Showing posts with label killing of 20 people in El Paso. Show all posts
Showing posts with label killing of 20 people in El Paso. Show all posts

Saturday, August 10, 2019

Individualism, American Exceptionalism Root Causes of Gun Violence: US Analyst

TEHRAN (Tasnim) – An American political commentator and social justice activist said sense of individualism and American Exceptionalism are at the root of gun violence and gun-related crimes in the US.

“An underlying reason for inaction is our sense of individualism and also American Exceptionalism. The very idea that we as Americans have a right to own a gun and not be interfered with by our government is a long-standing, yet probably minority, position. That we feel the US is the best in the world means we don’t like to copy what’s good or what works in other countries, such as gun legislation or health care,” Myles Hoenig, who ran for the US Congress in 2016 as a Green Party candidate, told the Tasnim news agency.
Following is the full text of the interview.
Tasnim: A gunman armed with a powerful assault-style rifle on Saturday opened fire at the Cielo Vista Walmart store in n El Paso, Texas, killing at least 20 people and injuring 26 others. Another shooting in Ohio killed nine people and wounded 16 others at in downtown Dayton, Ohio. What is your take on the deadly incidents?
Hoenig: The only thing truly unusual about these two incidents is the timing, that they were back to back, all within 24 hours. Most mass killings in the US happen weeks apart, in enough time for politicians to offer their ‘thoughts and prayers’, make a lot of political noise, or simply shrug it off until the next one happens. Ever since Columbine where two teenagers shot up a high school, the nation thought that Congress would really get serious about gun legislation. And when Sandy Hook happened, where an elementary school was shot up, and nothing came of it, then it is pretty much written off that any reasonable legislation will ever happen. In 1988, a lawn dart killed a child and they were banned. The toy industry is powerful but immediate and effective. The gun industry is almost untouchable.
But there is one difference now that just may effect change and that is that Trump is president and no rules apply for anything.
Tasnim: At public events and on television, several candidates pointed to a need for more gun restrictions, such as universal background checks. But they directed much of their criticism at Trump. They called on him "I say to stop “the racist anti-immigrant rhetoric” and “the hatred in this country which is creating the kind of violence that we see." What are your thoughts on this?
Hoenig: Democrats, in particular, like to think that President Trump invented violence. They look for single actors and blame them for all the evils that befall us. Hillary Clinton was a miserable candidate and was the only person who could lose to Trump but they blamed Russia and the Kremlin for her loss. The Republicans are no better at the blame game as during the Cold War Russia, again, was the ‘Evil Empire’, as President Reagan called them. And both parties call whichever foreign leader they wish to remove in order to take their countries’ resources another ‘Hitler’, as a way to justify their actions.
President Trump is being called out by Democrats, in particular, for exacerbating racial hostilities, and in this case, rightly so. His entire adult history has been predicated on demonizing immigrants and people of color, whether as a landlord or now as a politician. But racial animosity did not begin with Trump, either, as having a black president, Obama, was reason enough for the white supremacists to start feeling ‘justified’ in acting out on their bigoted and racist views.
Tasnim: Following the two mass shootings, President Trump said that “hate has no place in our country”. What is the root cause of this violence? Do you think it is related to the imperial system and the exercise of extreme individualism? It seems that modern individualism has no place in the US and the country is still using the ninetieth-century individualism. Kindly explain.
Hoenig: No president or administration has done enough to stop this kind of hatred but this president has done its fair share in flaming the hostilities and tensions. Its immigration policies, and campaigning before election are based on racism and hatred. Their indifference to the working poor and people of color is really no different than past administrations but the tone of their rhetoric is far more lethal. Although his entire administration stayed away from the talk shows on Sunday morning, as a way of avoiding discussing what needs to be done, public pressure just might push Congress to do something, but if it does, it will be so watered down that it would remain insignificant and fuel for campaign rhetoric and promises for the 2020 election.
An underlying reason for inaction is our sense of individualism and also American Exceptionalism. The very idea that we as Americans have a right to own a gun and not be interfered with by our government is a long-standing, yet probably minority, position. That we feel the US is the best in the world means we don’t like to copy what’s good or what works in other countries, such as gun legislation or health care.

