Showing posts with label Hayy Yaqzan. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Hayy Yaqzan. Show all posts

Friday, August 02, 2019

Financiers of the Islamophobia Industry

All money trails lead to Israel

Hayy Yaqzan
It has been a great start to the summer as Islamophobes in Europe and North America continue to get dragged through the mud. On June 13, a US judge ruled that the publisher of The Daily Stormer, a neo-Nazi fake news site, must pay a Muslim comedian $4.1 million for falsely portraying him as a terrorist. Two days later, a UK judge declared that The Daily Mail, a notoriously Islamophobic site, owes an apology and £120,000 to the Palestinian charity Interpal for claiming that it was a terrorist organization.
However, as discussed in the previous article in this series on Islamophobia, these moments of success only scratch the surface of a complex global industry.
A prominent but sometimes forgotten stakeholder in the Islamophobia industry is Israel, both through its own policies and through the powerful Zionist lobby in the US. Israel’s influence on the spread of anti-Muslim bigotry is joined at the hip with its efforts to suppress pro-Palestinian scholarship and advocacy. A 2015 report by the International Jewish anti-Zionist Network (IJAN) found that Israel and its supporters had pumped over $300 million into Islamophobic, anti-Arab, and anti-Palestinian efforts at the time. Hatem Bazian, a lecturer at UC Berkeley and a prominent researcher on Islamophobia, has estimated that about 70% of Islamophobia funding in the US comes from Zionist sources.
Exploring and exposing the way this process works is very difficult, as the entire scheme relies on secrecy from the general public. One Canadian professor at the University of Lethbridge learned this the hard way in 2018. In 2016, Anthony Hall — a tenured professor who had taught Native American studies, liberal education, and globalization for 26 years — found himself suspended without pay for suggesting that there was a Zionist connection to 9/11 and that it is important to think critically about the narrative of the Holocaust. B’nai Brith Canada had jumped on the case and pressured the university to remove Hall, but he was reinstated in 2017. In June 2018, he apparently went too far: he said that the Zionists were funding Islamophobia. B’nai Brith again raised the alarm, and this time Hall was seemingly pressured into retirement by August.
It is precisely these extraordinary efforts to silence anyone who tries to trace Islamophobia to the Zionist lobby that should raise eyebrows about just how deep of a relationship this is. And this is why the contents of IJAN’s report are so important.
The main offenders identified in the report, titled The Business of Backlash: The Attack on the Palestinian Movement and Other Movements for Justice, were 11 donors whose foundations (not including their private wealth) are collectively worth over $10 billion. Many of them fund Islamophobia through the donor-advised funds discussed in previous Crescent articles, as an effort to make it difficult to trace their contributions back to them. And most of them could clearly benefit from stirring up negative views of Muslims, and they have invested heavily in oil and weapons technology.
One of the Zionist contributors are the Koch Brothers. Fred C. Koch was a US chemical engineer and entrepreneur who, in 1927, found an efficient way to refine oil into gasoline. This led to him setting up his own oil refinery. However, in 1929, it became known that Fred and his partner, a former employee of Universal Oil Products, had only made minor tweaks to Universal’s existing process and claimed it as their own.
Embarrassed in the US, Koch entered a market that his competitors in the US were reluctant to support: Soviet Russia under Stalin’s brutal regime. This kept Koch afloat as he built up his business in the US, ready to sacrifice anything for money. His eldest son, Frederick, was all but ostracized from the family for his interest in studying theatre, and his sons have said that their mother lived in fear of their father.
