Showing posts with label Nuclear Arms Race. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Nuclear Arms Race. Show all posts

Monday, February 18, 2019

Trump re-sets the sail for U.S. nuclear supremacy

While for many the scrapping of INF at the hands of Donald Trump is a symbolic revival of cold war geo-politics, there are many important differences, which strongly indicate there is much more to it than meets the eye. Salman Rafi Sheikh, research-analyst of International Relations and Pakistan’s foreign and domestic affairs, has more in an article titled “Trump re-sets the sail for U.S. nuclear supremacy.”
This isn’t just a second coming of cold war; rather at the heart of the matter is the U.S.’ dwindling nuclear capability vis-à-vis its competitors, Russia and China. This capability has dwindled not because the U.S. hasn’t been spending enough, but because Russia and China have developed themselves into much more (militarily) powerful states than the U.S. could imagine. Scrapping INF is thus only a step, although a major one, towards re-establishing U.S. supremacy. As a matter of fact, the writing for the return of nuclear arms race was always on the wall ever since Trump assumed presidency.
Soon after becoming the U.S. president, Donald Trump had made his intentions clear. In an interview given to Reuters in February 2017, he said that the U.S. had “fallen behind on nuclear weapon capacity”. Trump added further that “I am the first one that would like to see everybody – nobody have nukes, but we’re never going to fall behind any country even if it’s a friendly country, we’re never going to fall behind on nuclear power.”
This resolve to build weapon capacity boiled down in 2018 to the other resolve to expand the nuclear arsenal when the U.S. announced to scrap the 1987 INF treaty.
And, in the 2018 Nuclear Posture Review, then Defense Secretary of the US, James Mattis brought to limelight what the U.S. is aiming at and what factors are driving the U.S. towards an expanded arsenal. The reason, according to Mattis, was the growing power and capability of Russia and China. He said “We must look reality in the eye and see the world as it is, not as we wish it to be…… Russia is modernizing these weapons as well as its other strategic systems……China, too, is modernizing and expanding its already considerable nuclear forces. Like Russia, China is pursuing entirely new nuclear capabilities tailored to achieve particular national security objectives…..Elsewhere [North Korea, Iran, India, Pakistan] the strategic picture brings similar concerns….”
He added, “given the range of potential adversaries….” the review argued that the need for a new nuclear strategy coupled with a “modernization programs” has never been greater than now.
The U.S. has already scrapped the INF, and president Trump’s recently delivered State of the Union address officially launched this arms race to purposefully re-establish U.S. nuclear supremacy.
Trump was explicit when he said that the US is “developing a state-of-the-art Missile Defense System.” He saw no reason to be apologetic about “advancing America’s interests” and cast his decision to withdraw the US from the INF in that light.
And, while the U.S. president did show that negotiating a new treaty was possible, he was quick to re-affirm his often-repeated resolve that the US “will outspend and out-innovate all others by far” in an arms race, underscoring that he is all but concretely seeking the U.S. nuclear superiority.
This is essential for the U.S. to maintain its position of strengthen in regions that it has been dominating ever since the end of cold war, but is increasingly become incapable. A case in point may be China’s rapidly growing military capability in the South and East China Sea regions. According to U.S.’ own estimates, China has set-up about 1,000 medium and short-range missiles, purportedly intending to prevent the U.S. from entering the waters with impunity. These missiles are capable of hitting U.S. aircraft carriers and military bases, strategic tools the U.S. uses to dominate remote regions.
Another case in point may be Russia’s testing of RS-24 Yars intercontinental ballistic missile following Trump’s State of the Union speech and within hours of an earlier similar American test-firing of a Minuteman ICBM in California. Russian missile system is capable of evading missile defense systems (which Trump boasted about.) It manoeuvers during the flight and carries both active and passive decoys and has at least 60-65% chance to penetrate defenses.
Sensing the seriousness of the challenges the Russians and Chinese are posing to the U.S.’ previously un-challenged supremacy, the Pentagon recently announced a special missile defense report, in which it stressed that the US should revamp its missile defense program to combat what it referred to as foreign threats. It includes plans to study a possible orbital sensor system (weaponizing the space) to intercept and stop missiles in their tracks. President Trump said as he unveiled the review “The world is changing and we’re going to change much faster”.
Significantly enough, the review was announced only months after an expert commission published a report on President Trump’s defense strategy and argued the U.S.’ “margin of superiority” is now “profoundly diminished”.
In this context, the U.S. decision to scrap the INF because Russia has been as the American officials said “violating,” it is only scapegoating; while the other developments we have noted show the true nature of the U.S. exit from INF, an exit that is nothing more than a U.S. resolve to keep the world under its unilateral domination, having the ability to hit and intervene anywhere and anytime with no strong adversaries, having the capability of hitting back the U.S., to counter.
But the true intentions notwithstanding, the possibility of the U.S. succeeding in re-establishing its supremacy is low, given that the U.S. withdrawal from the INF is only going to push its strategic peers, Russia and China, to give a befitting reply. Russia’s testing of RS-24 Yar is only an indication of what is to come.
As it seems, America's announced withdrawal from the Intermediate-Range Nuclear Forces Treaty (INF) with Russia indicates that US President Donald Trump has no interest in nuclear arms control. Dennis Etler, a former professor of Anthropology at Cabrillo College in Aptos, California, said, that the US withdrawal will lead to nuclear proliferation and fuel a new arms race.
Etler added, “It should be clear to one and all that the US under the Trump administration has no interest in nuclear arms control.” “Rather than seek avenues to reduce tensions and solve differences of opinion about adherence to the INF Treaty the US has opted to scuttle the treaty in opposition to the desire of other concerned nations.”
INF requires the US and Russia to eliminate all their nuclear and conventional missiles with ranges of 1,000–5,500 km (620–3,420 mi). It also bans either side from stationing short- and intermediate-range, land-based missiles in Europe.
The accord was signed towards the end of Cold War in 1987 between former US President Ronald Reagan and former Soviet leader Mikhail Gorbachev.
The US argues that Russia has jeopardized the treaty for years by deploying ground-launched missiles that fall within the banned range.
Russia has dismissed violating the agreement and has accused the US instead of breaking the deal, adding that a withdrawal from the accord would trigger an arms race
Russia’s President Vladimir Putin warned in December that Moscow will develop missiles currently banned under INF if the United States withdraws from the bilateral treaty.

