Showing posts with label JAWAHARLAL NEHRU. Show all posts
Showing posts with label JAWAHARLAL NEHRU. Show all posts

Monday, September 30, 2019

An Important History Lesson for Mainstream Indian and Pakistani Mainstream Politicians

 
India agreed to hold a free and impartial plebiscite in the state. At a mass public rally in Srinagar in 1948, Nehru, with the towering Sheikh Mohammad Abdullah by his side, solemnly promised to hold a plebiscite under United Nations auspices.
Sheikh Mohammad Abdullah’s ascendancy received vituperative opposition not just from royalist elements, but also from Ladakh’s Tibetan Buddhists who were apprehensive about the sudden rise of a new Kashmiri Muslim elite and were particularly fearful of the implications of its land reform policies for the Buddhist clergy’s enormous private land-holdings in Ladakh. As the elected head of government Abdullah
“pushed through a set of major reforms, the most important of which was the “land to the tiller” legislation, which destroyed the power of the landlords, most of whom were non-Muslims. They were allowed to keep a maximum of 20 acres, provided they worked on the land themselves: 188,775 acres were transferred to 153,399 peasants, while the government organized collective farming on 90,000 acres. A law was passed prohibiting the sale of land to non-Kashmiris, thus preserving the basic topography of the region.”
The new economic plan of the state, formulated and executed by Abdullah’s government, underlined cooperative enterprise as opposed to malignant competition, in keeping with Abdullah’s socialist politics, which implied the organization and control of marketing and trade by the state. This revolutionary economic agenda in a hitherto feudal economy enabled the abolition of landlordism, allocation of land to the tiller, cooperative guilds of peasants, people’s control of forests, organized and planned cultivation of land, the development of sericulture, pisciculture and fruit orchards, and the utilization of forest and mineral wealth for the betterment of the populace. Tillers were assured of the right to work on the land without incurring the wrath of exploitative creditors, and were guaranteed material, social and health benefits (Korbel [1954] 2002: 204). These measures signaled the end of the chapter of peasant exploitation and subservience, and opened a new chapter of peasant emancipation.
Sheikh Abdullah’s unsurpassed achievement during his years as the prime minister of J & K from 1948 to 1953 was the abolition of the exploitative feudal system in the agrarian economy. He was also responsible for the eradication of monarchical rule. A.M. Diakov, a Soviet specialist on India, wrote about the progressive and democratic policies adopted by Abdullah’s National Conference (NC):
“After the Second World War, a national movement in Kashmir developed the program of doing away with the Maharaja, of turning Kashmir into a democratic republic, of giving to the people of Kashmir the right of self-determination.”
The Dogra monarchy was formally abolished in 1952, and the last monarch’s heir apparent, Karan Singh, was declared the titular head of state. Disregarding the attempts of the Indian government to ratify its authority in J & K, the UN Security Council passed a resolution in March 1951 reminding the governments and authorities concerned of the premises of the Security Council resolutions of 21 April 1948, 3 June 1948 and 14 March 1950, and the United Nations (UN) Commission for India and Pakistan resolutions of 13 August 1948 and 5 January 1949, according to which a final decision about the status of the state would be made in accordance with the wishes of its people expressed in a free and fair referendum held under the impartial auspices of the UN.
This resolution also determined that the convening of a Constituent Assembly as recommended by the general council of the “All Jammu and Kashmir National Conference,” and any decision that the Assembly might take and attempt to execute determining the political affiliation of the entire state or any part thereof, would be considered as not in accordance with the above principles and would therefore be disregarded .
When Sheikh Abdullah first voiced his unrelenting opposition to autocratic rule in the state, his political stance was applauded by some sections of the Indian press, which, by foregrounding his position, further brought it out of the catacombs of provincialism:
“It is imperialism’s game to disrupt the great democratic movement led by the NC. . . . There is no doubt that the NC would defeat these disruptive efforts by placing in the forefront the issue of ending the present autocratic regime and establishing a fully democratic government in accordance with its program.” (Communist, October 1947, quoted in Krishen 1951: 3–4)
Despite the injunction of the Security Council, Abdullah and his organization convened a Constituent Assembly in 1951. The NC regime was faced with unstinting opposition in the Hindu-dominated southern and southeastern districts of the Jammu region. Disgruntled elements comprising officials in the former maharaja’s administration who had been divested of their authority by the installation of a democratic regime in the state, and Hindu landlords stripped of their despotism by the NC administration’s populist land reforms, founded an organization called the Praja Parishad in late 1947, which was at loggerheads with Abdullah’s regime since 1949 (see Bose 1997: 104–64).
Despite all the odds, Sheikh Mohammad Abdullah sought to maintain Kashmir’s autonomous status. Tariq Ali makes an astute observation regarding Abdullah’s locus standi:
If Sheikh Abdullah had allied himself with Pakistan, the Indian government and its troops would have been unpleasantly disarmed. But he considered the political and social ideologies of the Muslim League extremely conservative and was afraid that if Kashmir acceded to Pakistan, the Punjabi feudal lords who were at the helm of the ship of policy making in the Muslim League would hamper political and social progress. In order to prevent such an occurrence, Abdullah agreed to support the Indian military presence in the State provided under United Nations auspices in J & K.
The purportedly autonomous status of J & K under Abdullah’s government provoked the ire of the Hindu nationalist parties, which sought the unequivocal integration of the state into the Indian Union.
The unitary concept of nationalism that these organizations subscribed to challenged the basic principle that the nation was founded on, namely, democracy. In such a nationalist project, one of the forms that the nullification of past and present histories takes is the subjection of religious minorities to a centralized and authoritarian state buttressed by nostalgia of a “glorious past.”
The unequivocal aim of the supporters of the integration of J & K into the Indian Union was to expunge the political autonomy endowed on the state by India’s constitutional provisions.
According to the unitary discourse of sovereignty disseminated by the Hindu nationalists, J & K was not entitled to the signifiers of statehood – a prime minister, flag and constitution. The concept of nationalism constructed by Hindu nationalists bred relentless violence and the delusions of militant nationalisms, which is exactly what is happening now.

