an all male, middle-age cast with little comic relief, at least on stage.  The Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action, to give the play its formal name was signed in 2015 with polite applause and some anticipation of what the next acts might hold.
The second act started with the election of Donald Trump as the US President. He  was used to faster-paced TV shows and so left  the theater, saying that there were no lines concerning Iranian missiles.  The development of Iranian missiles is not a subject directly covered by the Iranian nuclear accord.  However, there is the Hague Code of Conduct aganst Ballistic Missile Production (HCOC) which came into force on 25 November 2002 which calls for restraint in their production, testing, and export.  The Hague Code could be strengthened although we have seen little leadership on the part of those States which have extensive missile programs.
One can understand the boredom of some.  The action was very slow.  The Iranians kept to the script, and IAEA atomic inspectors came periodically from Vienna but were largely nameless.  The Iranian economy did not improve dramatically and so some Iranian “hardliners” started wondering  who had written the play.  But as the Second Act continued, the drama started heating up. Off stage, one could hear war drums starting to beat. Armed conflicts continued in Syria and Yemen. One could hear the sounds of weapons off stage but rather close. Tankers with oil were menaced. Regional States not part of the Nuclear Accord such as Saudia Arabia and Israel were watching closely and even throwing some oil on the fire. As the Second Act ended, there was serious discussion of the possibility of a regional war.
Now the Third Act has started with two signs of hope that the drama will have a “happy end” or at least as “happy” as current world politics will allow. However, both signs of hope may require that we in the non-governmental world, stop being just spectators of the drama and ask to become actors as well and add lines to the script promoting negotiations in good faith.
The first sign of hope comes from Moscow.  On 23 July 2019, the Russian Government’s “Collective Security for the Persian Gulf Region” was presented in Moscow by the Deputy Foreign Minister, Mikhail Bogdanov.  Bagdanov stated that “ The main principles are incrementalism, multilateralism, and strict observation of international law, primarily the U.N. Charter and Security Council resolution.  The looming strategic challenge outlined is creating among all states in the region on an equal basis” a collective security institution.
The Russian proposal for Collective Security for the Persian Gulf follows closely the procedures which led to the 1975 Helsinki Final Act and the creation of the Conference on Security and Cooperation in Europe.  Bogdanov stressed multilateralism as a mechanism for all  involved in the assessment of situations, the decision-making process, and the implementation of decisions.
The second sign of hope comes from the decision within the G7 meeting which ended on 26 August 2019 to mandate the President of France to see what negotiations were possible to continue the Iran Nuclear Accord. This G7 agreement opens a door, at leat a bit, to renewed negotiations between the U.S.A. and Iran.  The first step may be to stop beating the war drums off stage. A second step will be to see what issues other than the Nuclear Accord can be discussed as the provisions of the Nuclear Accord are not really open to re-negotiation given the time it took to reach the original agrrement and the States involved.
Thus, it is probably around the Russian proposal of a Helsinki-type regional security conference that non-governmental organizations, such as the Association of World Citizens, can play an active role.  NGOs were active during the nearly three years that the  Helsinki Accord was being negotiated.  After a short start in Helsinki, the negotiations moved to Geneva.  Although NGO representatives had no direct avenue into the  discussions, all the key States in the negotiations had Diplomatic Missions to the U.N. in Geneva.  We often knew diplomats at these Missions from our work in U.N. meetings, so ideas could be passed on to the Helsinki Final Act negotiators.  It is still too early to know how the Russian proposal will be acted upon.  However, the Russian proposals are a positive sign. We need to work to see what issues can be negotiated.  The Third Act is not written in advance.
Rene Wadlow, President, Association of World Citizens

Thursday, June 13, 2019

Of Sanctions and Trade Wars

TEHRAN (FNA)- The United States has launched an economic war against Iran, which has no other choice but to take necessary countermeasures. The world is watching with great concern, and nations have every reason to worry, because Washington is resolved to pursue unilateralism.
In the world where we live, all countries are interdependent. At stake are the global security and economy and everyone in it. There will be no winners in a trade or sanction war, and no one can remain unaffected. In fact, Iran is not the only target. Since 2017, the United States has initiated trade wars with China and additional tariffs and other measures against its major trading partners. It has also imposed illegal sanctions on countries like Iraq, Syria and Libya.

Claiming "America First," the United States has also adopted a series of unilateral and protectionist measures, wielding a "big stick" of tariffs to force its own will onto China and others. This is sheer trade bullying and does harm to the world. It undermines the authority of the multilateral trading system, the WTO that has been propagated by the US-led West itself.

The United States, by launching unilateral investigations according to its domestic law and imposing additional tariffs on Chinese products, has violated WTO rules, such as most-favored-nation treatment and tariff binding. By imposing illegal and unjustified sanctions on Iran, it has also violated the fundamental norms of international law.

This hurts the interests of many countries, weakens the authority of the WTO, and the UN and its dispute settlement mechanism, and jeopardizes the multilateral trading system and the international political order. It poses a serious threat to global growth and security. The global economy is yet to fully recover from the devastating financial crisis in 2008.

However, some people may have already forgotten the pain. Higher tariffs have caused disorder of international trade, impending global recovery and hurting businesses and well-being of the people. As a result, the global economy is facing a rising risk of recession. The same could be said about America’s wars in the region. The region is yet to recover from the illegal wars on Afghanistan, Iraq, Syria, Libya and Yemen.

