Showing posts with label 'crushing' Iran's economy. Show all posts
Showing posts with label 'crushing' Iran's economy. Show all posts

Monday, August 12, 2019

Iran on the Precipice

 


Photograph Source: Tasnim News Agency – CC BY 4.0
There’s never been a full-scale war between two nuclear-armed states. If Iran one day did cross the nuclear threshold the same deterrence will apply. No one rational would want to provoke their own incineration.
Columbia University professor, Kenneth Waltz, the distinguished theorist on the conduct of war, wrote in Foreign Affairs that with Israel possessing over 200 nuclear weapons (which the US refuses to publically admit) Iran having a bomb would bring stability.
I would never go as far as Waltz on that last point. The launch of nuclear weapons can always be done by accident or by the rogue action of one or two of the members of the launch team in the silo.
It has nearly happened in the US a number of times, and probably in the Soviet Union too. Moreover, if Iran got really close to building a bomb, Saudi Arabia would follow in short order, and perhaps Egypt too somewhat later. That would really be Iran cutting off its nose to spite its face.
The arguments between Iran, the US and Europe over the supposed bomb question are becoming confused. To be frightened or not to be? If clear thinking is not quickly restored everyone will lose out.
When President Barack Obama and his team successfully negotiated a long-term freeze in Iran’s nuclear research a milestone in international cooperation on nuclear proliferation was passed.
Russia and China joined the EU and the US as negotiating partners and made a unanimous front when presenting the agreement to the UN Security Council for approval.
Donald Trump unilaterally upended this soon after taking office. In breaking apart a deal approved by the Security Council he broke international law.
The recent UK ambassador to the US, Kim Darroch, reckoned Trump’s primary motivation was not US security or anything of that ilk but was purely motivated by a gut hatred of Obama.
Now the old untruths that were churned out by the Republicans and the Israelis during the Obama-era negotiations are being recycled.
They predicted during the 1990s that Iran would have nuclear weapons by 2000. Then the estimated date was bumped up to 2005. Then to 2015. Now some are saying next year.
The CIA, for its part, has never put its name to these Iranian estimates. Apparently it still thinks that the probability is that Iran was never building a bomb.
They would have been better to focus on Brazil, now led by the extreme right wing nationalist, Jair Bolsonaro, who has close ties with the military, which is now engaged in enriching uranium to 90%, suitable for nuclear bombs, as against Iran’s just announced 5%, suitable for its Bushehr civilian power reactor and a long way from what is necessary to build a bomb.
Brazil needs this high degree of enrichment to fuel its new nuclear submarine, but it could easily be diverted to build a bomb.
There’s a danger, once removed but now back in circulation, that this negative attitude towards Iran could result in a self-fulfilling prophecy, especially if it leads to a military attack.
As two former US National Security Advisors to the president, Zbigniew Brzezinski and Brent Scowcroft, have written, “a military attack by Israel or the US “would significantly increase Iran’s motivation to build a bomb.”
An attack “would also increase the recruiting ability of radical Islamist groups, including Al Qaeda and ISIS.”
Does Trump want to attack Iran or not? Last month US planes were within ten minutes of bombing Iran before he had a last minute change of mind and called off the raid.
The last few days some smoke has been thrown into the air with the somewhat autonomous Iranian Revolutionary Guards seizing a British-owned ship steaming through the Persian Gulf.
Wisely, on the eve of a change in its leadership, the UK is not upping the ante with threats of retaliation. Trump has been careful not to get out in front of the British.
Nevertheless, these incidents go to show how a gunpowder trail can easily be laid. Meanwhile, the American sanctions that were supposed to be lifted because of the Obama agreement are being tightened.
Iran is suffering, especially the poor. Similar sanctions when used against the Iraq of Saddam Hussein resulted in over 30,000 children dying, according to UNICEF.
There are some hints that Trump wants to act as he has with North Korea- jump straight to the top of Iran’s decision making tree and make his own deal.
Never mind that a new deal might only have cosmetic changes, it would enable him to claim he had got a better deal than Obama. He did this with the North American Free Trade Area agreement.
Is it all a fuss about nothing? Only those who live inside Trump’s head know the answer. In this case he is truly master of the universe.