Monday, July 01, 2019

Kashmiris Victims of Indian State Terrorism

Despite Indian nationalist claims, Kashmir has never been part of India

Ibrahim Vawda

Palestinians are being killed in the hundreds by the militarized terrorists of the Zionist Israeli regime and the illegal Egyptian regime that has ensconced itself in power in Cairo. Palestinian properties and land worth billions of dollars are confiscated for future illegal Zionist settlement construction.
On the other hand, India kills Kashmiris as part of its sadistic strategy to silence them for seeking independence from Indian colonization. India invaded and annexed Kashmir in October 1947. The Indian Colonial forces have killed more than one million Kashmiris since. The occupation army’s thirst for Kashmiri blood remains unquenched.
China is the third nuclear power that controls a part of Kashmir. Having veto power in the UN Security Council and having done very little to secure peace in the region, makes China complicit in the human rights violations in Jammu and Kashmir. Pakistan, having given partial sovereignty to Azad (free) Kashmir, insists on a plebiscite (referendum), as promised by India’s first Prime Minister Jawaharlal Nehru, to determine the future of Jammu and Kashmir. There are at least 18 UN Security Council resolutions calling for a referendum that India had agreed to in the beginning but has since reneged on its pledge.
Indian rulers insist that Kashmir is part of India although in its constitution, Kashmir is accorded special status (Articles 135 and 370). The current Hindu fascist regime led by Narendra Modi has vowed to remove these articles from the constitution to prepare the way for total annexation of Kashmir into India. Kashmir was never a part of India. It was an independent state for 5,000 years.
India uses “terrorism” as a pretext to terrorize the Kashmiris. In fact much of the firing across the Line of Control (LoC) is used solely for this purpose.
India refuses to admit that Kashmir was invaded and annexed with the help of the then Hindu ruler of Kashmir, Maharaja Hari Singh. He had already fled the state capital Srinagar because of a popular mass uprising against his oppressive rule and dithering over not joining Pakistan as the people demanded. India touts the “Instrument of Accession” that the fleeing ruler allegedly signed with India as justification for its troops to invade and colonize Kashmir. India has never produced that “Instrument of Accession’.” Instead, Indian rulers in the past admitted that it was a provisional arrangement and once calm was restored, India would respect the wishes of the Kashmiri people.
Nehru made this pledge publicly on several occasions starting in October 1947 and repeated in telegrams to Pakistani Prime Minister Liaquat Ali Khan as well as broadcast on Indian radio. The same pledge was made to the United Nations Security Council. In fact, when war broke out between India and Pakistan, it was India that took the matter to the UN Security Council in January 1948 to secure a ceasefire. It again pledged that once calm was restored, India would hold a referendum under international supervision such as the UN to determine the wishes of the people.
Nehru and his cohorts were clearly playing for time. They got that once both countries — India and Pakistan — agreed to a ceasefire. The Security Council resolution also called for the withdrawal of the bulk of both countries’ forces to be followed by a referendum. While the ceasefire went into effect and that is where the current Line of Control in Kashmir is, India deliberately ignored and sabotaged the other two provisions of the resolution.
Acknowledging a problem is the first step to solving it. Even many Indians would agree.
In its efforts to change the demographic composition of Kashmir, India continues on its genocidal path of simply killing the indigenous population of Kashmir, calling them “terrorists” and “insurgents.”
