Showing posts with label Achievements and Challenges facing Pakistan. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Achievements and Challenges facing Pakistan. Show all posts

Tuesday, November 20, 2018

'Popular sentiment in Pakistan remains sympathetic to Tehran'

Syed Zafar Mehdi
TEHRAN - Imran Khan led government in Pakistan has been in talks with the International Monetary Fund (IMF) to tide over an economic crisis. It has also approached its allies China and Saudi Arabia for funds, which has however raised a few eyebrows at home. It remains to be seen whether Khan will be able to resuscitate the flailing economy without compromising on country’s independent foreign policy and whether he will be able to strike a delicate balance in relations with Saudi Arabia and Iran.
Farrukh K Pitafi is an Islamabad based senior journalist, political analyst and talk show host. With over 20 years of television and print journalism, he is known for his distinct voice on global and local policy issues. In an interview to Tehran Times, Mr. Pitafi speaks about Pakistan’s economic crisis, and Imran Khan-led government’s foreign policy issues.
Following are the excerpts:
Q. Imran Khan has inherited a flailing economy that needs to be revived with funds. Do you believe Khan will be able to tide through this economic crisis?
A: Pakistan is no stranger to economic crises. We have endured many in the past and have always survived them. This too will pass. But history is no excuse for the lack of progress on the economic front. Two economic powerhouses that sit next to Pakistan, China and India, achieved their success in past few decades right before our eyes. So the country has to take a serious look at what ails its economy.
Immediately after assuming the office of Prime Minister Imran Khan constituted a set of taskforces meant to fix the country’s ailing economy. These taskforces include a taskforce on restructuring of civil service, one on austerity and restructuring of government, another on telecommunication. As the country’s priority is macroeconomic stabilization this is a good call to cut wasteful expenditures. Once that is achieved government can look at long term measures.
So far PM Khan’s cabinet choices, team building and list of priorities gives me hope that he can deliver on economy.
Q. After his second visit to Riyadh since taking over as the PM, Khan said he was sad about the Jamal Khashoggi incident but Pakistan was 'desperate' for funds. How would you decode these words?
A: While Khashoggi incident shook the world, in Pakistan it barely moved the needle. For reasons you have to look at the 17 years of fighting terrorism and the loss it incurred. Over eighty thousand dead, at least a few of whom were journalists. So, the entire country is desensitized to such controversies.
Pakistan’s economic condition, as we have established earlier, is really dire. Hence the country had to look wherever it could get help. When PM Khan chose to go to Saudi Arabia for the second time participants were dropping out of the Riyadh investment conference in solidarity with the slain journalist. But that only meant more visible opening for Pakistan to highlight its economic cause. The country availed the opportunity.
Q. Relations between Pakistan and its new all-weather ally China have improved considerably with CPEC, which has however distanced Washington from Islamabad. How do you view these changing political dynamics?
A: Pakistan-China relationship has and will go from strength to strength. But Washington is displaying a characteristic lack of imagination. This is not the age of cold wars.
If anything, Trump’s surprise victory should have convinced the Washington elite that the traditional paranoid worldview has no place in the realities of our time. That the world belongs to interdependence and collective security. Ergo there is no zero sum game between China and the US.
A hard-learnt lesson for Pakistan is that it should not build one relationship at the cost of another. The country has to take every relationship seriously and on merit. This is a country that managed to defy the western and Arab pressures during Iran-Iraq war and maintained a healthy friendship with Tehran despite being heavily invested in West’s war in Afghanistan against Soviet occupation.