Tuesday, August 21, 2018

Trump's Iran offensive: Regime change by other names

By Kaveh L. Afrasiabi*


Tehran, Aug 18, IRNA - US Secretary of State Mike Pompeo has now announced the creation of a new Iran 'action group' aimed at coordinating and advancing US's grand strategy against the Islamic Republic of Iran.

Trump's Iran offensive: Regime change by other names

Insisting that the purpose of US sanctions against Iran is to cause a 'change in the behavior' of Iranian government, Pompeo has tried to shield the administration from the criticism that it is seeking an unlawful 'regime change' in Iran in violation of UN Charter and international norms.

Pompeo's earlier 12-point demands from Iran, announced immediately after Trump's May exit from the Iran nuclear deal, conveys a similar impression and, subsequently, Pompeo has defended his maximalist demands from Iran, which lack any legal basis whatsoever and simply represent an arbitrary wish list on the part of US, as quite 'ordinary' when, in fact, there is nothing ordinary about a government leveling extra-legal and arbitrary demands from another government while holding the fingers on the trigger of unilateral and unlawful sanctions, reflecting the poison pills of American foreign policy.

Of course, the ruse of 'regime change' approach under the more marketable veneer of modifying Iran's 'behavior' falls by the way side when considering (a) the naked economic aggression aimed at 'crushing' Iran's economy in Pompeo's own words, (b) the US's total disregard for international norms and the UN Security Council's decision on the nuclear deal incumbent on all member states including the US, and (c) the concurrent blistering public attacks on Tehran in the strongest language, reflecting Iranophobia ran amok. Both Pompeo, and his even more hawkish co-conspirator John Bolton, aptly denounced by North Koreans who have refused to negotiate with him, are indeed strong 'regime change' advocates and, yet, refuse to acknowledge the actual US policy against Iran, among other reasons, because they are fully aware of the likely futility of their strategy against an adversary that has successfully resisted the American pressure for nearly 40 years.

This aside, to deconstruct the White House's hostile narrative on Iran, suffice to say that US is a poor candidate to act as the guardian of 'normal behavior,' in light of its own exceptional and highly dreadful history of interventionism and militarism abroad and callous disregard for international norms and principles, vividly demonstrated in its recent gambits in the Middle East, its misbehavior against a whole slew of nations such as Cuba and Nicaragua and Venezuela that hark back to the 19th century Monroe Doctrine and its license to invade under the guise of manifest destiny. Now it turns out that US's new manifest destiny is to 'normalize' its perceived adversaries by the illegitimate hammer of sanctions and threats, this while its own allies such as Saudi Arabia go unpunished while abusing human rights at home and violating the sovereignty of their neighbors and, worse, committing horrific atrocities in Yemen while aiding and arming radical salafi groups in Syria and elsewhere in the region.

Little wonder, then, that the US foreign policy is in serious trouble, with hardly any evidence of success on any front, in light of the trade wars with China and Europe, sanctions and open verbal warfare with NATO ally Turkey, and its present attempt at cajoling the rest of the world behind the 'sanctions regime' on Iran twisting the arms of allies and friends, such as India, whose brave foreign minister has openly questioned the legitimacy of US unilateral sanctions on Iran. Faced with a united front of other JCPOA signatories in defense of the nuclear deal, Pompeo faces the tall challenge of selling his illegitimate Iran policy to the rest of the world, that is still reeling by the impacts of US's 'pre-textual war' on Iraq costing trillions of dollars and heightening international terrorism. Instead of focusing on the real threat to stability, as witnessed in Afghanistan and the resurgence of ISIS terrorists in parts of Iraq today, Pompeo has singled out Iran by resorting to a systematic misrepresentation of Iran's regional behavior, which is in fact openly praised by Iran's neighbors particularly in the Caspian basin and Central Asia. Fact is that Iran has had a constructive role in regional stability and is the target of Saudi and Israeli politics of scapegoat aimed at deflecting attentions to their outrageous misbehavior decried in the international community except in the US.

Indeed, Mr. Pompeo ought to take a serious look at himself in the mirror and stop turning a blind eye to the abnormal and rogue behavior US's allies in the region that must be condemned by any stretch of rule-based imagination. With allies like these flouting international norms on a daily basis, US which is complicit in the Yemen atrocities, has no moral standing, let alone legal, to preach Iran how to behave in its own region. But, of course, the 'regime change' policy is poorly camouflaged as a more modest 'regime behavior change' is destined to fail both by virtue of its sheer illegality and the weight of history operating against Iran and exposing its true unsavory nature.