In its Global Economic Prospects released in January 2019, the World Bank revised its forecast of global growth further down to 2.9 percent, citing continuous trade frictions as a major downward risk. The IMF, in its World Economic Outlook report published in April, marked down its projection of world economic growth for 2019 to 3.3 percent from the 2018 estimate of 3.6 percent, suggesting that economic and trade friction could further depress the global economy and weaken already anemic investment.

The oil ban on Iran disrupts global energy and supply chains. Iran is a key oil supplier with key links in global energy and supply chains. Given the large volume of oil and components from the country and other end-products exported to the world markets, the US oil ban will hurt all multinationals – not least US ones – that work with Iran and other countries.

The oil ban measures drive up the costs of supply chains and undermine their stability and security. Some countries and businesses are forced to relocate sources of supply at the expense of optimal global allocation of resources. What is even more worrying is that the US measures are putting multilateralism under threat.

In fact, slapping sanctions and tariffs and abusing state power to crush companies and undermine countries look quite familiar, reminding us of other US moves in recent years: The withdrawal from UNESCO and the UN Human Rights Council, the Paris Agreement on climate change and the Iran nuclear deal known as the JCPOA. Being challenged is the rules-based international order and the authority of the UN.

Multilateralism and mutually-beneficial cooperation are in the interests of all countries. Unilateralism and protectionism, on the other hand, go against the trend of history and will lead to nowhere. Facing bullying, countries cannot sit by in silence; after all, anyone could be the next victim.

The US is entirely responsible for the severe setback in security in the Persian Gulf and the broader Middle East. This hasn’t made America great again. On the contrary, it has hurt regional security, US economy, and global energy markets. Iran’s position is clear: Iran does not want a war, but it is not afraid of one; if the war reaches its doorstep, it will fight to the end.

Concerning differences and frictions on the region and security front, Iran has already stuck a nuclear deal in what was to be a win-win agreement. Now after increasing US unilateralism that saw an abrogation of the nuclear deal by Washington and after EU's inaction to provide Tehran with the promised merits, the deal has changed nature into a zero-sum game, leaving Iran no other option but to stop a trend that will eventually end up in its loss. Hence, Tehran is warning the EU and the US change course and revise their tricky strategy or wait for Iran's reciprocal move. In essence, this is not Tehran that should sit to the negotiating table with Washington; rather this is the US that should stop unilateralism and get back to the multilaterally and internationally endorsed nuclear deal and remove the sanctions reimposed on Iran.

Thursday, May 16, 2019

The US and the Law of Jungle

The US and the Law of Jungle








TEHRAN (FNA)- Trump’s one-man foreign policy, characterized by military buildups, sanctions, trade war, isolationism, xenophobia and anti-multilaterism is threatening not only the US, but the entire world.


The Middle East and other regions are on the verge of collapsing or new chaos, while petty ”national security interests” and “America First” policy are sabotaging an international unity and order that might reverse a catastrophic development.

A blatant example of the Trump adminstration’s refusal to engage in crucial inititives and diplomacy to save global peace and security was when the US began trade wars with friends and foes and walked out of numerous international treaties.

The Trump administration withdrew US participation from the Paris Agreement on Climate Change and the UN Human Rights Council, as well as less known treaties. US representatives have walked out of negotiations on the Transpacific Partnership Trade Agreement and the UN Global Compact for Migration, as well as renouncing the Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action (JCPOA), i.e. the Iran Deal. 

Furthermore, the Trump administration has announced the US withdrawal from the Intermediate-Range Nuclear Forces Agreement with Russia and ended cooperation with UN rapporteurs on human rights violations within the US, while cutting down funding for UN Peacekeeping and UN agencies dealing with human rights, Palestinian refugees, population control, sustainable development and global warming.

Contempt for multilateralism and cynical exploitation of fears for negative impacts of immigration are also being expressed by the slogan “America First”, which Trump declared as a theme for his administration.

He used the phrase in his inauguration address and it is part of the title of the federal budget, referencing to increases to the military, homeland security and cuts to spending towards foreign countries. The history of this specific slogan may expose some of the xenophobia and isolationism lurking behind Trump’s politics.

“America First” has echoed through a nation that began to withdraw into itself, while the Trump administration established a nationality quota system, officially based on the pre-existing composition of the American population, but in reality a racist scheme to effectively ban immigration from Asia and Africa and limit migration from Muslim countries like Iran and Syria. 

Considering this, the battle cry of “America First” seems to be an apt slogan for the Trump administration to destabilise the planet and the current trend of multilateralism. An anti-immigration and anti-Muslim stance combined with fears of foreign-inspired terrorism, where ”Catholicism and Judaism” have been superseded by Islam as a threat to the ”American Way of Life”. 

In reality, this epitomises the Cold War thinking and cultural hegemony that persists in the mindset of Trump officials and Christian-Zionists. This mindset is leading some sections of the American polity to draw a dividing line, a new type of Iron Curtain, across the world.
The United States has always boasted about being the most orthodox representative of Western civilization. But its destructive actions show that its idea of civilization is little more than the unrestrained and ruthless competition of the law of the jungle. This mindset informs not only Trump’s foreign policy, but has led to extreme divisions within American society itself.

As is, the world is home to a mix of vibrant cultures that are result of thousands of years of history. For thousands of years, Eastern and Western civilizations have benefited tremendously from taking a respectful and tolerant approach towards each other. The Trumpsters week to stir up conflicts across the globe in the name of civilisation and “America First”. They are doomed to be cast aside by the judgement of history.

