Showing posts with label 'enemies of the US (currently Iran. Show all posts
Showing posts with label 'enemies of the US (currently Iran. Show all posts

Wednesday, September 11, 2019

This is how an event more than 1,300 years ago today sparked the birth of Isis

Salim Kassam

Though Islam has little to do with the historical acts committed in its name, the preoccupation with the existence of a Caliphate is a much older phenomenon than many realise.









"Islam is misunderstood because many of us – Muslim and non-Muslim – are ignorant of Islamic history. It is this secret history that can tell us not only where Isis really come from, but why they are not going away any time soon, despite losing their territory.
For example, this Tuesday is Ashura, one of the saddest days of the calendar for the world’s 1.8 billion Muslims, marking the day the grandson of the Prophet Muhammad, Husayn ibn Ali, was killed during the Battle of Karbala, But few Muslims – and even fewer non-Muslims – truly understand what happened on this day over 1300 years ago. 
This was the crucial date when, just a few years after Prophet Muhammad’s death, Islam went from being practiced as a divine religion to being a tool used by a regime that, like its modern counterpart, had little interest in faith and more interest in territorial expansion and supremacism.
It was the birth of the first Isis, as a militant, brutal perversion of the religion massacred a vulnerable minority. The hijacking and abuse of Islam goes back a long way and it has been an onlgoing struggle for Muslims to isolate their faith from its often grimey historical context. This is a fact not appreciated by the majority of counter-extremism experts, meaning that much of their work is ineffective or even counter-productive, as policies and strategies are employed which target entire Muslim communities when really the pivot to violence and supremacism has always been isolated to very few marginal and radical individuals.
After 800 years of conflict between the Byzantine and Persian empires, a power vacuum had emerged, which the new empire of Islam filled. But expansionism came at a cost: the brutal Umayyad dynasty who siezed control of Islam had to eliminate all rivals, including the Prophet Muhammad’s own family. It is this injustice – and the chain of events it led to, where Imperialism in the name of Islam was unleashed on much of the civilised world – that many Muslims will mourn on Tuesday.
But this is about much more than history – it is about how, at the hands of a few self-elected strongmen, extremism and supremacism came to be a common byproduct of Islam’s interaction with the world, to the point where the two are almost indistinguishable to some. It is this blurring of the lines between faith and empire, that has led so many to wonder if Islam can peacefully exist in the modern world. It has also created powerful imagery of Islam’s “glory days”, used by extremists the world over to inspire their impressionable young recruits.
As many jump between two caricatures of Islam (that it is either an inherently violent and fascistic ideology, or that Muslims are perennially innocent victims of hatred and discrimination) we must understand that there are two Islams, both of which are very real. There is the Islam of the Umayyad dynasty and their modern ideological descendants in Wahhabism and Isis, which is a violent perversion of a harmonious faith. And there is the Islam of the vast majority of the world’s Muslims, which is an Abrahamic faith in the lineage of Judaism and Christianity.
Both Muslims and non-Muslims do the religion an injustice by confusing the faith with the historical acts committed in its name. There is a western intellectual tradition, going back to Orientalism and the idea of the “Clash of Civilisations” that primes some observers to believe that Islam is indeed an agressive, alien force. Many in the far-right seem more comfortable with the idea of being in perpetual conflict with Islam than with an acceptance of a shared Abrahamic tradition among the three major monotheistic faiths. 
At the same time, some Muslims fall into the trap of idealising their own history. Many in the diaspora prefer the self-image of being part of an ancient (albeit militaristic and unjust) empire, than an embattled minority with a range of complexities and often socio-economic disadvantages.
At the extreme end of this scale are some Islamists who believe that all the problems in the world can be solved merely by the existence of a Caliphate, regardless of its moral compass. The date 1924 (the end of the last Caliphate, the Ottoman Empire) has been immortalised by many activists who want nothing other than a return to Islamic political authority – whatever the outcome of that regime.
This idea, that the simple existence of a Caliph (however brutal or barbaric he may be) will solve all the world’s problems, is dangerous. Isis showed what happens when it is taken to its natural conclusion. 
But this ideology is not going to go away: “power at all costs” has been a belief amongst some Muslims from the time of the Umayyads and the Ashura massacre that will be commemorated on Tuesday. 
It was Yazid, the Umayyad commander, that introduced the Arabs to beheadings and the eating of one’s enemies’ vital organs – both of which are favoured tactics of Isis. And their sense of supremacism, evident in their exclusion of other tribes and sectarian minorities from power, is still alive today in some parts of the Muslim world.
Most importantly, Yazid used the Quran to justify his war crimes, and called his enemies (including Prophet Muhammad’s grandson, Hussain) apostates.
If all this sounds familiar, it is because Isis themselves do not identify as a 21st century grouping, but rather the continuation of this war that began on the sands of Kerbala, Iraq 1339 years ago. It is a war that is far from over.
Salim Kassam is a community activist and co-founder of TheMuslimVibe.com