Wednesday, December 05, 2018

Disarmament: The forgotten premises of Non-Proliferation

By: Hossein Mousavian*


Tehran, Dec 5, IRNA - Iranian ex-diplomat and former nuclear negotiator Hossein Mousavian in an article referred to US withdrawal from Iran nuclear deal saying Trump is forcing the world into a nuclear arms race.

The “withdrawal doctrine” of the Trump administration is pushing the world to the brink of a new nuclear arms race, Mousavian said in his article. 

The full text of Mousavian’s article that originally appeared in lobelog.com is as follows:

In an interview with the daily Neue Osnabrücker Zeitung, German Foreign Minister Heiko Maas announced a German-led initiative on global disarmament, warning that technologically advanced weapons can soon transform science fiction into “deadly reality.” This announcement came a few weeks after President Trump declared that the United States plans to withdraw from the Intermediate-Range Nuclear Forces Treaty (INF), which was ratified in 1988. State managers in the European Union recognize the crucial need to embark on universal disarmament even if the current U.S. government remains oblivious.

For about five decades during the Cold War, a nuclear arms race between the Soviet Union and the United States constantly threatened the peace and security of the world. However, advances in the destructive capacities of military technologies, which drastically raised the cost of nuclear wars in economic and human terms, produced a mutual deterrence between the two leading superpowers. This political reality of mutually assured destruction meant that the line of demarcation between victory and self-annihilation is extremely thin.

Hence, observing the magnitude of the destructive capacity of nuclear weapons, both superpowers became increasingly aware of the importance of mutual reduction of their nuclear stockpiles.

Gloomy Prospects for Nuclear Disarmament 

Prior to the implementation of the INF Treaty, another crucial international instrument—the Treaty on the Non-Proliferation of Nuclear Weapons Treaty (NPT)—has served as the cornerstone of the global nuclear non-proliferation regime. The NPT provides legal and technical mechanisms to facilitate the pursuit of nuclear disarmament by the nuclear-weapon states. More importantly, Article VI of the treaty legally obligates five nuclear states namely, United States, Russia, China, France, and the UK to “complete disarmament under strict and effective international control.”

Over the past five decades, none of the NPT-designated nuclear weapon states has meaningfully engaged in negotiations to complete disarmament of their nuclear weapons. Worse, they have set agendas to enhance and modernize their nuclear capabilities at enormously high costs. For instance, modernizing the U.S. nuclear arsenal will cost an estimated $1.7 trillion over the next 30 years, which is equivalent to the GDP of Canada! Hence, the biggest violators of the core tenets of the NPT are the five designated states who possess nuclear weapons.

The NPT-designated countries are not the only ones who continue to violate the treaty. Those who have failed to join the treaty in the first place have, with the exception of North Korea, have escaped the repercussions of failing to join such an important international treaty. India, Pakistan, and Israel are non-signatories of the NPT that possess nuclear weapons, but international efforts at disarming them have been largely in vain.

In July 2017, over 120 nations adopted the international treaty banning possession of nuclear weapons by the nine nuclear weapon states. This attempt at getting such a historic resolution approved in order to universally ban possession of nuclear weapons by all UN member states was scuttled by the nuclear-weapon states themselves.

Impediments to Denuclearization of the Middle East 

In 1974, Iran formally presented the proposal for establishing the Middle East nuclear-weapons-free-zone in a resolution submitted to the United Nations General Assembly with Egypt as a co-sponsor. Since then, despite numerous UN resolutions to create a Middle East free of weapons of mass destruction (including nuclear warheads), Israel remains the single state in the region to have gone nuclear.