Charles and David Koch: not as erudite as they look in their carefully choreographed images. Among the wealthiest billionaires in the US, they too acquired their fortune through fraud, trickery, and extortion. They shield their contributions to the Islamophobia network by providing the seed capital for donor-advised funds.
After Koch’s death in 1967, his sons fought bitter legal battles to control the business, and eventually two of them, Charles and David, succeeded (their brother Bill Koch has called them “the biggest crooks in the oil industry”). They expanded into other ventures, and today they own $115 billion in assets and Koch Industries is the second-largest privately-held company in the US (as of 2015). Koch Industries controls at least four oil refineries, six ethanol plants, a natural-gas-fired power plant, and 4,000 miles of pipeline. At one point, it was producing 5% of all oil burned in the US and also producing billions of pounds of petrochemicals, inserting itself into the production of everything from fertilizers and the plywood sold at Home Depot to Angel Soft toilet paper and Apple’s iPhones.
In addition to being one of the top 30 polluters in the US and repeatedly showing no concern for the health of residents in the areas they work in, Koch Industries is a major contributor to the Donors Capital Fund (discussed in the previous article), which they know funnels their money to Islamophobic and anti-Palestinian projects. These include the Clarion Project, the David Horowitz Freedom Center, Stand With Us, the Israel Law Centre (which defends illegal Israeli squatters and war criminals), and more.
The Kochs must certainly be aware of where their donations are going, though publicly they put on the mask of progressive views and criticism of Israel. In May 2016, for example, they invited notoriously anti-Israel pundits to the Charles Koch Institute’s conference, even as they were funneling money to Zionist enablers and likely exploring the options for their first major ($150 million) investment in Israel, which came just a year later. It is important to note that the Koch family are not of Jewish or Israeli background; they are Christian Zionists of Dutch descent.
Another of the 11 major Zionist funders of the Islamophobic and anti-Palestinian machine is the Sheldon Adelson Family Foundation. In May of 2017, Sheldon Adelson owned $36.7 billion in assets. He owns Las Vegas Sands, the largest casino company in the world. The Adelsons’ contributions are focused mostly on pro-Israel efforts, particularly sending young American Jews on fully-paid “birthright” trips to Israel. However, they also support more general Islamophobic organizations, including the American Islamic Congress, the Endowment for Middle East Truth, and the Middle East Media Research Institute (MEMRI).
Adelson has also given as much as $250,000 to the Counterterrorism and Security Education and Research Foundation (CTSERF), which is yet another Islamophobic think tank. And in case this does not make it clear enough, he has also openly said that “all Muslims are terrorists.” He has also supported current presidential candidate Tulsi Gabbard, a supporter of Indian PM Narendra Modi and his virulently Islamophobic rhetoric. She has also spoken about “radical Islamic ideology” and countries with “Islamic extremist” populations, and Adelson has stood by her despite — or perhaps, because of — all this.
There is much more to discuss on this topic, so this will continue in upcoming articles. It is important to point out here that the many links between Islamophobic and anti-Palestinian efforts is one more reason why the Palestinian struggle for justice should be a pressing concern for all Muslims. Those who enable and maintain the illegal colonization of Palestine are often the same people who are sending harassment and even violent right-wing extremists to our doorsteps, such as recent shootings in masjids in Quebec and New Zealand.