Friday, August 30, 2019

Anthony Hall: Pro-Israel “Im Tirzu” Project against Civil Societies


Anthony Hall: Pro-Israel “Im Tirzu” Project against Civil Societies
TEHRAN (FNA)- Anthony Hall, Canadian professor, strongly criticized the moves made in the West to blacklist academic critics of Israel as “very reprehensible and anti-academic”.
Speaking in an exclusive interview with FNA, Professor Hall commented on an Israeli project called Im Tirzu, listing academics who are “anti-Zionists or Leftists” and inviting students to file complaints against them.

He further said such a move prevents academics from expressing their ideas, saying, “What is the University for, if questions cannot be asked in an open fashion? The basis of democracy requires free and open expression of a range of opinion.”

Anthony James Hall is Professor emeritus of Globalization Studies at the University of Lethbridge in Alberta, Canada. Also, he is the editor in chief of American Herald Tribune. Professor Hall was a target of pro-Israeli lobbies’ Canary project, which filed a complaint against him based on his interviews and speeches against Zionism. The court dismissed the accusations against him, but the university admiration forced him to get retired.

Below is the full text of the interview.

Q: How do you view the practice of the blacklisting academics by Israeli extremists?

A: Ironically this is all framed in terms that Israel is Jewish and democratic! Zionists suggest Israel is an exclusively Jewish state, so that does not represent in an equitable way, those who are not Jews (Arabs-Palestinians, Muslims or Christians.) There is something lacking and contradictory in the claim to democracy: in a democracy you do not expect everyone to have the same opinion; you expect that there will be a disagreement about opinion. The move to blacklist academics suggests there are right and wrong opinions, and if you have these supposedly wrong opinions then perhaps you should not be working at a university. What is the University for, if questions cannot be asked in an open fashion? The basis of democracy requires free and open expression of a range of opinion.

Q: It sounds Israeli extremists do not want to have Zionism discussed academically. Where else this can be discussed, if not at a university?

A: Surely the essence of what university is supposed to stand for is a range of free expression of a range of opinion. We get away from that and it is tragic. In Canada teaching about indigenous people is a patriotic thing to do as the Canadians want to address these issues. With the Palestinians, why should not the same apply? Why would not a patriotic Israeli citizen say we have a problem here? We have something out of order? These professors are apparently put in a hard situation.

Q: How do you view the reactions from inside Israel to the move?

A: When Benjamin Netanyahu, the Prime Minister, spoke to the camera, he supported that move, showing government’s approval. But, even the Likud party, which is the center of gravity, has condemned the project. There was actually a court case where a group accused this move of having fascist characteristics, and a judge agreed that characterization was valid in some respects. It seems to be creating great divisions inside Israel.

Q: What are the possible consequences of Im Tirzu?

A: Of course to be subjected to this kind of recriminations that move is bringing on might be considered blacklisting. It might be considered an encouragement to add students to the list of those making a complaint, or maybe even commit violence against the professors or to have contempt for them. This is not a healthy approach. It resembles Canary mission, a website devoted to blacklisting students who support BDS. Blacklisting is illegal. Blacklisting is unethical. If you disagree with the positions of an academic professor, express your disagreement, find out how that professor is wrong, or have an open debate using the dynamics of academic discourse to find out where the truth lies. That a group is blacklisted and designated as somehow traitors is very reprehensible and anti-academic, not conducted in a civil society.