Several secret mass-graves have been uncovered in Kashmir. Obviously these contain the remains of Kashmiris who protested India’s human rights violations. They were kidnapped, tortured, and murdered by the Indian colonial army.
Like Israel on the Palestine freedom issue, Delhi has taken it for granted that Kashmir should not be resolved so as to keep it an unsettled problem. In fact, India would like to project the notion that Kashmiris are happy under India’s murderous occupation and there is no need for any settlement beyond maintaining the status quo.
India refuses to discuss the Kashmir question with a third party or intermediary. It demands it will only talk to Pakistan if the latter admits to harboring “terrorists” and “facilitating the infiltration of insurgents” into Kashmir from Pakistan.
India remains in perpetual denial and claims the status of “terror victim,” like the apartheid regime of Israel. India has joined the US and Israel as part of the new axis of evil. It hopes to ride out any criticism, like the Zionist regime, of its murderous policy against the Kashmiris.
Virtuous talk of unity in diversity and secularism have been replaced by bareknuckled Hindu nationalism. The state, colonized by a fascist ideological movement, is emerging triumphant over the civilian population. It has assumed vast powers of control — telling people what they should eat at home and how they should behave in public, and whom to lynch.
There is no doubt that the Kashmiris have suffered immensely for more than seven decades. They are being tortured not merely to obtain false confessions but to break their self-esteem, dignity and self-image. The Indian military and intelligence services continue to indulge in terror to create mayhem in Kashmiri communities. India has turned on the civilians with a vengeance and harsh malevolent behavior. Rape is used as an instrument of war. More than 11,000 Kashmiri women and girls have been raped since 1989. These are well documented and were even reported in the UN Human Rights Commission of June 14, 2018. To India’s lasting shame, not one person has been arrested much less prosecuted for such heinous crimes.
This hardline approach embraced by Hindu religious fanatics confirms that the world as we have known it, molded by the heirs of both Western imperialism and anti-imperialist nationalism, is crumbling. Countries and people that genuinely believe in human dignity and honor should take the lead in helping the colonised nations to gain freedom from the clutches of foreign occupation.
Ibrahim Vawda works for the Johannesburg-based Media Review Network.

Monday, January 07, 2019

Could India Have Remained an Undivided Country?


(L to R) Pandit Jawaharlal Nehru, Lord Mountbatten and Mohammad Ali Jinnah
by 

It would be a silly question indeed to ask why December 25th is celebrated.  On the other hand, one could ask why it is a national holiday in Pakistan, for it is not because it’s Christmas.  By an unusual coincidence it happens to be the birthday of Muhammad Ali Jinnah, the founding father of the country.  Exactly how Pakistan came into being is an interesting story as it also leads to the question whether the dismemberment of the Indian subcontinent — now three countries — could have been averted.
 
Jinnah started out as a voice for Hindu-Muslim unity, although wary of majoritarianism and Hindu domination.  A highly successful lawyer with patrician tastes, he was averse to mob violence and wanted constitutional independence — the British handing over to an elected Indian government and a constitution safeguarding the rights of minorities.
 
The first step was to seek Dominion status in which Indians would run their own affairs although subject to control by the British government.  Accordingly a London conference was convened.  The Round Table Conference began in grand style on November 30, 1930 with a plenary session at the House of Lords;  after which the participants retired to St. James Palace for the talks.
 