Saturday, June 01, 2019

Islamophobia’s Financiers

Cut the funding and the useful idiots go away

Hayy Yaqzan 
There has recently been a flurry of activity aimed at shutting down right-wing extremists’ access to public spaces, where they spread hateful rhetoric and then cry “free speech.” In early March, the Canadian government announced a special fund that enabled UOIT, a prominent Canadian university, to research right-wing extremism in the country. In April, Facebook banned multiple popular pages on its platform that were used to spread hateful views, and on the same day the UK government announced a plan to fine or block websites promoting bigotry.
These are all helpful steps, but they are only scratching the surface. Right-wing extremists, who generally figure prominently in the Islamophobia industry, are not simply a hodgepodge of “lone wolf” actors but part of a complex, organized, and well-funded network crisscrossing Europe and North America and inspiring horrific violence around the world.
The hierarchy of the Islamophobia industry can be broken down into the following categories. First there are the funders, those who are eager to invest in spreading hatred and fear but are not capable or interested in doing the “dirty work” themselves. For this they fund the next category, the misinformation experts — people like Daniel Pipes or Robert Spencer who masquerade as “experts” on Islam and present their work as “research.”
Next come the activists, such as Pamela Geller, the poor souls who can’t even pretend to have any understanding of Islam or Muslims and simply amplify the nonsense produced by the misinformation experts. Then there are the validators, the “Muslims” like Tarek Fatah or Maajid Nawaz who lend credence to Islamophobic messages from “the inside.” And finally, there is the echo chamber, including the media, politicians, religious leaders, and grassroots organizations, which actively spread Islamophobia into mainstream society.
Understanding the dynamics of this industry are important for any person or movement making an effort to dismantle it. And the best place to start is in the first category: the funders. These are crucial because those doing the “dirty work” are often low-lives who have no respectable or even sustainable career and little to no means to support themselves. They rely on wealthy patrons to help them in everything from paying their bills to defending themselves in lawsuits and being bailed out of prison.
In recent years they have also begun to rely on crowdfunding and other means of support. This author recently came across one case of a loud and proud Islamophobe living in his girlfriend’s basement. However, large-scale funding continues to drive the industry.
According to a comprehensive report published in 2011 by the Center for American Progress (CAP), the top donors to the Islamophobia industry in the US specifically were the Donors Capital Fund, the Richard Mellon Scaife foundations, the Lynde and Harry Bradley Foundation, the Newton D. and Rochelle F. Becker foundations and charitable trust, the Russell Barrie Foundation, the Anchorage Charitable Foundation and William Rosenwald Family Foundation, and the Fairbrook Foundation. These names may not mean much to many Muslims and their non-Muslim allies, but considering that they collectively put more than $42.5 million into spreading Islamophobia in the first decade of the 21st century, these are names that cannot be ignored.
In his groundbreaking 2012 book The Islamophobia Industry, researcher Nathan Lean built on the findings of the CAP report to provide an example of how the Islamophobia industry can function, especially the flow of funding within it. In 2008, a 77-minute documentary titled Obsession: Radical Islam’s War Against the West was released. Some of the “stars” of this production included Daniel Pipes, Alan Dershowitz, and Steven Emerson, and it was produced by an Israeli-Canadian rabbi, Raphael Shore. While these “dirty workers” may have been proud of their role in the film, the funders were clearly very reluctant to have their names attached to it; one wonders why. The executive producer of the film, Peter Mier, provided 80% of the film’s $400,000 budget. But that is an alias, not his actual name, just like the “name” of the production manager, Brett Halperin.
Distribution of the film was led by the Clarion Project (known at the time as the Clarion Fund), another sketchy organization, of which Raphael Shore just happens to be a founder. The Clarion Project’s “office” in Manhattan is empty; the building in which it is housed is designed to offer a “virtual” official space, complete with an address and phone number, for a mere $79 per month. Shore’s actual office is in Jerusalem, as he leads a number of Zionist initiatives, some of which are clearly right-wing to the extreme.
Using his connections, Shore promoted Obsession in various ways, including billboards, flying banners, and screenings at universities. His efforts were picked up by Christian Zionists, who distributed it among their congregations, and the Endowment for Middle East Truth (EMET), which made it a mission to distribute the movie “to every single congressional office” — an effort that failed spectacularly.
All of this paled in comparison to the Clarion Project’s next move, which came in 2008, just two months before the presidential election. Some 28 million copies of the film were distributed in swing states through special supplements of 74 newspapers, including prominent ones such as the New York Times. This effort to spread Islamophobia (and try to illegally influence the US election), and the other promotions for Obsession before it, cost an estimated $17 million.
Where was all of this money coming from? The Clarion Project remained tight-lipped about giving away any names. Some years later, a Salon journalist came across a document submitted to the IRS by the Clarion Project, which showed that a donor named “Barry Seid” had donated nearly $17 million in 2008. “Barry Seid” did not exist (or match), but Barre Seid, a Chicago millionaire, certainly did. Seid’s assistant denied any donations or links to the Clarion Project, and he could conveniently do so because of the shroud of secrecy offered by the Donors Capital Fund (DCF).
The Donors Capital Fund, you will recall, was the top funder of Islamophobic “dirty work” listed in the CAP report. It is a “donor-advised fund,” meaning that donors can make an account (which requires a minimum investment of $1 million) and instruct the fund to donate a certain amount on their behalf, thus protecting their own identity. In 2009, the DCF disbursed nearly $60 million in funding to mainstream, non-Islamophobic conservative groups, creating an overall clean record in the midst of which, between 2007 and 2009, $21 million could be funneled to Islamophobic groups. This included the generous donation of $17 million from one anonymous donor — possibly Barre Seid, the owner of a business that produces surge protectors — that went to the Clarion Project, just when it was needed to promote Obsession.
This is just one example of an Islamophobic project, and the focus is only on funding. The purpose here is to remind the reader that while the “useful idiots” at the front lines of the Islamophobia industry (that is, on Twitter, at protests, in far-right rallies, etc.) are certainly harmful to the Muslim community and society at large, they are only the tip of the iceberg. Any serious effort to counteract Islamophobia will require us to understand every aspect of this industry, as we will continue to do in upcoming articles, insha’ Allah.