Monday, December 03, 2018

G20 Summit, Top Agenda Item: Bye-Bye American Empire

G20 Summit, Top Agenda Item: Bye-Bye American Empire

The G20 summits are nominally about how the world’s biggest national economies can cooperate to boost global growth. This year’s gathering – more than ever – shows, however, that rivalry between the US and China is center stage.
Zeroing in further still, the rivalry is an expression of a washed-up American empire desperately trying to reclaim its former power. There is much sound, fury and pretense from the outgoing hegemon – the US – but the ineluctable reality is an empire whose halcyon days are a bygone era.
Ahead of the summit taking place this weekend in Argentina, the Trump administration has been issuing furious ultimatums to China to “change its behavior”. Washington is threatening an escalating trade war if Beijing does not conform to American demands over economic policies.
President Trump has taken long-simmering US complaints about China to boiling point, castigating Beijing for unfair trade, currency manipulation, and theft of intellectual property rights. China rejects this pejorative American characterization of its economic practices.
Nevertheless, if Beijing does not comply with US diktats then the Trump administration says it will slap increasing tariffs on Chinese exports.
The gravity of the situation was highlighted by the comments this week of China’s ambassador to the US, Cui Tiankai, who warned that the “lessons of history” show trade wars can lead to catastrophic shooting wars. He urged the Trump administration to be reasonable and to seek a negotiated settlement of disputes.
The problem is that Washington is demanding the impossible. It’s like as if the US wants China to turn the clock back to some imagined former era of robust American capitalism. But it is not in China’s power to do that. The global economy has shifted structurally away from US dominance. The wheels of production and growth are in China’s domain of Eurasia.
For decades, China functioned as a giant market for cheap production of basic consumer goods. Now under President Xi Jinping, the nation is moving to a new phase of development involving sophisticated technologies, high-quality manufacture, and investment.
It’s an economic evolution that the world has seen before, in Europe, the US and now Eurasia. In the decades after the Second World War, up to the 197os, it was US capitalism that was the undisputed world leader. Combined with its military power, the postwar global order was defined and shaped by Washington. Sometimes misleading called Pax Americana, there was nothing peaceful about the US-led global order. It was more often an order of relative stability purchased by massive acts of violence and repressive regimes under Washington’s tutelage.
In American mythology, it does not have an empire. The US was supposed to be different from the old European colonial powers, leading the rest of the world through its “exceptional” virtues of freedom, democracy and rule of law. In truth, US global dominance relied on the application of ruthless imperial power.
The curious thing about capitalism is it always outgrows its national base. Markets eventually become too small and the search for profits is insatiable. American capital soon found more lucrative opportunities in the emerging market of China. From the 1980s on, US corporations bailed out of America and set up shop in China, exploiting cheap labor and exporting their goods back to increasingly underemployed America consumers. The arrangement was propped up partly because of seemingly endless consumer debt.
That’s not the whole picture of course. China has innovated and developed independently from American capital. It is debatable whether China is an example of state-led capitalism or socialism. The Chinese authorities would claim to subscribe to the latter. In any case, China’s economic development has transformed the entire Eurasian hemisphere. Whether you like it or not, Beijing is the dynamo for the global economy. One indicator is how nations across Asia-Pacific are deferring to China for their future growth.
Washington likes to huff and puff about alleged Chinese expansionism “threatening” US allies in Asia-Pacific. But the reality is that Washington is living in the past of former glory. Trading blocs like the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) realize their bread is buttered by China, no longer America. Washington’s rhetoric about “standing up to China” is just that – empty rhetoric. It doesn’t mean much to countries led by their interests of economic development and the benefits of Chinese investment.
One example is Taiwan. In contrast to Washington’s shibboleths about “free Taiwan”, more and more Asian countries are dialing down their bilateral links with Taiwan in deference to China’s position, which views the island as a renegade province. The US position is one of rhetoric, whereas the relations of other countries are based on material economic exigencies. And respecting Beijing’s sensibilities is for them a prudent option.
A recent report by the New York Times starkly illustrated the changing contours of the global economic order. It confirmed what many others have observed, that China is on the way to surpass the US as the world’s top economy. During the 1980s, some 75 per cent of China’s population were living in “extreme poverty”, according to the NY Times. Today, less than 1 per cent of the population is in that dire category. For the US, the trajectory has been in reverse with greater numbers of its people subject to deprivation.
China’s strategic economic plans – the One Belt One Road initiative – of integrating regional development under its leadership and finance have already created a world order analogous to what American capital achieved in the postwar decades.
American pundits and politicians like Vice President Mike Pence may disparage China’s economic policies as creating “debt traps” for other countries. But the reality is that other countries are gravitating to China’s dynamic leadership.
Arguably, Beijing’s vision for economic development is more enlightened and sustainable than what was provided by the Americans and Europeans before. The leitmotif for China, along with Russia, is very much one of multipolar development and mutual partnership. The global economy is not simply moving from one hegemon – the US – to another imperial taskmaster – China.
One thing seems inescapable. The days of American empire are over. Its capitalist vigor has dissipated decades ago. What the upheaval and rancor in relations between Washington and Beijing is all about is the American ruling class trying to recreate some fantasy of former vitality. Washington wants China to sacrifice its own development in order to somehow rejuvenate American society. It’s not going to happen.
That’s not to say that American society can never be rejuvenated. It could, as it could also in Europe. But that would entail a restructuring of the economic system involving democratic regeneration. The “good old days” of capitalism are gone. The American empire, as with the European empires, is obsolete.
That’s the unspoken Number One agenda item at the G20 summit. Bye-bye US empire.
What America needs to do is regenerate through a reinvented social economic order, one that is driven by democratic development and not the capitalist private profit of an elite few.
If not, the futile alternative is US failing political leaders trying to coerce China, and others, to pay for their future. That way leads to war.
Finian CUNNINGHAM
Former editor and writer for major news media organizations. He has written extensively on international affairs, with articles published in several languages

