Showing posts with label Islamophobia Industry. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Islamophobia Industry. Show all posts

Tuesday, September 10, 2019

Exposing the Origins of Islamophobia

All roads lead to the security of the Zionist cancer in the Holy Land
Hayy Yaqzan
In 1979, a symposium was organized in Jerusalem by the Jonathan Institute, headed by one Benjamin Netanyahu. Influential political leaders from across the world were invited to Jerusalem to discuss “terrorism” as the new global threat. Netanyahu had founded the Jonathan Institute, “a private foundation dedicated to the study of terrorism,” in 1977, and named after his late brother.
The 1979 conference was the Jonathan Institute’s first foray into trying to shape the definition of “terrorism” to serve Israeli interests, and among those who came to get their instructions were George H.W. Bush (Bush Sr.) and several high-level European officials. Richard Pipes, father of the notorious Islamophobe Daniel Pipes, was also in the crowd.
There was little effort at this first conference to start the mental gymnastics of stringing together Islam and terrorism. While many speakers denigrated Palestinians and Arabs, there was only one overt mention of “Islamic terrorism.” However, in 1984, a follow-up conference was organized, this time in Washington, DC. Many scholars have argued that this is where the Islamophobia project as we know it today was launched.
This time, the crafty Netanyahu said in his opening remarks that modern terrorism had its roots in “communist totalitarianism and Islamic (and Arab) radicalism.” The success in 1979 of the Islamic Revolution in Iran had certainly convinced this cult, in the five years since the previous conference, to speed up their process of conjuring up the Muslim boogeyman. To do this, they sought the help of the orientalist so-called scholars Bernard Lewis and Elie Kedourie. These two helpfully explained that to claim the existence of “Christian terrorism” and “Jewish terrorism” was inappropriate, but “Muslim terrorism” was certainly real because “Islam is a political religion” and “Muhammad founded a state and governed it.”
The 1984 conference made it clear that the US would lead in defining and dismantling “Islamic terrorism” around the world. But it is important to remember where this entire initiative began. As scholars such as Deepa Kumar have suggested, Israel had started to realize by the mid-1970s that the best way to sustain and justify its inhumane treatment of Palestinians was to use the smokescreen of a global Islamic threat. “By the late-1980s and the early-1990s it did, therefore, appear as if Israel was locked into an overarching battle with the Islamic world,” wrote Fred Halliday in his Islam and the Myth of Confrontation. Israel’s key weapon in this battle was misinformation about Islam and Muslims — the fuel for Islamophobia — and its key objective was (and is) to keep the winds of public opinion in the West blowing in Israel’s favour.
The results have been spectacular. According to Sarah Marusek of the University of Leeds, of the 60 known leading US charities or foundations that fund the Islamophobia industry, the data clearly indicates that 45 of these also finance organizations that directly support Israel’s colonization of Palestine (particularly by funding Zionist colonies), generously giving almost $169 million just between 2009 and 2013.
As discussed in the previous article in this Crescent series on Islamophobia, Zionists have thus been some of the leading funders of the Islamophobia industry. But before returning to our effort to familiarize ourselves with some of the sickening people involved in this game, let us turn to one very important component of it: the sayanim.
The Hebrew word sayanim (sing. sayan) refers to “helpers.” These are Zionists who do not necessarily have the means to fund Islamophobia on a large scale, but have achieved influential positions in US, Canadian, and European societies from which they can support the Islamophobia industry, especially when they cooperate among themselves. As the pro-Palestinian activist Paul Larudee has explained, “for example, friendly journalists can work with lobbyists and others to quickly and massively spread influence, information, analysis, and disinformation that are useful to Israel.”
And as Telegraph reporter Gordon Thomas has written about their role in Israel’s assassinations, “In practical terms, a sayan who runs a car rental agency will provide [the assassin] with a vehicle on a no-questions basis. An estate agent sayan will provide a building for surveillance. A bank manager sayan will provide funds at any time of day or night, and a sayan doctor provides medical assistance.”