Wednesday, August 07, 2019

White Supremacy

A number of commentators have linked the killing of 20 people at a Walmart store in El Paso in the United States of America on Saturday 3rd August 2019 to the rising tide of White Supremacism.
White Supremacism is a belief that whites are superior to others and therefore have a right to dominate them. There were elements of such thinking in a “manifesto” posted online allegedly written by the suspected killer, a 21 year old white from a Dallas suburb. The suspect had justified his massacre as a response “to the Hispanic invasion of Texas” and had made references to the Christchurch (New Zealand) shootings in March this year where a white gunman killed 51 mosque worshippers.
It has been suggested that the notion of white supremacy has become more virulent in the US in the last two years mainly because of president Trump’s rhetoric against Mexicans and other Hispanics and non-white minorities in general. This is the reason why when his daughter Ivanka condemned the Al Paso massacre there was an immediate torrent of criticisms against her. Congresswoman Rashida Tlaib for instance advised her to “check your dad in his tweets. 251 mass shootings in the US in 216 days. He incites violence every day with his hate agenda and racism. More people are dying because he fails to fight white supremacist terrorists.”
White supremacist ideology and practice has a long history behind it. It precedes the American civil war in the middle of the 19th century. The oppression of the African slave population and indeed the institution of slavery itself embodied the contempt and hatred that the whites bore towards the blacks.  The elimination of a huge segment of the indigenous American Indian communities and the systematic marginalisation of those who survived was further proof of white supremacy.  In that sense the Ku Klux Klan as the flag bearer of white racism is not alien to American history.
However, white racism and white supremacy go beyond the US. Western colonialism, whatever its economic and strategic motives, was rooted to a great extent in the ideology of white supremacy. Colonial rulers and administrators were deeply imbued with this ideology. A case in point would be Winston Churchill who stated in 1937, “I do not admit for instance that a great wrong has been done to the Red Indians of America or the black people of Australia. I do not admit that a wrong has been done to these people by the fact that a stronger race, a higher-grade race, a more worldly-wise race to put it in that way has come in and taken their place.”
Of course, in Britain and in much of the contemporary Western world blatant white supremacist thinking has declined considerably. This is partly because of the end of formal colonial rule and the emergence of alternative centres of civilisation especially in the non-Western world.  Nonetheless, because Western hegemony persists in current patterns of global political, economic and cultural power, hints of superiority continue to manifest themselves in various spheres of life. This is why the struggle to evolve more equitable global structures remains formidable.
If anything, two recent developments have exacerbated the situation. Expressions of white supremacy and racist hatred are disseminated more widely today through the social media. Analysts have observed that the vile and vicious propaganda of white supremacists for instance appears to have a greater impact because of the new avenues of communication — avenues which allow their users to adopt extreme positions without assuming responsibility for them. Add to this the flow of migrants to Europe from West Asia, North Africa and Sub- Saharan Africa which has encouraged the Right in the continent to manipulate baseless fears   about the so-called threat to the white, European way of life from these newcomers whose cultures and religions are different. For the Right, the migrant sometimes escaping the chaos at home created by the politics of regime change instigated by Western powers has become a boon to their political fortunes.
In spite of these developments, there are countless groups in Europe and the US standing up to white supremacist politics and racism. They have become vocal champions of inclusivity and diversity in their societies. They eschew the politics of fear and hatred. In fact, Trump’s brazen attempt to harness the support of the white majority by frightening them of some imaginary danger posed by minorities appears to have backfired. A grassroots movement is developing rapidly in various parts of the US seeking to repudiate the politics of white supremacy as anathema to the ideals of the American Constitution and the American Republic.
Dr Chandra Muzaffar is the President of the International Movement for a Just World (JUST).
Malaysia.