Monday, May 06, 2019

Sanctions-Loving US Marching to Its Doom

By: Kayhan Int’l 
It is indeed the height of hypocrisy. The world’s dangerously nuclear armed power with a criminal record of deliberately dropping two atomic bombs on Japan to kill, disable, and deform the maximum number of civilians while destroying the hapless cities of Hiroshima and Nagasaki, continues to accuse Iran of seeking to produce nuclear weapons despite the fact that the Islamic Republic which has mastered the nuclear fuel cycle, considers it "haraam” or religiously forbidden to manufacture weapons of mass destruction.
The US had targeted Japan during the closing years of World War 2 because the Japanese didn’t have the atomic arsenal to retaliate, and the reason Washington dare not attack Pyongyang these days is because of this very factor. That is, North Korea has the nuclear weapons technology to rain down death and destruction on US cities, if provoked.
The other day, the gangster Mike Pompeo, a cowardly character steeped in lies and deceit who acts as Secretary of State to the thuggish US president, Donald Trump, threatened sanctions against countries cooperating legally with Iran under NPT rules to expand the Bushehr Nuclear Power Plant for peaceful production of electricity. 
He alleged that the latest American measures were meant to curb Iran’s ability to refine uranium and mitigate its pursuit of a nuclear weapon.
What a harebrained idiot this Pompeo is? Either he has not studied the history of the Bushehr Power Plant, which despite sabotage by German and French firms that were involved in the original project, was finally completed by Iranian experts (with some technical cooperation from Russia), or he thinks that his threats will scare away foreign firms coordinating with the Islamic Republic, under round-the-clock IAEA monitoring. 
Anyway, like his Italian progenitor Pompeius, whose dream of subjugation of the Parthian Empire was turned into nightmare at the Battle of Carrhae in 53 BC in what is now Turkey when the famous Iranian general Surena crushed the Roman army, Pompeo will be in for a rude shock if he were to provoke the tried and trusted generals of the Islamic Republic in any place in West Asia.
Sanctions or economic terrorism – whatever you call them – is a cowardly tactic used by impotent regimes, supposed to be enjoying a certain degree of military and economic superiority but fearful of the growing political, industrial, commercial and cultural power of a determined nation. 
These are used mostly as a psychological weapon for causing short term pains since in the long run they lack any practical purpose to scare away world countries from the targeted nation or to sabotage that country’s indigenous talents for resistance and development.
In the case of Iran, if sanctions are a blessing in disguise for a strategically located country blessed with a wide variety of natural resources, possessing skilled manpower, serving as a vital link between various geographical areas, and having the iron resolve to defeat terrorism and tyrannical regimes, for the US sanctions are nothing but an exercise in futility. 
Neither Washington has the ability to confront Tehran’s growing popularity in the region, nor the power to stop its rapidly expanding missile and aerospace defence technology, let alone halting Iranian oil imports to ‘zero’.
The main goal of Trump is to prolong the precarious existence of the illegal Zionist entity through such bullying tactics in the vain hope of browbeating Iran into submission.
But when racist Israel and its genocidal ruler, Benjamin Netanyahu the children-killer, cannot cope with the crude missile power of the besieged Palestinians of Gaza, how can they face the powerful precision-guided projectiles of Hezbollah, in case they were foolish enough to bank upon Donald the Dotard’s promise of support for starting hostilities with Lebanon’s legendary anti-terrorist movement.
Sanctions-loving US should know that one false move in West Asia will open the gates of hell for the CENTCOM terrorists who will be wiped out from this part of the world. 

Thursday, April 04, 2019

Kaveh Afrasiabi: US Efforts at IAEA Hit Tall Wall

TEHRAN (FNA)- Kaveh Afrasiabi, author and political scientist, says neither the International Atomic Energy Agency, nor even the US intelligence community ever backed White House allegations against Iran’s nuclear program.
Speaking in an exclusive interview with FNA, Kaveh Afrasiabi mentioned US isolation resulted by its hostile Iran policy, saying “by scrapping the Iran nuclear deal, the Trump administration has put itself in the defensive mode”.

Kaveh Afrasiabi, PhD is an Iranian political scientist who served as Iran’s nuclear negotiation team advisor. He taught political science at Tehran University, Boston University, and Bentley College. He has authored several books on Iran nuclear deal, and other topics including Iran, Islam, ecology, Middle East and UN reform.

Below is the full text of the interview:

Q: Washington withdrew from the Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action (Iran Deal); yet again, in its recent move, it is pressuring the International Atomic Energy Agency to renegotiate the deal. What is the Trump Administration trying to achieve?

A: This is not new and I recall when the then US envoy to UN Nikki Haley visited the IAEA in August, 2017 and reportedly pressured the agency on Iran to no avail. Bad habits die hard and, clearly, the US is intent on influencing the IAEA in order to gain some traction for its flagging hostile Iran policy. By scrapping the Iran nuclear deal, the Trump administration has put itself in the defensive mode and to turn the situation around has to convince others that its non-proliferation policy toward Iran is rational and logical, when in fact it is neither. As a result, as indicated by US media, US efforts at the IAEA have hit a tall wall.

Q: John Bolton, US National Security Adviser, says there is “substantial evidence” that Tehran had lied to IAEA inspectors. On what grounds does he make such a claim?

A: Bolton has not provided any evidence to corroborate his wild claim against Iran, nor his claim is backed by any US intelligence report. In fact, the US intelligence community has gone along with the reports of the IAEA regarding Iran's full compliance with its JCPOA obligations and to this date, no US intelligence has backed the Israeli propaganda against Iran. Bolton's agenda is, therefore, divorced from reality and pushes a jingoistic line against Iran that lacks legitimacy.

