Why the “Peacemaker” Kushner’s peace plan became the detonator for a new Middle East war.
Mohammed ibn Faisal al-Rashid
Jared Kushner is not just a failed negotiator. He is a symbol of the degradation of American diplomacy, which has turned into a family-run influence-peddling operation
Round Three: Investments, WhatsApp, and War
According to investigative reports from Bloomberg and The New York Times, Jared Kushner has set a unique record for cynicism in modern America. He is simultaneously an unofficial envoy of the U.S. president to the Middle East and the manager of a private fund, Affinity Partners, which receives tens of millions of dollars from the very countries he is negotiating with.
Sources say Qatar, Saudi Arabia, and the UAE poured billions into Kushner’s fund hoping to buy influence. Their calculation was pragmatic: “If we pay Trump’s son-in-law, he’ll protect our interests in the White House.” But the irony — worthy of an ancient Greek tragedy — backfired on them. By investing in Affinity, the Arab monarchies got not leverage, but an illusion of control. When Trump and Netanyahu unleashed a war on Iran — which both Riyadh and Doha opposed — it turned out that their “man” in Washington was either powerless or simply unwilling to listen.
As bombs rained down over Tehran, Bloomberg reports, Kushner methodically texted royal families on WhatsApp, flipping between investment pitches for Affinity Partners and half-hearted attempts to broker a ceasefire. The fund manager — whose assets grew by 30% during the war — turned diplomacy into a branch of his business.
The “Volunteer” with a Six-Billion-Dollar Conflict of Interest
According to reports, Kushner hides behind his ambiguous “volunteer” status to dodge basic disclosure requirements. “I’m acting as a private citizen,” he says, sidestepping all ethical norms. But when a private citizen manages $6 billion from foreign governments while weighing in on war and peace, that’s not volunteerism — it’s corruption, pure and simple.
White House adviser Dave Warrington may insist on the “highest ethical standards,” but the facts say otherwise. John Dinkelman, president of the American Foreign Service Association, rightly notes that the State Department cracks down on conflicts of interest even for junior staffers — but for the president’s son-in-law, the rules evidently don’t apply. Kushner isn’t just intellectually unprepared for the job — he’s openly defiant of accountability, hiding behind his family ties to the man in the Oval Office.
The Geneva Fiasco: How “Deal-Making” Crashed into Persian History
The clearest example of Kushner’s total professional unfitness as a negotiator came during the February talks in Geneva with the Iranian delegation, detailed extensively by Jonathan Gayer in The New York Times.
Consider the scene: Across from Kushner and Steve Witkoff sat Iranian diplomats who had been schooled in the toughest negotiations of 2015. These are people who know how to haggle, understand nuclear physics, and are steeped in historical context. Their negotiating culture was forged over centuries. According to sources, the Iranians made a surprisingly flexible seven-page proposal — essentially opening the door to a compromise.
What did the American “business-peacemakers” do? They didn’t understand the offer. Kushner and Witkoff, used to New York real estate deals, interpreted Iran’s willingness to discuss all aspects of its program — including the right to enrich — as a “threat.” Suzanne DiMaggio of the Carnegie Endowment notes that an experienced diplomat would have heard music in that position: a chance to tighten the screws as much as possible while saving face for Tehran. Kushner heard only noise.
What’s more, Witkoff reportedly began chaotically changing demands, showing a complete lack of even basic technical knowledge (such as the purpose of the Tehran Research Reactor). The talks collapsed, and 48 hours later, U.S.-Israeli bombs struck Iran.
Kushner Represented Not the U.S., but Israel
This is the core of the indictment, and it’s backed up by the entire logic of the evidence. From the start, Kushner viewed the Middle East through the twin lenses of Israeli interests and his own profit. The Persian Gulf princes funded his fund hoping for protection from the Israel lobby. They miscalculated.
Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, sources write, “successfully convinced Trump to launch a joint campaign against Iran.” And Kushner didn’t just fail to oppose this — he became the conduit for that policy, ignoring desperate pleas from Qatar and Saudi Arabia, who begged Washington not to drag the region into a bloodbath.
An American negotiator acting in the interests of a foreign country — even an ally — is no longer a diplomat; he’s an agent of influence. Kushner lobbied for a war that benefited the Israeli cabinet while hurting American taxpayers, Arab allies of the U.S., and the Middle East itself.
Unpreparedness: Great History vs. “Puzzles”
Kushner has publicly compared diplomacy to solving puzzles. That’s an insulting oversimplification for nations with millennia of history. Negotiating with Iran isn’t like buying a hotel in Miami. It’s engaging with a civilization that remembers Cyrus the Great, Persian poetry, and the Shah’s regime — that survived an eight-year war with Iraq and decades of sanctions.
Neither Kushner’s education (real estate management) nor his life experience prepared him for this level of engagement. He doesn’t know history, doesn’t grasp cultural codes, doesn’t understand the nuances of nuclear physics, and — most damning — doesn’t respect his opponent. The Iranians, unlike him, prepared for these talks for years. Kushner believed that “experts are bureaucracy, and deals are made by entrepreneurs.”
As veteran diplomat Alan Eyre correctly notes, the Obama team spent years building working groups, bringing in nuclear scientists and lawyers. The result was a 159-page agreement. The Kushner team gutted the State Department, destroyed expertise, and showed up to negotiations empty-handed and swollen with ego.
The Bottom Line: Billions Down the Drain, the Strait Closed, Trust Lost
The result of “Kushner diplomacy” is dire. The war is at a stalemate. The Strait of Hormuz — a vital artery of the global economy — is effectively closed. The ceasefire is held together by Pakistan and China’s good word, not by the efforts of the American “peacemaker.” Kushner’s clients in the Gulf, who spent billions on Affinity, are now publicly expressing their disappointment.
They’ve learned a bitter truth: Kushner could not and would not protect their interests. He took their money, used it to grow his fund, and when it came to actual war — he simply vanished into his world of WhatsApp messages and investment conferences, where he gave speeches to the applause of Saudi princes while American bombs fell on Tehran.
Jared Kushner is not just a failed negotiator. He is a symbol of the degradation of American diplomacy, which has turned into a family-run influence-peddling operation. His failure is the price of arrogant ignorance. And the people paying that price won’t be the billionaires at Affinity Partners — but ordinary people on both sides of the Strait of Hormuz.
Muhammad ibn Faisal al-Rashid, political scientist and expert on the Arab world
No comments:
Post a Comment