When it comes to two of its closest allies, China and the U.S., Pakistan can maintain a healthy balance between the two and can even function once again as a bridge between them if such a need arises.
Q. U.S. unilateral withdrawal from Iran nuclear deal and diktat to countries to bring Iranian oil imports to zero has drawn angry reactions across the world. What's the popular opinion in Pakistan's intelligentsia circles regarding it and regarding Trump's policies?
A: Popular sentiment remains sympathetic to Tehran. Unity among Muslims and defiance of foreign inflicted suffering in the Muslim countries are some of the ideas that find a lot of traction here. Policies of governments can change but one thing cannot. The hearts of Pakistani citizens and Iranians are one. And I do not exaggerate.
As for intelligentsia, the question is of the paradigm every individual uses to view the world. There are those who are given to realpolitik. And those who think a better world is possible. To the latter, every setback offers a new opportunity.
After the unilateral withdrawal of the U.S., Iran can either wait for the end of Trump’s presidency or renegotiate the deal. The second option might be useful as it may offer some immediate relief to the beautiful people of Iran. But here is one fact of life that does not escape this scribe’s attention. A nation of such brilliance and full of competent people cannot be kept back for long. That is a given.
Q. According to reports, Pakistan-Iran gas pipeline project that was shelved by Nawaz Sharif government in 2015 apparently under Saudi pressure will be revived soon. How critical can it be in addressing Pakistan's energy crisis?
A: Pakistan is bound by international law and treaty obligations. Its economic volatility weakens its hand diplomatically and makes it prone to the U.S. pressures. Activation of IP gas pipeline will remain a pipedream till the time one of two things do not materialize – ease of U.S. sanctions on Iran and Pakistan regaining economic autonomy.
Remember Pakistan is faced with mounting Indian propaganda and while New Delhi uses its diplomatic muscle and mysterious influence on Trump and Washington elite, it unleashes its onslaught whenever Islamabad tries to behave proactively. India exploited the name of the then Iran-Pakistan-India (IPI) pipeline to seek nuclear deal as a concession from the U.S. and conveniently abandoned the project. Nevertheless, in view of waiver given to eight countries including India and China, Pakistan should use diplomacy to find a working solution on IP. The project is of great economic significance to Pakistan.
Q. In the initial few weeks Khan had reaffirmed his commitment to open a new chapter of relations with India but the overtures didn't last too long. What makes India-Pakistan relationship so complex?
A: India is known for its great diplomatic skill, imagination and economic might. Despite that influence sadly a baser instinct has seized control of the policy making apparatus in the country and stymied all imagination.
Right now it is preparing for the next general elections and it seems unlikely that it will be able to reciprocate any overtures from Islamabad. Pakistan waits for the day when the election cycles are over.
As for the complexity of the relationship, many books have been written on the matter and I will not be able to do justice to it in this limited space. Two issues, however stand out: cold war mentality and denial of each other’s identity.
Q. Do you see 'Naya Pakistan' (New Pakistan) taking shape under Imran Khan, the Pakistan envisioned by Mohammad Ali Jinnah and Sir Mohammad Iqbal?
A: Every century has its own dynamics. Pakistan is bound to follow the path laid out by the founder of the nation, Mohammad Ali Jinnah. Sir Mohammad Iqbal being the country’s national poet has special place in people’s imagination.
But as time passes, realities of life and of political world change. Many institutional concepts have changed or evolved since 1947. So the idea is to take the golden principles of the country’s founding fathers and adapt them to present times. Ergo, Naya (new) Pakistan.
The present government has been in power for roughly three months. In this duration what to talk of rebuilding a nation a new house is not finished. So we will have to wait and see. I am very hopeful.