Bolton has substituted ideological demagoguery for rational policymaking on Iran, by habitually presenting a caricature of Iran and misrepresenting facts in order to sustain a failed Iran policy that has won few allies around the world. His Iranophobic approach is even dysfunctional for other dimensions of US foreign policy, such as US's South Asia Policy, that has resulted in exemptions for India on Chabahar project. Fortunately, Bolton's opposition was overruled in that case and that alone shows the limits of his influence in setting the White House's Iran policy that is in dire need of reconsideration.

Q: Considering the fact that Tehran is a signatory to the Non-Proliferation Treaty, while Tel Aviv not only has never signed the NPT, but also is believed to already possess nuclear warheads, why should there be any demand for more aggressive inspections of Iran's nuclear facilities?

A: Israel is opposed to the Iran nuclear deal, because it raises the prospect of Israel's denuclearization and regional nonproliferation, which runs contrary to Israel's nuclear monopoly in the Middle East. It is, of course, a sign of Western duplicity and double standards that they completely ignore Israel's nuclear arsenal and press countries such as Iran, which is a member of the NPT and in good standing. By smearing Iran, however, Tel Aviv hopes to deflect attentions from itself and inflate the threat of Iran in the region, so that it can pursue its alliance strategy. The problem is that as long as Tel Aviv refuses to respect the rights of Palestinians and to open its nuclear facilities to outside inspections, as requested by the IAEA, there are structural limits to how far it can achieve its alliance strategy.

Q: How do you find the European special purpose vehicle designed to protect EU companies from US sanctions? Do you believe if it will be put into operation?

A: It appears that the SPV is in the final stages of being formulated as a limited "humanitarian" mechanism to facilitate the transactions on food, medicine, and the like. Due to US pressure, European officials have stepped down from the initial promise of including oil trade in the SPV, and that certainly limits the utility of this mechanism from Iran's perspective, that counts on Europe's living up to the provisions of JCPOA calling for normalization of Iran trade. Still, despite its limitations, the SPV initiative is a right step in the right direction, with a political significance that outweighs the economic significance, and, perhaps, can be the springboard for bolder European stance vis-a-vis the unjust US sanctions in the future.

Sunday, February 24, 2019

How many minutes to midnight?