*Kaveh L. Afrasiabi is political scientist specializing in Iran’s foreign affairs. He has co-authored Iran Nuclear Accord and the Remaking of the Middle East (2018)

Wednesday, February 15, 2012

Iran versus the New Imperialism

by Izeth Hussain

In this Thursday, Feb. 2, 2012 photo, Iranians walk at Tehran’s old main bazaar, Iran. A simple trip the store these days offers a crash course in life under sanctions. The price tags on many imported goods from South Korean refrigerators to Turkish crackers are sometimes double from last year. The money to buy them, meanwhile, has plunged in value against the U.S. dollar and other foreign currencies. (AP)
In my article In Support of Iran in the Island of February 1, I cited material from an article by Peter Jenkins, who is from right within the British Establishment, to sustain the argument that sanctions and the threat of war are clearly disproportionate responses to the Iran nuclear imbroglio, and that all that is required – in Jenkins’ words – is that "Iran should be allowed to enrich uranium – but with the toughest safeguards". In this article I want to contextualize the Iran nuclear imbroglio in relation to what in earlier articles I have called the New Imperialism.

A distinction has to be drawn between the New and the Old Imperialism, a distinction that cannot be an absolute one because the Old continues to persist with the New as can be demonstrated by noting the reactions to the Iran imbroglio. What I have in mind is that there has come about a note of moderation in the West, a retreat from the "aggressive lunacy" that I noted in my earlier article, but Israel seems determined to give Iran a nuclear bomb whacking. The explanation is that Israel is stuck with the Old Imperialism, while the US and the West as a whole have been shifting – in the case of the Iran imbroglio – from the Old to the New Imperialism.

The US and the EU now want more time to be given for sanctions to work, envisaging even tougher sanctions than have been applied up to now. There is a note of moderation about this position that is in striking contrast to the bellicosity that prevailed earlier, symbolized by the sending of US warships into the Straits of Hormuz. The probable reason for this shift is that the world has come to know that Iran is still years away from the capability to make nuclear weapons that can be effectively deployed. The supposition that it wants to proceed to that stage is furthermore no more than a supposition. Also, there is now some degree of alarm that continuing sanctions, with the prospect of even more serious sanctions to follow, will cause serious damage to the world economy. Clearly, sanctions and the threat of war have been disproportionate responses, as pointed out by Jenkins. What is the reason for the aggressive lunacy shown by the West? I believe that it regressed – temporarily we must hope – into attitudes typical of the Old Imperialism: racist arrogance and murderous bellicosity towards natives who dare to defy the West. But Israel, as I have noted, is stuck in the Old Imperialism. US Defense Secretary Panetta is reported as believing that there is a "strong likelihood" that Israel will attack in April, May, or June. At present the world is witnessing the ludicrous spectacle of the US, Britain, France, the UN Secretary General etc pleading with Israel to desist. But Israel is hopping about and yelping delightedly at the prospect of bomb-whacking Iran.

I will now draw the distinction between the two kinds of imperialism. It will help if we approach this distinction by noting what is meant by "modernity". Usually this term is meant to denote a configuration brought about by certain Western historical processes: the Renaissance, the discovery of the individual, the scientific revolution of the seventeenth century, the Enlightenment of the eighteenth, and the industrial revolution of the nineteenth century. In politics it has led to the liberal democratic order being widely regarded as the ideal one. But there is an obverse side to this notion of modernity. An alternative notion gained wide diffusion after 1992 which saw the celebration of the 500th anniversary of the discovery of America by Christopher Columbus. In 1492 Christian Spain conquered Granada, ending Muslim rule in Western Christendom. That led to two major consequences: the unification of a nation, Spain, and the Western drive towards the conquest of the world.

Both consequences, the nation-state and imperialism, led to dominant groups treating others as inferior. In 1492 Christian Spain ordered the Jews to convert or leave, treatment that was extended to the Muslims as well in 1499. Outside Spain the Conquistadors ravaged Latin America, robbing silver and gold and natural resources after subjugating or committing genocide against the indigenous peoples. That inaugurated the several centuries of imperialist domination by the nation-states of the West, and that was "modernity" as experienced and understood by the peoples of Afro-Asia and Latin America. It was an imperialism that was racist to the bone. Of course the Enlightenment ideology was also there, but what clearly predominated was the Columbus ideology. A major change took place after 1945, when the Enlightenment ideology became much more assertive.