Thursday, October 18, 2018

Pakistan’s Opportunity to Pivot to Eurasia

China’s initiative is an important part of Pakistan’s future

Zafar Bangash


Nothing remains constant in life; change is inevitable. How people manage change determines whether the outcome would be positive or disastrous. This is also true in politics.

Pakistan stands at the threshold of major changes. There is a new government at the helm unencumbered by the slavish policies of past regimes: the Bhutto-Zardari combine and the (non)Sharifs. This is the time for Pakistan to wean itself away from America’s teats. Far from fortifying it, America’s breast milk has poisoned Pakistan’s body politic.
On the international scene, new power blocs have emerged challenging US hegemony. America is a has-been superpower. This is largely the result of aggressive US policies that have antagonized friend and foe alike. The three pillars of US hegemony were its soft power appeal manifested through Hollywood, the dollar, and its military might.
The US lost its soft power appeal long before 9/11 when it went totally rogue. The dollar has been losing ground to other currencies notably the Chinese yuan in recent years primarily because of unilateral sanctions against countries whose policies Washington does not like. Countries suffering US sanctions have entered into bilateral trade agreements with others. This is likely to become more widespread as US actions continue its irrational trajectory. And the US military has not won a single war since the Second World War (even that war was lost by Germany, not won by the Allies). This is hardly sterling performance for a military with the highest budget in the world, far exceeding the combined total of the next 10 countries!
Even at home the US is engulfed in a civil war-like situation where a moronic president, Donald Trump, is fighting everyone including his closest advisors. Bob Woodward’s latest book, Fear: Trump in the White House details the infighting in great detail. How long will it be before there are moves to impeach him? With the US in turmoil at home and faced with numerous military defeats abroad, it is time for Pakistan to reset its relations based on its own priorities and interests.
Eurasia is the new frontier that beckons. It is a land of opportunities and riches. China serves as the engine for this brave new world in the making. Russia, Turkey, and Islamic Iran are already on-board.
Pakistan needs to join it with enthusiasm. The new government led by Imran Khan, however, will face numerous internal hurdles. America’s agents among the Pakistani elite whether in politics, the bureaucracy, or media will create obstructions. They will resort to dirty tactics to create despondency. The signs are already visible. One only has to watch some of the television talk shows with anchors busy spreading doom and gloom.
Barely two weeks into Imran’s government, some TV anchors started to complain that he had provided no blueprint for how he planned to tackle the myriad problems facing the country. “He has no plan, only slogans,” they screamed from their television pulpits.
The new government has not even been fully briefed yet. Imran Khan had asked for 90 days to show results; that is what he promised during the election campaign but the TV talking heads are not interested in facts, only scoring cheap points. They even resorted to outright lies, hurling allegations that were quickly proved false. This is beneath contempt but it is expected from hired guns used to getting stuffed envelopes from earlier regimes to bark on their behalf, especially the one just ousted from power. Envelopes have stopped coming. It must be really painful, hence the loud screams.

On his first official state visit abroad, Pakistani Prime Minister Imran Khan arrives in Jeddah on 9-19-2018. While the PM’s tour of the Gulf is being billed as a move to shore up old alliances, keen observers say that, as the PM has said going to the IMF will be a last resort, he will be tapping on the resources of China and Saudi Arabia to offset the balance of payments crisis at home. However, Bani Saud through its spokespeople is already asking for a quid pro quo. “Iran-Pak ties are on the mend and the Saudis are worried about it,” said Kamal ‘Alam, a Pakistan and Muslim East expert at the Royal United Services Institute. Any offer of money or deferred oil payments would come with the condition that Pakistan “lay off Iran,” he added.
But it is to foreign policy that we need to turn our attention. China has launched the “One Belt, One Road” policy, also called the Belt and Road Initiative (BRI). China plans to invest one trillion dollars (yes, that is trillion with a “t”) over the next decade or so building roads and ports and laying train tracks as well as building other infrastructure to enhance trade. Beijing describes it as the “connectivity project.” True, it connects China to the world but it also connects the world — at least the Eurasian countries — to each other.
The China Pakistan Economic Corridor (CPEC) is an important component of the BRI. While the overall investment amount is $50 to $60 billion, it holds enormous potential for China. Here is how. First, it cuts travel time for Chinese goods by 10 days to reach the port of Gwadar at the southern tip of Pakistan. Gwadar is the new gateway to the world and frees China from the long sea route that is susceptible to US and its allies’ disruptive tactics, especially Japan, Australia, and India. A recently opened train track from China to Iran’s Caspian Sea has cut travel time from 45 days to 15.
The US is propping up India through the Indo-Pacific Strategy framework to confront China. India’s US-assigned role was outlined in the 2017 National Security Strategy (NSS). As Alyssa Ayres candidly admitted in her “Expert Brief” for the Council on Foreign Relations on May 25, 2018,
While the NSS calls for working in concert with US allies and partners, including boosting ‘quadrilateral cooperation with Japan, Australia, and India,’ otherwise known as the Quad, the newly formulated strategy also welcomes India’s rise as a ‘leading global power’ and emphasizes expanded defense ties with New Delhi. Notably, the framework ap-pears focused on pulling India more intensively into regional activities to its east but does not necessarily take into account India’s own interests in the Indian Ocean [emphasis added].