by James Carroll and Tom Engelhardt

The US president is pushing the world to the edge of the precipice by his doomsday policies based on devilish designs and the destruction of humanity. Stay with us for an article jointly written for the TomDispatch website by James Carroll and Tom Engelhardt, titled: “How Many Minutes to Midnight?”
James Carroll, a former Boston Globe columnist, is the author of “History of the Pentagon, the House of War”, while Tom Engelhardt is author of the book “A Nation Unmade by War”.
Consider it a marriage made in hell. Start with the groom, Donald Trump, the man who once wondered why in the world we make nuclear weapons if we can’t use them; who wouldn’t rule out using nukes, even in Europe; who insisted that a president should be “unpredictable” on the subject; who suggested that it might not be “a bad thing for us” if Saudi Arabia, Japan, and South Korea all became nuclear powers; who threatened North Korea with “fire and fury like the world has never seen”; and who called for a nearly 10-fold increase in the US nuclear arsenal (among many other, often contradictory, comments he’s made on nuclear matters).
Now, think about the bride, National Security Advisor John Bolton, who never saw a nuclear agreement he didn’t want to nuke. Those included President Richard Nixon’s Anti-Ballistic Missile Treaty, President Bill Clinton’s Agreed Framework with North Korea, President Barack Obama’s Iran nuclear deal (all of which he helped to deep-six), and most recently President Ronald Reagan’s Intermediate-Range Nuclear Forces, or INF, Treaty (a pact that had actually resulted in thousands of ready-to-use nuclear weapons being scrapped).
Bolton, with the help of his neocon bro, Secretary of State Mike Pompeo, recently succeeded in sticking a knife directly in the back of that treaty. He’s undoubtedly now eying the New START treaty, which put limits on long-range nukes and is up for renewal in 2021.
The first new member of Trump’s and Bolton’s nuclear family, a “low-yield” nuke, was only recently born and given the less-than-apocalyptic name, W76-2. It looks as though, in nuclear terms, they are headed for a grim version of connubial bliss. To mix a metaphor or two in the fashion of the American president, you might even think of that first progeny of theirs as a minute hand on a ticking clock heading for midnight. It is the most dangerous weapon ever rolled off the nuclear assembly line.
Last month, the National Nuclear Security Administration (formerly the Atomic Energy Commission) announced that the first of a new generation of strategic nuclear weapons had rolled off the assembly line at its Pantex nuclear weapons plant in the panhandle of Texas. That warhead, the W76-2, is designed to be fitted to a submarine-launched Trident missile, a weapon with a range of more than 7,500 miles. By September, an undisclosed number of warheads will be delivered to the Navy for deployment.
What makes this particular nuke new is the fact that it carries a far smaller destructive payload than the thermonuclear monsters the Trident has been hosting for decades – not the equivalent of about 100 kilotons of TNT as previously, but of five kilotons. According to Stephen Young of the Union of Concerned Scientists, the W76-2 will yield “only” about one-third of the devastating power of the weapon that the Enola Gay, an American B-29 bomber, dropped on Hiroshima on August 6, 1945. Yet that very shrinkage of the power to devastate is precisely what makes this nuclear weapon potentially the most dangerous ever manufactured. Fulfilling the Trump administration’s quest for nuclear-war-fighting “flexibility,” it isn’t designed as a deterrent against another country launching its nukes; it’s designed to be used. This is the weapon that could make the previously “unthinkable” thinkable.
There have long been “low-yield” nuclear weapons in the arsenals of the nuclear powers, including ones on cruise missiles, “air-drop bombs” (carried by planes), and even nuclear artillery shells – weapons designated as “tactical” and intended to be used in the confines of a specific battlefield or in a regional theater of war. The vast majority of them were, however, eliminated in the nuclear arms reductions that followed the end of the Cold War, a scaling-down by both the United States and Russia that would be quietly greeted with relief by battlefield commanders, those actually responsible for the potential use of such ordnance who understood its self-destructive absurdity.
Ranking some weapons as “low-yield” based on their destructive energy always depended on a distinction that reality made meaningless (once damage from radioactivity and atmospheric fallout was taken into account along with the unlikelihood that only one such weapon would be used). In fact, the elimination of tactical nukes represented a hard-boiled confrontation with the iron law of escalation, another commander’s insight – that any use of such a weapon against a similarly armed adversary would likely ignite an inevitable chain of nuclear escalation whose end point was barely imaginable. One side was never going to take a hit without responding in kind, launching a process that could rapidly spiral toward an apocalyptic exchange. “Limited nuclear war,” in other words, was a fool’s fantasy and gradually came to be universally acknowledged as such. No longer, unfortunately.
Unlike tactical weapons, intercontinental strategic nukes were designed to directly target the far-off homeland of an enemy. Until now, their extreme destructive power (so many times greater than that inflicted on Hiroshima) made it impossible to imagine genuine scenarios for their use that would be practically, not to mention morally, acceptable.
It was exactly to remove that practical inhibition – the moral one seemed not to count – that the Trump team recently began the process of withdrawing from the Cold War-era Intermediate-Range Nuclear Forces Treaty, while rolling a new “limited” weapon off the assembly line and so altering the Trident system. With these acts, there can be little question that humanity is entering a perilous second nuclear age.
That peril lies in the way a 70-year-old inhibition that undoubtedly saved the planet is potentially being shelved in a new world of supposedly “usable” nukes. Of course, a weapon with one-third the destructive power of the bomb dropped on Hiroshima, where as many as 150,000 died, might kill 50,000 people in a similar attack before escalation even began. Of such nukes, former Secretary of State George Shultz, who was at President Ronald Reagan’s elbow when Cold War-ending arms control negotiations climaxed, said, “A nuclear weapon is a nuclear weapon. You use a small one, then you go to a bigger one. I think nuclear weapons are nuclear weapons and we need to draw the line there.”
The question that arises is: How close is the world to midnight?
Until now, it’s been an anomaly of the nuclear age that some of the fiercest critics of such weaponry were drawn from among the very people who created it. The emblem of that is the Bulletin of Atomic Scientists, a bimonthly journal founded after the bombings of Hiroshima and Nagasaki by veteran scientists from the Manhattan Project, which created the first nuclear weapons. (Today, that magazine’s sponsors include 14 Nobel Laureates.) Beginning in 1947, the Bulletin’s cover has functioned annually as a kind of nuclear alarm, featuring a so-called Doomsday Clock, its minute hand always approaching “midnight” (defined as the moment of nuclear catastrophe).
In that first year, the hand was positioned at seven minutes to midnight. In 1949, after the Soviets acquired its first atomic bomb it inched up to three minutes before midnight. Over the years, it has been reset every January to register waxing and waning levels of nuclear jeopardy. In 1991, after the end of the Cold War, it was set back to 17 minutes and then, for a few hope-filled years, the clock disappeared altogether.
It came back in 2005 at seven minutes to midnight. In 2007, the scientists began factoring climate degradation into the assessment and the hands moved inexorably forward. By 2018, after a year of Donald Trump, it clocked in at two minutes to midnight, a shrill alarm meant to signal a return to the greatest peril ever: the two-minute level reached only once before, 65 years earlier. Last month, within days of the announced manufacture of the first W76-2, the Bulletin’s cover for 2019 was unveiled, still at that desperate two-minute mark, aka the edge of doom.