Larudee notes that “that there are as many as 4,000 sayanim in each of the major centers of power and influence, such as London and New York. A concentration of sayanim in important sectors of society that inform the public, such as film, entertainment, journalism, education and social media permits them to help shape public opinion.” These “helpers” thus run the “Brand Israel” campaign, continuing to build a positive image of Israel through the media and, for good measure, demonizing and vilifying the Muslims.
A good example of the significant influence even non-donors can have on promoting Israeli interests is that of Mark Zuckerberg, co-founder and CEO of Facebook. In 2016, Zuckerberg privately met with Netanyahu, and shortly afterward news broke that “the Israeli government and Zuckerberg have agreed to work together to determine how to tackle incitement on the social media network.” Zuckerberg even hired a long-time advisor of Netanyahu and former chief of staff at the Israeli embassy in Washington, DC to be in charge of censoring “fake news” on Facebook. The outrageous conflict of interest in this case was tossed out the window, and it was considered acceptable that the leading source of news for millions of people around the world should have a Zionist as a gatekeeper. Good luck to any positive stories about Palestinians, Arabs, or Muslims!
At the same time, the Israeli lobby tries to decriminalize Islamophobia anywhere it can. France is a good example. In France, you can be arrested for wearing a t-shirt that says “Free Palestine.” This is because “anti-Semitism,” as vaguely and manipulably defined there as it is anywhere else, is illegal, and can get you fined and jailed. However, Islamophobia is free speech, and therefore must be allowed.
The CRIF (the French equivalent of the Israeli lobby group AIPAC) maintains that “Islamophobia is not a form of racism” and that recognizing Islamophobia “would impede all criticism of Islam, such that the fundamental rights of [other] religions could not be respected.” Jacob Cohen, a French researcher, has written about the role of Israeli operatives and French Zionists in promoting Islamophobia in the country — but the only way he could get it published was presenting it as a work of fiction!
It should by now be clear that not only does the present-day Islamophobia industry have its origins in Zionist efforts to continue oppressing the Palestinian people, but that Zionists at all levels of society — not only those with enough money to fund the industry — are doing their part to keep the hate factory running. In the next article in this series, I will return my focus to the big funders of Islamophobia, but the “small fish” should never be ignored, especially because they are the ones against whose day-to-day efforts we are more likely to be effectively put down.

