Showing posts with label JCPOA agreement. Show all posts
Showing posts with label JCPOA agreement. Show all posts

Wednesday, July 17, 2019

What Right Has Britain to Seize an Iranian Tanker Off Spain?

 

Photograph Source: Bengt Nyman from Vaxholm, Sweden – CC BY 2.0
“We have reason to believe that the Grace 1 was carrying its shipment of crude oil to the Banyas Refinery in Syria. That refinery is the property of an entity that is subject to European Union sanctions against Syria.”
– Fabian Picardo, chief minister of Gibraltar
“[Praise for Gibraltar and the British marines] for this bold move to enforce Syria sanctions [that deny] valuable resources” to the Syrian government.
– British Foreign Secretary Jeremy Hunt On Twitter
The EU has banned the sale of oil to Syria. Very well, but what has that to do with Iran, or its sales of oil to Syria? Tomasz Wlostowski, a lawyer who specializes in EU regulations, says there is no legal basis in EU sanctions law to take such action.)
– Tomasz Wlostowski on Twitter
What gives the UK the right to seize on July 4 an Iranian oil tanker in Spanish territorial waters, force it to Gibraltar, interrogate its four-man (non-Iranian) crew, and arrest its captain and chief officer?
Why, the request of the U.S. of course.
The Spanish government has stated that the British marines and Gibraltar port authority operated at the behest of Washington, after Trump threatened then called off airstrikes against the Islamic Republic. (Gibraltar authorities deny this.) The piratical act was naturally denounced by Iran, which threatens to seize a British tanker if London does not return its vessel. The Brits respond that they might return the ship if given assurances it was not headed to Syria; indeed, Foreign Minister Hunt had a “constructive” phone call with his Iranian counterpart Javad Zarif.
Iran for its part denies that the ship was heading to Syria, but what if it was? What is wrong with any country selling oil to Syria, whose government is recognized by many large powerful countries and needs oil to recover from its horrific civil conflict?
The EU has slapped sanctions on Syria since the Arab Spring protests and outbreak of war in Syria in 2011, in compliance with the U.S. decision to effect regime change through aid to armed rebels, and a concerted U.S.-Israeli campaign to isolate Damascus. The premise is that the U.S. determines a government’s legitimacy; when it withdraws it, Europe must go along.
And when Europe tells Iran it must not sell oil to Syria, Iran must go along. Despite Iran’s extraordinary patience in the face of Trump’s provocations, its determination to stick to the JCPOA, its willingness to discuss with France some changes to the deal, it remains a pariah in Washington’s eyes.
Despite the fact that Trump himself is deplored by world leaders generally and the U.S. has lost prestige in the world since his election, Britain still does its bidding. The British ambassador to Washington has been obliged to quit his post after the leaking of diplomatic cables accusing Trump of ineptness and incompetence, but still, London marches almost lock-step with Washington in foreign policy.
Britain might have told Washington: “We don’t have any right to seize a commercial vessel in foreign waters engaging in legal activities. And why would we want to cooperate with you in exacerbating tensions with Iran?” Instead the British Marines act as Trump’s buccaneers.
The U.S. press does not problematize the ship seizure itself. It reports on attempts to “violate sanctions” as though the sanctions are themselves proper and worthy of observance. China, Russia, India, South Africa, many countries do not sanction Syria or buy the U.S. interpretation of Syrian realities. It is not the “international community” that wants to punish Syria, or cut its ties to Iran. It is the U.S., which seems of late to be testing its lingering clout with its allies.
The UK was on board the Iraq War-based-on-lies, but has not committed to a U.S.-Israeli-Saudi war on Iran. Perhaps the favor of the tanker seizure was designed to deepen London’s involvement in the U.S.’s long-term regime-change projects in both Iran and Syria. As Trump tries to woo the UK away from Europe, the “special relationship” acquires new meaning, even as an ambassador departs for candidly noting the Trump administration’s ineptness. The seizure looks to me like a loyalty statement. Britain remains the U.S.’s poodle.