To fully appreciate how precarious our situation is today, the Bulletin of Atomic Scientists implicitly invites us to return to that other two-minutes-before-midnight moment. If the manufacture of a new low-yield nuclear weapon marks a decisive pivot back toward jeopardy, consider it an irony that the last such moment involved the manufacture of the extreme opposite sort of nuke: a “super” weapon, as it was then called, or a hydrogen bomb. That was in 1953 and what may have been the most fateful turn in the nuclear story until now had just occurred.
After the Soviets exploded their first atomic bomb in 1949, the United States embarked on a crash program to build a far more powerful nuclear weapon. Having been decommissioned after World War II, the Pantex plant was reactivated and has been the main source of American nukes ever since.
The atomic bomb is a fission weapon, meaning the nuclei of atoms are split into parts whose sum total weighs less than the original atoms, the difference having been transformed into energy. A hydrogen bomb uses the intense heat generated by that “fission” (hence thermonuclear) as a trigger for a vastly more powerful “fusion,” or combining, of elements, which results in an even larger loss of mass being transformed into explosive energy of a previously unimagined sort. One H-bomb generates explosive force 100 to 1,000 times the destructive power of the Hiroshima bomb.
Given a kind of power that humans once only imagined in the hands of the gods, key former Manhattan Project scientists, including Enrico Fermi, James Conant, and J. Robert Oppenheimer, firmly opposed the development of such a new weapon as a potential threat to the human species. The Super Bomb would be, in Conant’s word, “genocidal.” Following the lead of those scientists, members of the Atomic Energy Commission recommended – by a vote of three to two – against developing such a fusion weapon, but President Truman ordered it done anyway.
In 1952, as the first H-bomb test approached, still-concerned atomic scientists proposed that the test be indefinitely postponed to avert a catastrophic “super” competition with the Soviets. They suggested that an approach be made to Moscow to mutually limit thermonuclear development only to research on, not actual testing of, such weaponry, especially since none of this could truly be done in secret. A fusion bomb’s test explosion would be readily detectable by the other side, which could then proceed with its own testing program. The scientists urged Moscow and Washington to draw just the sort of arms control line that the two nations would indeed agree to many years later.
At the time, the United States had the initiative. An out-of-control arms race with the potential accumulation of thousands of such weapons on both sides had not yet really begun. In 1952, the United States numbered its atomic arsenal in the low hundreds; the Soviet Union in the dozens. (Even those numbers, of course, already offered a vision of an Armageddon-like global war.) President Truman considered the proposal to indefinitely postpone the test. It was then backed by figures like Vannevar Bush, who headed the Office of Scientific Research and Development, which had overseen the wartime Manhattan Protect. Scientists like him already grasped the lesson that would only slowly dawn on policymakers – that every advance in the atomic capability of one of the superpowers would inexorably lead the other to match it, ad infinitum. The title of the bestselling James Jones novel of that moment caught the feeling perfectly: From Here to Eternity.
In the last days of his presidency, however, Truman decided against such an indefinite postponement of the test – against, that is, a break in the nuke-accumulation momentum that might well have changed history. On November 1, 1952, the first H-bomb – “Mike” – was detonated on an island in the Pacific. It had 500 times more lethal force than the bomb that obliterated Hiroshima. With a fireball more than three miles wide, not only did it destroy the three-story structure built to house it but also the entire island of Elugelab, as well as parts of several nearby islands.
In this way, the thermonuclear age began and the assembly line at that same Pantex plant really started to purr. Less than 10 years later, the United States had 20,000 nukes, mostly H-bombs; Moscow, fewer than 2,000. And three months after that first test, the Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists moved that hand on its still new clock to two minutes before midnight.
This is a madman-theory version of the world.
It may seem counterintuitive to compare the manufacture of what’s called a “mini-nuke” to the creation of the “super” almost six decades ago, but honestly, what meaning can “mini” really have when we’re talking about nuclear war? The point is that, as in 1952, so in 2019 another era-shaping threshold is being crossed at the very same weapons plant in the high plains country of the Texas Panhandle, where so many instruments of mayhem have been created. Ironically, because the H-bomb was eventually understood to be precisely what the dissenting scientists had claimed it was – a genocidal weapon – pressures against its use proved insurmountable during almost four decades of savage East-West hostility. Today, the Trident-mounted W76-2 could well have quite a different effect – its first act of destruction potentially being the obliteration of the long-standing, post-Hiroshima and Nagasaki taboo against nuclear use. In other words, so many years after the island of Elugelab was wiped from the face of the Earth, the “absolute weapon” is finally being normalized.
With President Trump expunging the theoretical from Richard Nixon’s “madman theory” – that former president’s conviction that an opponent should fear an American leader was so unstable he might actually push the nuclear button – what is to be done? Once again, nuke-skeptical scientists, who have grasped the essential problems in the nuclear conundrum with crystal clarity for three quarters of a century, are pointing the way. In 2017, the Union of Concerned Scientists, together with Physicians for Social Responsibility, launched Back from the Brink: The Call to Prevent Nuclear War, “a national grassroots initiative seeking to fundamentally change US nuclear weapons policy and lead us away from the dangerous path we are on.”
Engaging a broad coalition of civic organizations, municipalities, religious groups, educators, and scientists, it aims to lobby government bodies at every level, to raise the nuclear issue in every forum, and to engage an ever-wider group of citizens in pressing for change in American nuclear policy. Back From the Brink makes five demands, much needed in a world in which the U.S. and Russia are withdrawing from a key Cold-War-era nuclear treaty with more potentially to come, including the New START pact that expires two years from now. The five demands are:
No to first use of nukes. (Senator Elizabeth Warren and Representative Adam Smith only recently introduced a No First Use Act in both houses of Congress to stop Trump and future presidents from launching a nuclear war.)
End the unchecked launch-authority of the president. (Last month, Senator Edward Markey and Representative Ted Lieu reintroduced a bill that would do just that.)
No to nuclear hair-triggers.
No to endlessly renewing and replacing the arsenal (as the U.S. is now doing to the tune of perhaps $1.6 trillion over three decades).
Yes to an abolition agreement among nuclear-armed states.
These demands range from the near-term achievable to the long-term hoped for, but as a group they define what clear-eyed realism should be in Donald Trump’s new version of our never-ending nuclear age.
In the upcoming season of presidential politics, the nuclear question belongs at the top of every candidate’s agenda. It belongs at the center of every forum and at the heart of every voter’s decision. Action is needed before the W76-2 and its successors teach a post-Hiroshima planet what nuclear war is truly all about.