Monday, October 15, 2018

Trump Not to Take Any Meaningful Action against Riyadh over Khashoggi: US Prof.

TEHRAN (Tasnim) – An American political scientist said US President Donald Trump would not take any “meaningful action” against Saudi Arabia over the case of Jamal Khashoggi, saying US allies are immune to being held to account on human rights abuses.

Trump Not to Take Any Meaningful Action against Riyadh over Khashoggi: US Prof.

“…President Trump has already signaled he is unwilling to take any meaningful action against the Saudi regime,” Beau Grosscup, California State University Professor Emeritus of Political Science, told Tasnim.
He added, “As in the past, allies of the US are immune to being held to account on human rights abuses except in a rhetorical sense. Only the designated 'enemies of the US (currently Iran, Venezuela, Syria) are to be held to account.”
Following is the full text of the interview:
Tasnim: As you know, Jamal Khashoggi entered the Saudi consulate in Istanbul on Oct. 2 to get documents for his forthcoming marriage. Saudi officials say he left shortly afterwards but Turkish officials and his fiancée, who was waiting outside, said he never came out. What do you think?
Grosscup: It has been pretty well established that Mr. Khashoggi did not come out of the consulate office, especially since with an impending marriage, there would be no reason for him to be/stay in hiding.
Tasnim: Turkish sources have said the initial assessment of the police was that Khashoggi, an outspoken critic of the Saudi government, had been deliberately killed inside the consulate. Riyadh has dismissed the claims. Could you possibly say what motive Riyadh had for this?
Grosscup: Mr. Khashoggi is/was regarded as an outstanding journalist, with strong family ties to the Saudi royal family in the past. But, as a major player in the Saudi 'progressive' media, once in exile he had become a fierce critic of the new Saudi regime under Mohammad bin Salman, charging that repression in Saudi Arabia is worse than ever. I suspect the Crown Prince's motive was to make clear to all dissidents and would be dissidents that his reach is global and the punishment severe as there has been little effort, other than public denials, to cover the assassination event. I see it as a clear warning to critics of the new leader and his 'reforms', especially his recent 'purges' against the old guard, that young though he may be, he is in charge, and having been lauded by President Trump, (and to some extent Israeli leadership), he feels he has a 'green light' to do whatever he pleases with only mild symbolic criticism. He knows the real focus of US-Saudi-Israeli unity is regime change in Iran and that neither the Trump administration nor Israel will do anything to undermine that unity and its goal, especially the assassination of a 'fake news' Washington Post journalist.
Tasnim: US President Donald Trump threatened “severe punishment” for Riyadh if it turned out Khashoggi was killed in the Saudi consulate in Istanbul. Do you believe Trump will take any action against Riyadh taking into account Washington’s arms deals with Riyadh? 
Grosscup: President Trump has already signaled he is unwilling to take any meaningful action against the Saudi regime. He has showered the new Crown Prince with high praise, has an important business relationship with past Saudi regimes (as he himself has publicly noted), and has made clear he admires the autocratic rulers around the world, openly wishing he had their power and was able to adopt their methods of governing. I suspect, even with a confirmation of the assassination, Trump will basically say to the Saudis, "please don't do this again" and focus the world's attention on 'more important tasks' requiring a strong US-Saudi relationship. Trump will find a way to push this 'unfortunate event' into the background and move on.
Tasnim: When do you think the world would smell the coffee and stand up to Saudi human rights violations? 
Grosscup: Since the US 'owns' (dominates/enforces) the global human rights discourse and policy, there is no reason to expect any movement against Saudi Arabia for their human rights violations. As in the past, allies of the US are immune to being held to account on human rights abuses except in a rhetorical sense. Only the designated 'enemies of the US (currently Iran, Venezuela, Syria) are to be held to account. It is the reason the Trump administration recently withdrew from the UN Human Rights Council, to make the point that it is the US who determines human rights policy, not the UN or any other agent.