The Iran nuclear deal was a step forward in terms of nuclear non-proliferation. As President Barack Obama said, “the Iran deal is the most robust and intrusive inspections and transparency regime ever negotiated for any nuclear program in history.” The regionalization of the Iran deal could have been a great step toward nuclear weapon free zone in the Middle East.

Instead, the U.S. withdrawal from the Iran nuclear deal limited the possibilities of creating a Middle East free from nuclear weapons. The “withdrawal doctrine” of President Trump’s administration, which has led to pulling back from effective arms control agreements along with his administration’s plans to modernize U.S. nuclear arsenal, is inimical to the premise of both regional and universal disarmament. For the first time since President Truman, a U.S. president has so blatantly dismissed the premise of reducing nuclear arsenals.

In today’s world, sober political analysts now agree that possession of nuclear weapons—once an assurance of security—barely does anything to protect countries from threats and insecurities. Hence, further modernization of nuclear armaments will only serve to undermine the peace and stability of this planet. It will also push the world toward a cataclysmic great powers conflict that is so reminiscent of the outdated Cold War mentality.

The difference, however, is that in the context of the Cold War, the polarized international politics and the constant threats of nuclear annihilation focused peace efforts increasingly on law and adjudication. The NPT was one such conspicuous result. In contrast, the “withdrawal doctrine” of the Trump administration is pushing the world to the brink of a new nuclear arms race. Nothing endangers the planet more than nuclear weapons. Only a renewed effort to negotiate nuclear disarmament and non-proliferation agreements can reduce this urgent threat.

*Hossein Mousavian
is a Middle East Security and Nuclear Policy Specialist at Princeton University and a former spokesman for Iran’s nuclear negotiators. His book, The Iranian Nuclear Crisis: A Memoir, was published in 2012 by the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace. His latest book, Iran and the United States: An Insider’s view on the Failed Past and the Road to Peace was released in May 2014.

Wednesday, November 14, 2018

Nuclear Arms Race in the Region Further Exposes US Hypocrisy

By: Kayhan Int’l 

    

An arms race, especially between neighbours with an unending record of hostility that has seen three devastating wars, is a horrifying idea.
What if the two belligerents possess nuclear weapons and are not members of the NPT (Non Proliferation Treaty) to keep under check and control their unbridled ambitions?
The immediate answer could be "destructive”, but on second thoughts the better word to describe such a situation would be "deterrence”, or more properly "balance of terror” – as was the term used to describe US-USSR relations during the Cold War.
The adversaries in question here are not super powers, but India and Pakistan, the two regional states, whose policies are based on military competition to deter the other from gaining the upper hand and turning into a practical threat.
Recently, when India claimed on November 5 that it had succeeded in launching its first nuclear-powered submarine, Pakistan wasted no time in announcing its intention.
What Mohammad Faisal, the foreign ministry spokesman in Islamabad said was not a mere bluster, but indication of things to come in the arms race between the two rivals of the Subcontinent.
He said: "No one should doubt Pakistan’s resolve and capabilities to meet the challenge posed by the latest developments.”
It means, Pakistan, apprehensive that the latest Indian move could disturb the delicate military balance between the nuclear-armed neighbours, is already secretly engaged in a similar project that might soon assume practical proportions – given Islamabad’s close ties to Beijing, which in turn has a cold attitude towards New Delhi.
It should be recalled that twenty years ago in 1998, when India carried out a series of successful nuclear blasts from May 11 to 13, Pakistan promptly came out with its own explosive answer by triggering at least five nuclear blasts on May 28.
This time, though India which has of late developed close ties with the US, holds the upper hand in economy compared to Pakistan’s dire financial situation, the monetary and military means at the latter’s disposal to maintain the weapons balance at any cost, should not be ruled out.
If China accounts for most of Pakistan’s weapons needs, Saudi Arabia is known to grant it blank petro-dollar cheques running into billions of dollars.
Thus, since the two countries, according to experts, have an estimated stockpile of roughly 150 nuclear warheads, Pakistan can ill afford to let India take the edge through its nuclear-powered submarine.
Moreover, in view of India’s plans to build two more such submarines as sequels to its first one named "Arihant”, for completing a "triad” that would give it the ability to deliver nuclear payloads from land, air and sea, Pakistan might borrow a deterrent from China, if it hasn’t completed its own version.
Leasing out a nuclear submarine is nothing new. In the past, Moscow had leased a nuclear sub to New Delhi, which means Beijing might already be in the process of leasing one to Islamabad on a temporary basis.
Whatever the speculations, an arms race between the two nuclear armed neighbours is not even alarming but speaks of the hypocrisy of the big powers, as far as their proxies are concerned.
The fueling of a nuclear weapons race is a dangerous development and threat to the security of the entire region, but when double standards are in vogue, even at the UN, a blind eye is turned to catastrophes in the making (similar to the case of the nuclear armed Zionist entity), while hypocrites in Washington try to mislead the world by imposing sanctions and crying hoarse over Iran’s IAEA-attested peaceful atomic project and Tehran’s right to upgrade its conventional ballistic missile defence capabilities.