Saturday, January 12, 2019

New Dimensions of human rights violations - Zaeri Amirani


article_imageAlmost every day when browsing through the media, a new sanction by the U.S. government on other countries comes up. They are applied so frequently that it seems imposing sanctions has become the favorite pastime of the U.S. The sanctions which are so called "punitive", are imposed on any state that acts against the will of the U.S. says says Iran’s Ambassador to Sri Lanka Zaeri Amirani.


The Ambassador said that although such measures were meant to target governments and force them to back down, the ultimate victims were the people.


"The sanctions and its political, economic and legal aspects have been widely addressed by politicians and the mass media, but its impact on the people in the country receiving the sanctions has received less attention. A significant matter that relates to some basic rights of the people and disregarding it, could be considered a form of human rights violation.


The Universal Declaration of Human Rights, proclaimed by the General Assembly in 1948, entitles all people to have the right to life, liberty, nationality, freedom of thought, conscience and religion, the right to work and to be educated and the right to food and housing. All economic sanctions targeting any state will directly influence the people and their quality of life, hence depriving them of a normal life, is in contradiction with human rights principles.


When it comes to Iran, sanctions go beyond the limits and take newer forms to fulfill multi–pronged purposes. Sanctions become a race for the U.S. and its allies to compete on imposing the strongest restrictions and to boast about. The history of sanctions against Iran dates back to almost four decades. The first sanctions along with freezing Iran’s assets, which kicked in against the country in 1979 and aggravated by eight years of Saddam imposed war, inflicted heavy casualties and grievous sufferings on the Iranian people.


Imposition of severe sanctions on Iran, which at times are eased in parts and reimposed again, has been an inalienable part of U.S. policy towards Iran during the past forty years. However, it’s not the sanctions per se that are important here, but it’s the double standards approach on human rights and its philanthropic gesture towards Iranian people that matters.


Many instances of violation of Iranian people’s rights can be seen, by taking a brief glance at what is happening in the international arena. The U.S. decision to unilaterally withdraw from the Iran nuclear deal and rejecting recent ruling by the International Court of Justice ordering Washington to lift restrictive measures linked to humanitarian trade, food, medicine and civil aviation are the most recent cases to name a few.


The nuclear deal, formally known as the Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action (JCPOA), was finalized in 2015 in Vienna by Iran and six world powers and endorsed by United Nations Security Council Resolution 2231, to restrict Iran nuclear program in return for the lifting of sanctions. Needless to mention that all member states are required to commit themselves to implement the JCPOA and normalize their economic, trade and banking relations with Iran.


The US pulled out of the agreement in May 2018 and reimposed tough sanctions on Iran. It’s so much surprising that a UN member blames and imposes sanctions on a country which abides by the UN Security Council resolution. Worse is to persuade other members to cease implementing the JCPOA by cutting their ties with Iran and threatening to punish countries and companies which keep their cooperation with Iran. This is a true indication of unilateralism and disrespect to international norms and a clear breach of international law.


It goes without saying that violation of international treaties, imposition of oppressive sanctions against innocent people, bullying, intimidation and lack of basic decorum for nations and cultures, results in extremism in the world, which in turn leads to turmoil, bloodshed and finally violation of human rights", the Ambassador said


Ambassador Amirani, quoting Iran’s famous 13th century poet Saadi said ;


Human beings are members of a whole In creation of one essence and soul If one member is afflicted with pain Other members uneasy will remain If you have no sympathy for human pain The name of human you cannot retain.

Monday, November 19, 2018

New sanctions against Iran showed U.S. irresponsibility: Daryl Kimball

By Hamid Bayati


TEHRAN - Daryl Kimball, executive director of the Arms Control Association in Washington believes the new sanctions against Iran showed U.S. irresponsibility. He adds the re-imposition on Nov. 5 of oil-related sanctions on Iran by the Trump administration’s compounds President Trump's reckless and irresponsible decision in May to violate the 2015 Iran nuclear deal, despite acknowledging Iran’s compliance with the accord, and reimpose sanctions.
“We strongly encourage all the other parties to the JCPOA to continue to meet their obligations and preserve legitimate trade with Iran,” Kimball tells the Tehran Times in an exclusive interview.
Following is the full text of the interview:
Q: As announced before, U.S. returned all nuclear sanctions against Iran. Do you think this sanctions is according to U.S. national interest in the long term?
A: The re-imposition on Nov. 5 of oil-related sanctions on Iran by the Trump administration’s compounds President Trump's reckless and irresponsible decision in May to violate the 2015 Iran nuclear deal, despite acknowledging Iran’s compliance with the accord, and reimpose sanctions. It is another serious blow to the Trump administration’s already low credibility on nuclear nonproliferation matters.
Trump administration’s so-called “maximum pressure” policy is not a viable strategy for replacing or augmenting the JCPOA. Although the new oil sanctions are unlikely to change Iran’s commitment to the JCPOA in the short-term, the long-term viability of the deal remains at risk.
Q: U.S. exempt 8 countries temporary from importing of Iran’s oil. Do you think these countries can replace another resource instead of oil of Iran?
A: The Trump administration did not realize its goal of pushing Iran’s oil exports to “zero,” or as close to zero as possible, ahead of the Nov. 5 deadline and issued waivers that allow states to continue purchases, a tangible benefit for Iran. 
The effect of the exemptions to eight countries to continue to import oil from Iran is, however, not yet clear, in part because the details of those waivers, including the amount of oil purchases that would be allowed without sanctions, have not been spelled out. 
Even with these exemptions, the new oil sanctions will deprive Iran of the some of the sanctions relief promised under the original terms of the JCPOA back in 2015. That said, we do not expect that the renewed oil sanctions will change Iran’s commitment to the JCPOA in the short-term. 
Q: The Head of the U.S. Treasury Steven Mnuchin has announced that Washington wants the worldwide payment network to cut off its services to the entities that were affected by Iran sanctions and warned that otherwise SWIFT might be sanctioned as well. Can the U.S. do it?
A: SWIFT is not obligated to comply with the U.S. request but announced Nov. 5 it would again disconnect some Iranian banks from its system. SWIFT said its decision to suspend Iranian banks was “regrettable,” but necessary to maintain stability in the international banking system. This will make it more difficult for other countries, including close U.S. allies, to conduct legitimate trade with Iran. This makes the effective functioning of the European Union’s SPV mechanism, which is designed to allow legitimate trade with Iran, all the more important.
Q: If Iran cannot export oil and cannot work by SWIFT, what means JCPOA for it? I mean if the U.S. can impose their will on these two key issues for Iran, is it rational for Iran stay in JCPOA? What is the EU and Russia and China in this regard?
A: While the waivers granted for oil sales and nuclear cooperation projects detailed by the JCPOA will positively contribute to sustaining the nuclear deal, the Nov. 5 sanctions will have a negative effect on Iran’s economy and reduce the sanctions relief envisioned under the deal.
The commitment of the remaining parties to the JCPOA (EU, China, France, Germany, Russia, and the United Kingdom) and to developing options to sustain legitimate trade with Iran sends an important message of political support, but it will not make up for revenue lost due to the U.S. sanctions.
We strongly encourage all the other parties to the JCPOA to continue to meet their obligations and preserve legitimate trade with Iran. The international community must fulfill UN Security Council Resolution 2231, which endorsed the nuclear deal and called upon all states to support it, until such time as the United States comes back into compliance with the agreement and new talks can begin on win-win approaches to extend and build upon key elements of the JCPOA.