I have argued in an earlier article that it is wrong to think of the New World Order and the New Imperialism in terms of a dichotomy in which one is good and the other evil. We should rather think of them as positions in a spectrum in which the one can slide into the other, and back again. The changing Western attitudes to the Iran imbroglio that I have noted above illustrate my point. Another convincing illustration is provided by the case of Syria. Practically everyone agrees that the Assads pere et fils have been grisly horrors, that Bashir should go and a democracy be installed, and that that would help towards a New World Order. The difference is that China, Russia and others want an orderly transition to democracy, whereas the West’s focus is on regime change behind which could lurk the drive towards a New Imperialism.

As I have noted above Israel is stuck in attitudes appropriate to the Old Imperialism, and recently Obama has declared that in the event of an Iran-Israel conflict the US will side with Israel. Nothing surprising in that of course, but what is the explanation for what looks like US idiocy. Would it be far-fetched to suggest that they are in unholy bedlock because both nations have their origin in the expropriation of lands belonging to natives and bouts of genocide against them? Was that also the reason for the unholy bedlock between Zionist Israel and apartheid South Africa? Anyway, some kind of explanation has to be found to dissuade the West from sliding into the aggressive lunacy appropriate to Colombusian modernity.

I will next make some very brief observations on why the West’s aggressive lunacy over Iran has been allowed to go this far. Iran is years away from the capability to equip itself with even a rudimentary nuclear arsenal, and even if it goes further it is difficult to see how that arsenal can be deployed. If it is used aggressively, Iran‘s own extinction will quickly follow. Only Islamophobic idiocy can lead to the supposition that Iran will use the nuclear bomb for aggression. It can of course serve as a deterrent to make Israel and the West think twice before committing aggression against Iran – about which I will be making some further observations. I believe that the reason why the West’s aggressive lunacy has been allowed to go this far is that powers, such as Russia, China, and India, which earlier curbed the West are now showing a readiness to compromise with it. The underlying reason for that is that they are pleased by the prospect of the West co-opting them as the world’s bosses to run the New World Order.

The most important question underlying the Iran imbroglio is this: Are Iran and other small states entitled to defend themselves? The answer of the international community will of course be resoundingly in the positive. But that is in theory. In practice of course the answer is in the negative, because the small states are not allowed to acquire nuclear weapons or weapons of mass destruction which are reserved for the powerful nations, the happy few. By way of illustration of what I have in mind I will cite the case of Iraq. In 2002 there was no UN authorization for military action against Iraq. At that time Iraq had been mercilessly beaten down through the Gulf War and posed no threat whatever to any country. And yet, the Bush-Blair gang pretended that Iraq had WMDs, deliberately ignoring the contrary evidence provided by Al Baraedi of the International Atomic Energy Agency, and unleashed aggression resulting in the deaths of 600,000 guiltless Iraqis and other horrific consequences. Would all that have happened if Iraq had a dinky little nuke that could be dropped on Golden Californy, or on the M-East buddy boys of the US, or – perish the thought – on Israel? A very plausible case can be argued that only a nuclear bomb could have served as a deterrent against that aggression, one of the greatest crimes against humanity ever committed.


The case then is for all states to be equipped with nuclear weapons. But that prospect is terrifying because the small states, not just the powerful ones, can also be subject to fits of aggressive lunacy. The valid case therefore is for total nuclear disarmament, but we all know that the present nuclear weapons powers will agree to that only theoretically, not in practice. There seems to be only one possible deterrent for the small states in the present situation: the power of international public opinion. This may sound rather fanciful, but not if we consider the case of Vietnam. The US did not withdraw from there because it was defeated militarily, retaining as it did the power to bomb Vietnam back into the Stone Age if it so desired. It withdrew because international public opinion turned against the US aggression, most powerfully in the US and other Western countries as manifested by the huge mass demonstrations that took place there. Interestingly, no such demonstrations took place in the Third World countries. Why not? The probable reason is that very few of them had fully functioning democracies, and the masses were not accustomed to the idea of asserting their will through demonstrations. It would appear therefore that the only deterrent against aggression for small states requires fully functioning democracies as a pre-condition. Otherwise they could be at the mercy of the New Imperialism.