Hindu and Muslim members sought first to agree on a united front.  His Highness The Aga Khan was leading the delegation and also spoke for the Muslims.  Sir Chimanlal Setalvad, a prominent Hindu member, has written that the Aga Khan agreed to the Hindu demand for joint electorates, instead of separate Hindu and Muslim ones, but with the reservation of seats for Muslims, and he added magnanimously, “In that event you lead and we follow.”  Jaswant Singh describes (p. 178) what transpired in his excellent book, “Jinnah: India — Partition, Independence.”   Unfortunately the Hindu members receptive to the proposal were intimidated by the others and the Hindu Mahasaba (p. 179, ibid.), the precursor of the nationalist Hindutva movement.  Prime Minister Modi’s Bharataya Janata Party (BJP) has a Hindu nationalist fervor which has unmasked the BJP that was in power with Jaswant Singh as Foreign Minister.
 
Without a united front, the Round Table Conference was doomed.  The seeds of Pakistan had been sown, and as Jinnah repeatedly confronted majoritarianism devoid of any assurances for Muslims, his demands for Pakistan became more implacable.
 
The last chance for one India arrived in 1946 with the Cabinet Mission.  Field Marshal Viscount Archibald Percival Wavell served as Viceroy of India from 1943 to early 1947.  Lord Wavell hosted the Mission and served as a link to the parties i.e. Jinnah of the Muslim League and Nehru of the Congress Party.  The somewhat ingenious plan devised coalesced the provinces into four groups, the western provinces (now Pakistan), the east, the center and the south.  The first two were Muslim majority, the latter two Hindu.  The individual provinces would elect members to a group constituent assembly which would then select representatives for the central government in Delhi.  Equal Hindu and Muslim groups ensured reasonable parity in Delhi.
 
The interim government in Delhi that Wavell had in mind would consist of a council of twelve (p. 207, ibid.):  five from the Muslim League, five from Congress, one Sikh and one Dalit.  In accepting the plan and therefore less, Jinnah was putting his demand for Pakistan at risk.  The gesture was unappreciated for with each letter and each communication with Congress, Wavell’s original parity suffered dilution.  Moreover, Nehru even rejected the Cabinet Mission’s grouping plan claiming clearly falsely that, the “entire country is opposed” to it (p. 379, ibid.).
 
In the end there were fourteen members of the council without parity for Muslims.  The plan was formally rejected by the Muslim League on July 27, 1946 (p. 382, ibid.).  The era of a constitutional path to independence was over.   Jinnah and the Muslim League had tired of Nehru’s repeated shifts on positions critical to Muslim interests.
 
Thus the call for Direct Action.  The demonstrations began on August 16, 1946, and the confrontations led to riots leading to killings.  The British government recalled Wavell in February 1947.  Lord Mountbatten of Burma took over, and a precipitate rush to independence followed.  Group enmities resulted in a mania of  killing as Muslims fleeing violence in the new India and Hindus and Sikhs the same in Pakistan fled towards the borders without protection.  Over two million lost their lives before the cataclysm ended.  And occasional spasms still erupt such as the 2002 killings of Muslims in Gujarat during Modi’s rule plus numerous other incidents.

The leftovers include the continuing troubles in Indian Kashmir and the frequent blinding of the young during demonstrations.  The security forces eschew rubber bullets for pellet loaded shotguns.  The decades-long insurgency has cost the lives of up to 100,000 Kashmiris.
 
The two countries have fought four wars.  In the first, Pakistan wrested control of a third of Kashmir from India after the Maharaja seceded the state to India against the wishes of an overwhelming majority of his people.  In the third war, India repaid Pakistan in kind paving the way for East Pakistan to become the new country of Bangladesh.  The other two wars ended in the status quo ante.  If there is another war, the world could face a nuclear winter — about 300 nuclear weapons in the two countries are trained on each other.
 
What a price to pay for majoritarianism!  In the meantime, the new Modi government with its Hindu nationalist agenda and continuing contempt for secularism  — even centuries-old place names are being changed — confirms the fears of the Muslim minority, justifying their course of action during that fateful summer of 1946. 
Arshad M. Khan is a former professor who has, over many years, written occasionally for the print and often for online media outlets.