Sunday, November 18, 2018

How China is helping Iran skirt U.S. sanctions

By Syed Zafar Mehdi
TEHRAN - Shortly after the Trump administration reimposed sweeping sanctions on the Islamic Republic of Iran, Secretary of State Mike Pompeo made an important announcement. It was a calculated move to avoid a major embarrassment. The hawks in the power corridors of Washington had anticipated the backlash of sanctions on U.S. foreign policy with many global powers rebuffing Trump’s foolhardy move.
Pompeo said eight countries would be exempted from the draconian sanctions on buying Iranian crude oil due to special circumstances. The countries included China, India, Italy, Greece, Japan, South Korea, Taiwan, and Turkey.
Many of these countries had quite clearly indicated that they would not be cutting oil imports from Iran under the U.S. pressure, most importantly China, Turkey, and India – three of Iran’s largest oil customers.
While India has its own strategic interests in maintaining good relations with Tehran, for instance, the Chabahar port project in Sistan-Baluchistan, Turkey’s relations with Washington have hit a new low following sanctions and trade tariffs imposed by the U.S.
China, which has emerged as a viable counterweight to U.S. hegemony in the world and a protagonist of new international economic policy, has unambiguously reaffirmed its commitment to keep alive the Iran nuclear deal and stand by the Islamic Republic of Iran.
On November 5, when the petroleum-related sanctions came into effect, Chinese foreign ministry said it will continue to “hold a fair, objective and responsible attitude” and “resolutely safeguard its legitimate rights”, while reiterating its opposition to the unilateral U.S. sanctions.
“China feels sorry for the U.S.' decision and we noticed that the international world as a whole opposes the practice of such unilateral sanctions,” foreign ministry spokesperson Hua Chunying said at a press briefing.
She said Iran has been seriously fulfilling its obligations under the JCPOA and its efforts have been recognized by the International Atomic Energy Agency dozen times. She also affirmed that China will firmly safeguard its lawful rights while continuing to adhere to JCPOA and urged relevant parties to stand on the “right side of history”.
China has maintained that implementing the Iranian nuclear deal is akin to safeguarding the authority of UN Security Council, basic norms of international law, international non-proliferation treaty and peace and stability in the Middle East.
As one of the remaining signatories of the JCPOA, along with European Union countries who are exploring options to circumvent the U.S. sanctions, Beijing wants to keep the deal alive. China, believe experts, is in a better position compared to other Asian countries as it is not subservient to U.S. interests and is already embroiled in a bitter trade war with Washington.
For all parties of the JCPOA, Iranian crude oil is the main commodity of interest, particularly for Beijing. In 2017, one-third of Iran’s oil was supplied to China, which underlines the significance of oil trade between the two countries. China’s commitment to continue importing oil from Iran is very likely to deal a body blow to U.S. ploy of reducing Iranian oil imports to zero and ‘starving’ the Iranian nation.
Hu Xijin, chief editor of the influential Chinese daily Global Times, told Tehran Times that there was no possibility of Washington reducing the Iranian oil exports to zero, “because Washington lacks righteousness to do so, therefore it can’t have the full support of the international community”.
To continue oil trade in different currencies other than dollar, Iran has been in talks with key allies, including China. On September 29, Foreign Minister Javad Zarif said Tehran would circumvent sanctions by conducting trade in all currencies to avoid using the US dollar. “You can use your own currency. Sell stuff in your own currency, buy stuff in the other country’s currency, and at the end of a specific period, balance it out in a non-dollar currency. It’s quite possible and may even be profitable,”
China, which is the largest oil importer in the world with around nine million barrels imports every day, has been making concerted efforts to reshape the global oil market with increased usage of its currency in oil trading. If Chinese currency manages to replace the U.S. dollar, it will be a masterstroke.
U.S. has been rendered friendless and isolated in its quest to tear up the Iran deal and force countries to cut oil imports from Iran. European Union has already refused to back down on the Iran deal, exploring ways to develop payment channels to facilitate payments related to Iran’s exports. The goal, according to a statement issued by EU, “is to protect the freedom of other economic operators to pursue legitimate business with Iran”.
Beijing has expressed its full support to the EU's proposal to set up a "special payments system" to facilitate trade with Iran and safeguard the Iranian nuclear deal, which experts believe will significantly reduce reliance on the U.S. dollar in the global oil trade. That will be a game-changer.