Thursday, January 24, 2019

Some Want Iran’s Past To Poison Its Future


height.576.no_border.width.1024


by Peter Jenkins
The Washington Times reported on January 14 that the Institute for Science and International Security (ISIS) is accusing Iran of having failed to declare to the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) a site charged with “producing components for nuclear weapons.” The accusation is based, apparently, on satellite imagery and documents that the Israeli intelligence service claims to have stolen from a warehouse in a suburb of Tehran. ISIS urges the IAEA to “verify sites, locations, facilities, and materials involved in these activities.”
This accusation came to the notice of the National Security Advisor John Bolton. According to the Washington Times, he used it as a pretext to accuse Iran, in a tweet, of “fudging its reports to the nuclear disarmament watchdog” and of “not-identifying a former nuclear weapons site under Project 110 of the Amad Plan.” Bolton added: “Pressure on Iran to abandon nuclear ambitions will increase.”
These accusations are curious in a number of ways.
The 2015 Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action (JCPOA) commits Iran to refrain from engaging in activities that could contribute to the development of a nuclear explosive device. The commitment came into effect in January 2016. The stolen warehouse material relates to Iranian nuclear weapon activities prior to 2004. Whether or not, prior to 2004, Iran ran a site producing components for nuclear weapons is irrelevant to a post-2015 JCPOA commitment. A belief that something was happening prior to 2004 cannot serve as a reason to suspect that the same thing is happening in 2019. In fact, since Iran’s Supreme Leader ordered a stop to nuclear weapon research and development in late 2003, it is very unlikely that Iran is still running a site “charged with producing components for nuclear weapons.”
It may be, however, that ISIS—not to mention the Israeli suppliers of the stolen material and John Bolton—wants the IAEA to revisit Iran’s historic nuclear weapon activities, which used to be referred to as a “possible military dimension” (PMD). If so, they are likely to be disappointed. The PMD file was closed in December 2015. That was when the IAEA Board of Governors noted (in resolution GOV/2015/72) that “all the activities in the Road-map for the clarification of past and present outstanding issues regarding Iran’s nuclear programme were implemented in accordance with the agreed schedule,” and further that “this closes the Board’s consideration of this item.”
In theory, of course, the Board could decide that it had been a little hasty in closing its consideration of a PMD. It could ask the IAEA director general to re-open the file and request access to the location that ISIS has in its sights. But that would be a gross breach of faith. One of the understandings that made possible the JCPOA was that, if Iran did everything the IAEA asked to clarify “past and present outstanding issues,” the file would be closed.
Perhaps a gross breach of faith is precisely what ISIS and its Israeli backers hope to cause. If so, they will probably fail. Why would the remaining JCPOA parties and most IAEA Board members provoke Iran, through a breach of faith, into renouncing the JCPOA? Their interest is to sustain an agreement that gives the IAEA an exemplary opportunity to acquire confidence that there are no undeclared nuclear materials or activities in Iran, and in complying, unlike the United States, with UN Security Council resolution 2231.
Another curiosity is that Bolton referred to the IAEA as a “nuclear disarmament watchdog.” In as much as the IAEA has any canine features, it is a nuclear non-proliferation watchdog. It verifies the non-diversion of nuclear materials to uses incompatible with Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty (NPT) obligations. It would be surprising if Bolton, for all his limitations, were unaware of this. So presumably the reference to disarmament is intended to mislead. It conveys the impression that Iran possessed nuclear weapons and is being deprived of them. This is the sort of alternative reality usually associated with Bolton’s current boss.
Bolton’s reference to Iran abandoning nuclear ambitions is similarly off base. It seems improbable that Bolton has in mind Iran’s civil nuclear energy program. Almost certainly, he wants readers of his tweet to believe that Iran still harbors an ambition to be a nuclear weapon possessor-state. If so, he is ignoring that for more than a decade the U.S. national Intelligence community has judged Iran’s decision-makers to have abandoned a nuclear weapon program in 2003 and to have no plan to acquire nuclear weapons.
Reader, beware attempts to use Iran’s past to poison its future!