The proposed pipeline project between Pakistan and Iran; the Chinese were supposed to build the Pakistani portion until the Sharif administration quashed the idea under pressure from Bani Saud.
This is an old strategy that the US used 50 years ago against the erstwhile Soviet Union by aligning with China. Interestingly, today China and Russia (successor to the Soviet Union) have developed a strategic partnership and are sending strong signals of their seriousness to confront US unilateralism and adventurism. This was underpinned by Russia and China holding the largest military exercises last month in Siberia. More than 300,000 troops were involved.
Pakistan needs to evolve a two-tier strategy: based on an inner rim and an outer rim. In the inner rim would be countries like Iran, China, and Turkey. Afghanistan could be brought in once the war ends there and some semblance of stability has been restored. The outer rim would comprise the Central Asian Republics, Russia, and countries of the Muslim East that are prepared to deal on the basis of equity and fairness.
It is in Pakistan’s interest to cultivate closer links with Islamic Iran. The two countries can learn from each other’s experiences and also share strategies for overcoming the threats and challenges they face. Pakistan should move quickly to restart the gas pipeline from Iran that has been kept in abeyance for seven years.
Both countries have a shared interest in confronting the threat of terrorism in Balochistan province. External powers, far and near, are instigating trouble in order to destabilize both countries. Given goodwill on both sides, this can be overcome and while the menace of terrorism may not be eliminated entirely, it can be reduced considerably in order to allow for development to take place on both sides of the border.
One other point is worth mentioning: the role of overseas Pakistanis. Currently they provide $20 billion in remittances each year, the bulk of the money coming from the Muslim East. These annual remittances are more than Pakistan’s total exports. To utilize the overseas Pakistanis’ full potential, the new government ought to address their concerns.
Beyond voting rights, there is need for some confidence building measures. Many overseas Pakistanis have had bitter experiences sending their hard earned income to build homes or invest only to discover that these properties have been usurped by property mafias. Often, close relatives are the culprits. But given the archaic legal system, there is little recourse for redress. Court cases can take decades and still not deliver a just verdict.
Even when the court delivers a favorable verdict, it is not enforceable. Often, the police do not cooperate. If the new government wants to mobilize the full potential of overseas Pakistanis, it must institute two policies immediately: first, set up separate courts dealing with the cases of overseas Pakistanis with the proviso that cases must be concluded in one year. Second, there must be an enforcement mechanism so that the court verdict is not left in abeyance.
The government should also seriously consider setting up a ministry for overseas Pakistanis. It should be separate from the foreign ministry since many problems especially relating to land and property disputes are not the responsibility of the foreign ministry.

Hitherto, overseas Pakistanis have been emotionally blackmailed into contributing financially every time a disaster strikes. And Pakistan is quite prone to disasters: earthquakes, floods, drought, and other such calamities. This emotional blackmail must end and serious effort needs to be made to establish respectful relations. The present arrangement will not last long.

Saturday, August 18, 2018

Pakistan, achievements and challenges

Islamabad, Aug 14, IRNA - Since the creation of Pakistan way back in 1947 the country has seen many ups and downs and still it is subject to many challenges.





Pakistan got independence and was declared a sovereign nation following the end of the British rule on 14th August 1947. Pakistan came into existence as a result of a movement under the leadership of Muhammad Ali Jinnah.

Pakistan officially called the Islamic Republic of Pakistan is the fifth-most populous country in the world with a population exceeding 200 million people. 