Saturday, June 01, 2019

Islamophobia’s Financiers

Cut the funding and the useful idiots go away

Hayy Yaqzan 
There has recently been a flurry of activity aimed at shutting down right-wing extremists’ access to public spaces, where they spread hateful rhetoric and then cry “free speech.” In early March, the Canadian government announced a special fund that enabled UOIT, a prominent Canadian university, to research right-wing extremism in the country. In April, Facebook banned multiple popular pages on its platform that were used to spread hateful views, and on the same day the UK government announced a plan to fine or block websites promoting bigotry.
These are all helpful steps, but they are only scratching the surface. Right-wing extremists, who generally figure prominently in the Islamophobia industry, are not simply a hodgepodge of “lone wolf” actors but part of a complex, organized, and well-funded network crisscrossing Europe and North America and inspiring horrific violence around the world.
The hierarchy of the Islamophobia industry can be broken down into the following categories. First there are the funders, those who are eager to invest in spreading hatred and fear but are not capable or interested in doing the “dirty work” themselves. For this they fund the next category, the misinformation experts — people like Daniel Pipes or Robert Spencer who masquerade as “experts” on Islam and present their work as “research.”
Next come the activists, such as Pamela Geller, the poor souls who can’t even pretend to have any understanding of Islam or Muslims and simply amplify the nonsense produced by the misinformation experts. Then there are the validators, the “Muslims” like Tarek Fatah or Maajid Nawaz who lend credence to Islamophobic messages from “the inside.” And finally, there is the echo chamber, including the media, politicians, religious leaders, and grassroots organizations, which actively spread Islamophobia into mainstream society.
Understanding the dynamics of this industry are important for any person or movement making an effort to dismantle it. And the best place to start is in the first category: the funders. These are crucial because those doing the “dirty work” are often low-lives who have no respectable or even sustainable career and little to no means to support themselves. They rely on wealthy patrons to help them in everything from paying their bills to defending themselves in lawsuits and being bailed out of prison.
In recent years they have also begun to rely on crowdfunding and other means of support. This author recently came across one case of a loud and proud Islamophobe living in his girlfriend’s basement. However, large-scale funding continues to drive the industry.
According to a comprehensive report published in 2011 by the Center for American Progress (CAP), the top donors to the Islamophobia industry in the US specifically were the Donors Capital Fund, the Richard Mellon Scaife foundations, the Lynde and Harry Bradley Foundation, the Newton D. and Rochelle F. Becker foundations and charitable trust, the Russell Barrie Foundation, the Anchorage Charitable Foundation and William Rosenwald Family Foundation, and the Fairbrook Foundation. These names may not mean much to many Muslims and their non-Muslim allies, but considering that they collectively put more than $42.5 million into spreading Islamophobia in the first decade of the 21st century, these are names that cannot be ignored.
In his groundbreaking 2012 book The Islamophobia Industry, researcher Nathan Lean built on the findings of the CAP report to provide an example of how the Islamophobia industry can function, especially the flow of funding within it. In 2008, a 77-minute documentary titled Obsession: Radical Islam’s War Against the West was released. Some of the “stars” of this production included Daniel Pipes, Alan Dershowitz, and Steven Emerson, and it was produced by an Israeli-Canadian rabbi, Raphael Shore. While these “dirty workers” may have been proud of their role in the film, the funders were clearly very reluctant to have their names attached to it; one wonders why. The executive producer of the film, Peter Mier, provided 80% of the film’s $400,000 budget. But that is an alias, not his actual name, just like the “name” of the production manager, Brett Halperin.
Distribution of the film was led by the Clarion Project (known at the time as the Clarion Fund), another sketchy organization, of which Raphael Shore just happens to be a founder. The Clarion Project’s “office” in Manhattan is empty; the building in which it is housed is designed to offer a “virtual” official space, complete with an address and phone number, for a mere $79 per month. Shore’s actual office is in Jerusalem, as he leads a number of Zionist initiatives, some of which are clearly right-wing to the extreme.
Using his connections, Shore promoted Obsession in various ways, including billboards, flying banners, and screenings at universities. His efforts were picked up by Christian Zionists, who distributed it among their congregations, and the Endowment for Middle East Truth (EMET), which made it a mission to distribute the movie “to every single congressional office” — an effort that failed spectacularly.
All of this paled in comparison to the Clarion Project’s next move, which came in 2008, just two months before the presidential election. Some 28 million copies of the film were distributed in swing states through special supplements of 74 newspapers, including prominent ones such as the New York Times. This effort to spread Islamophobia (and try to illegally influence the US election), and the other promotions for Obsession before it, cost an estimated $17 million.
Where was all of this money coming from? The Clarion Project remained tight-lipped about giving away any names. Some years later, a Salon journalist came across a document submitted to the IRS by the Clarion Project, which showed that a donor named “Barry Seid” had donated nearly $17 million in 2008. “Barry Seid” did not exist (or match), but Barre Seid, a Chicago millionaire, certainly did. Seid’s assistant denied any donations or links to the Clarion Project, and he could conveniently do so because of the shroud of secrecy offered by the Donors Capital Fund (DCF).
The Donors Capital Fund, you will recall, was the top funder of Islamophobic “dirty work” listed in the CAP report. It is a “donor-advised fund,” meaning that donors can make an account (which requires a minimum investment of $1 million) and instruct the fund to donate a certain amount on their behalf, thus protecting their own identity. In 2009, the DCF disbursed nearly $60 million in funding to mainstream, non-Islamophobic conservative groups, creating an overall clean record in the midst of which, between 2007 and 2009, $21 million could be funneled to Islamophobic groups. This included the generous donation of $17 million from one anonymous donor — possibly Barre Seid, the owner of a business that produces surge protectors — that went to the Clarion Project, just when it was needed to promote Obsession.
This is just one example of an Islamophobic project, and the focus is only on funding. The purpose here is to remind the reader that while the “useful idiots” at the front lines of the Islamophobia industry (that is, on Twitter, at protests, in far-right rallies, etc.) are certainly harmful to the Muslim community and society at large, they are only the tip of the iceberg. Any serious effort to counteract Islamophobia will require us to understand every aspect of this industry, as we will continue to do in upcoming articles, insha’ Allah.