avatar

PETER JENKINS

Peter Jenkins was a British career diplomat for 33 years, following studies at the Universities of Cambridge and Harvard. He served in Vienna (twice), Washington, Paris, Brasilia and Geneva. He specialized in global economic and security issues. His last assignment (2001-06) was that of UK Ambassador to the IAEA and UN (Vienna). Since 2006 he has represented the Renewable Energy and Energy Efficiency Partnership, advised the Director of IIASA and set up a partnership, The Ambassador Partnership llp, with former diplomatic colleagues, to offer the corporate sector dispute resolution and solutions to cross-border problems. He was an associate fellow of the Geneva Centre for Security Policy from 2010 to 2012. He writes and speaks on nuclear and trade policy issues.

Saturday, December 01, 2018

Sanctions War

Editor


The US is the only country in the world that uses sanctions as a weapon of war. Islamic Iran has been subjected to a new round of sanctions — completely illegal — to force it to comply with Washington’s ludicrous demands. They went into force on November 5 (meant to coincide with the “hostage crisis” that started on Nov. 4, 1979) with the avowed aim of shutting off Iran’s oil exports. The punitive measures also targeted 700 individuals, banks, aircraft, ships, and companies tied to Iran’s energy and financial industries.
If it is any consolation to the Islamic Republic, it is not alone in being subjected to sanctions. Russia, China, Turkey, Syria, Cuba, Venezuela, and North Korea also face America’s wrath. In the past, Iraq and Pakistan were also sanctioned because the Washington warlords did not like their policies. Between 1991 and 1996, more than 586,000 Iraqi children were killed as a result of US sanctions, a horror described by then US Secretary of State Madeleine Albright as a price “worth it” to remove Saddam Husayn from power (he was removed from power not through sanctions but by US bombs).
Returning to the latest round of illegal sanctions against Iran, the US no longer has the clout or the power to enforce them as it used to. Even America’s European allies are appalled at the cavalier attitude of Donald Trump. Iran is in strict compliance of the 2015 JCPOA agreement — a fact repeatedly certified by the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA). Even Trump does not dispute that; what he is demanding is that Iran must abandon its defensive missile program and end all policies that advance its strategic interests. In other words, Trump demands Iran’s surrender, something the moron-in-chief is not going to achieve in his lifetime.
While Trump continued with his characteristic bombast through tweets, the climb down was left for Secretary of State Mike Pompeo to announce. Ten countries in all were exempted from sanctions, including Turkey, Iraq, India, China, South Korea, Japan, Taiwan, Russia, Italy, and Greece. Three countries — India, China, Japan — account for some 80% of Iran’s oil, so the latest round of sanctions are practically meaningless as far as Iran is concerned.
Some countries had already announced that they would not abide by the illegal US sanctions. These included Turkey, Iraq, China, and Russia. Members of the European Union (EU) said they would establish a separate payment mechanism to bypass trading in US dollars. Russia has created a new payment system that bypasses SWIFT (Society for Worldwide Interbank Financial Telecommunication), the Belgium-based mechanism that simply transmits information about transactions.
Russia’s alternative to SWIFT — SPFS — is drawing considerable interest, especially from the Europeans, who are fed up of Trump’s disruptive behavior, as well as China and Turkey. And then there are barter arrangements being worked out whereby countries trade in their own currencies. Turkey, Iran, Russia, and China have all entered into such arrangements. India, too, despite playing both sides of the fence, is looking into it.
Thus, realistically, while Iran may face some difficulties in the near term, it is the US under Trump that has been left largely isolated. He only has himself to blame. Washington’s demands were always illegal but Trump’s latest moves have shown how obnoxious he can be. His behavior has turned off even his closest allies. He is too toxic to touch. Similarly, the two pariah regimes, Zionist Israel and Wahhabi Arabia that have pushed this policy, also stand exposed.

Wednesday, August 22, 2018

7 reasons that prove Netanyahu is a liar


By: Seyyed Hadi Borhani

























Borhani: It’s been a while that a new so-called friend for Iranian nation has raised head out of soil. Only a little bit of time in social networks introduces him.