The territory that now constitutes Pakistan was the site of several ancient cultures, including the Indus Valley Civilization, and was later home to kingdoms ruled by people of different faiths and cultures, including Hindus, Indo-Greeks, Muslims, Turco-Mongols, Afghans, and Sikhs.

Pakistan is an ethnically and linguistically diverse country, with a similarly diverse geography and wildlife. Pakistan adopted its first constitution in 1956. 

When Pakistan was created in 1947, it faced many challenges and the most important one was the settlement of migrants coming from India to settle here. At the time of existence Pakistan had limited resources and it was very difficult for any country to run its affairs without any money. 

The region of Kashmir is a core issue between India and Pakistan. Both the countries have fought three wars on the issues one in 1948, second in 1965 and third in 1971. 

Approximately 45.1% of the Kashmir region is controlled by India whereas approximately 38.2% of the Kashmir region is controlled by Pakistan.

It is pertinent to mention that Bangladesh was also part of Pakistan until 1971. However due to some internal and external problems the Bangladeshi people decided to have their new country so Pakistan was broken in 1971. 

The two countries have also involved in skirmishes in northern and southern parts but the Kargil issue of 1999 was a prominent one when world powers had to intervene into the matter to stop the two countries from starting a full fledge war. 
Pakistan was established as a democracy however since its creation in 1947, Pakistan has spent several decades under military rule (1958 – 1971, 1977 – 1988, 1999 – 2008).

In 1972 Pakistan Peoples Party (PPP) led by Zulfikar Ali Bhutto came to power and in 1973 Pakistan's elected parliament promulgated the 1973 Constitution which proclaimed that no Pakistani law could contradict Islamic laws from the Quran and Sunnah. 

Pakistan has the sixth-largest standing armed forces in the world and is also a nuclear power as well as a declared nuclear-weapons state, the second in South Asia and the only nation in the Muslim world to have that status.

Pakistan had also joined US led coalition in Afghanistan two times one against the Soviet invasion and the other in war against terrorism in 2001. The people of Pakistan believe that these wars were not Pakistan’s wars and the country had to pay huge price of joining those wars. 

Afghanistan and Pakistan have had their own historic rivalry over their border, the Durand Line, which numerous Afghan governments have refused to recognize as the border. This has led to strong tensions between the two countries and even military confrontations. 

However, Pakistan continues to enjoy strong ties with Iran and China. Iran was the first country which recognized Pakistan as an independent state and since then the two countries have been tied in the eternal bond of friendship. The ties between the two countries grew even further in post-revolution era.

With China, Pakistan also have strong ties and in recent years both countries have signed China, Pakistan Economic Corridor (CPEC project which will link Pakistani port of Gwadar with China and also bring billions of dollars of investment in Pakistan. 

Pakistan over all has good ties with the Islamic World, European Countries and Far East Asian Countries. 

However its relationship with the US is full of ups and downs. Currently the ties between US and Pakistan are going through a difficult phase and the new US administration has ended military cooperation with the country along with cutting its financial aid.

Due to some tensions in ties with the US, Pakistan is tilting towards Russia. Both countries are taking various steps to improve their bilateral ties in all areas including defense cooperation.

There are various challenges which Pakistan has to face. Terrorism is the menace which has caused a lot of damage to the society of Pakistan. Though Pakistan army has carried out some successful operations against the terrorists and controlled the situation but still more steps need to be taken in this regard.

Energy crisis is also another issue haunting Pakistan. Pakistan has signed IP gas pipeline project which will bring Iranian gas to Pakistan, but still the project is not completed. The project would help Pakistan to overcome its energy crisis.

Water shortage is a new issue that has hit Pakistan. The depleting water resources are matter of concern for the country. Pakistan has to construct more water reservoirs to save the water from going into the waste. 

A large number of Pakistanis are living in Europe, Americas, and the Middle East and contributing a lot to the economy of the country by sending heavy amounts in remittances.

Pakistan has a good number of resources and its geographical location makes the country very important in the world, but all depends on the leadership of Pakistan; if they take right decision at right time, the country can become one of the strongest countries of the world.