He is so enthusiastic to follow up events inside Iran and he keeps delivering video messages to Iranian people, based on sympathy over disasters such as earthquakes, hails for Iranian national football team and deeply looks for solutions over Iran’s water crisis.

In this regard 7 major reasons are to introduce to prove that Netanyahu is a liar and is not trustworthy:

1-Netanyahu’s corruption cases are well proved to his own people, Case 1000 and Case 2000 are viral inside Israel and the local media deeply follow the cases.

2-Netanyahu’s scandal over his open relationships with women outside his marriage: Netanyahu was caught in a relationship with Fleur Cates a none Jewish girl, while he was married to his first wife Miriam Weisemann the scandal followed to a divorce between the couple. Netanyahu was caught again for having a physical relationship with Ruth Bar a married woman and his office assistance, a short clip of the relationship went viral throughout the regime well known as Bibi-Gate scandal. Netanyahu challenged to save his 3rd marriage.

3-Corruption is not limited to Netanyahu. His family is also engaged in a number of corruptions. His family members are well known for luxury life style. There have been many complaints from his house maids over their wages. These cases are well known inside Israel as Bottle-Gate. Netanyahu’s wife is nicknamed as (Modern Marie Antoinette) inside Israel, because she unfamiliar with domestic financial issues of Israelis.

4-Corruption in Netanyahu’s cabinet and coworkers: Corruption is considered to be a default option for cooperating with Netanyahu. Many of his office members were forced to resign over the scandals of their corruptions such as: Natan Eshel, Gil Shefer, Ari Harow and David Sharan.

5-Netanyahu has already been well known for lies in international societies, some of them are as follows:

a- In October 2015, Netanyahu claimed that Nazi German leader Hitler initially did not intend to kill the Jews, but after meeting with Palestinian leader Haj Amin al-Husseini Hitler was convinced by al-Husseini’s recommendations to massacre the Jews. This lie not only surprised Muslim archeologists but also surprised Jewish archeologists. Angelina Merkel, the German Chancellor, rejected this allegation and urged over Germany's responsibility for this crime. Even Holocaust archeologists stepped into the arena and revealed Netanyahu’s lies: Jewish genocides began five months before Hitler and Al Husseini's visit.

b- Netanyahu claimed several times that Israel is the only spot in the region that freely celebrates Christian events such as Christmas. Those who are educated enough are very well informed that Christian events are freely celebrated in the region’s independent countries such as Iran, Syria and Lebanon.

c- For 26 consecutive years Netanyahu has claimed that Iran is only few steps from making a nuclear bomb. First in 1992 he claimed so and said that Iran is only 5 years from making a nuke. He then continued these sets of lies in 1995, 1996, 2009 and 2012. After JCPOA agreement IAEA reported that Iran’s nuclear program has no signs of a military use and is completely peaceful.

d- Obama’s administration pressured Netanyahu’s administration over continuing expansions of settlement, Netanyahu agreed to postpone settlements for 10 months but as local media reported Israel did not stick to the agreement and soon after that started expansion of settlements.

6- Former Israeli Prime Minister Isaac Robin's wife also wrote about Netanyahu: “Benjamin Netanyahu is a corrupt man and such a liar.” More interestingly, Israeli public opinion is about Netanyahu. Sixty percent of Israelis and 41 percent of Netanyahu's supporters do not consider him to be honest in 2009 according to a poll conducted by the New America's Middle East Task Force.

7- Netanyahu's lies have also plagued the leaders of the friendly countries of Israel, so that they also had to take positions that are not so common in the diplomatic world: a number of quotations from Netanyahu's talks with Western leaders in the press, indicates their anger and discomfort from the lack of coherence from Netanyahu’s lies. The conversation broke out when French President Nicolas Sarkozy was unaware of the microphone being on and in a meeting with Obama (November 4, 2011) on the sidelines of the G20 summit said: “I can no longer bear him. He is such a liar.” Obama answered in sympathy: “What can I do that I have to deal with him every day?”