Showing posts with label hamza yusuf. Show all posts
Showing posts with label hamza yusuf. Show all posts

Thursday, October 03, 2019

Hamza Yusuf’s Fall from Grace

Clarity comes from perseverance through privation, not knowledge


Salina Khan
In a newly released video from a 2016 conference, American Muslim “scholar” Hamza Yusuf is seen snickering as he asks Syrians,
How’s that revolution working for you? Huh? You know what the slogan of the Syrian revolution was? Huh? “The Syrian people will not be humiliated.” They were shouting it in the streets. Now all these poor innocent people are begging non-Muslims to let them into their countries. Allah can humiliate whomever He pleases.
What he forgets to mention is that he was also on the streets in September 2012 leading a Syria Freedom Rally in Washington, fully encouraging the Syrian people to join a (now-failed) regime change plan orchestrated by America and Israel and their Arabian and Turkish lackeys. Shouting from the stage, Yusuf promised that “the Syrian people will not be humiliated” in their fight against the so-called “tyranny” of the Syrian government.
However, four years later in the video he is seen sitting on a cushioned sofa in the coastal town of Samsun, Turkey, laughing as he discusses the plight of the Syrians who were duped into destroying their own country by people like him. Now he claims Muslims are “fluff” and don’t have the capabilities to choose their own leadership (conveniently ignoring that the Islamic Republic of Iran successfully overthrew a 2,000-year-old monarchy in 1979 and replaced it with an Islamic government).
Chastising those who rebelled against Syrian President Bashar al-Asad, Yusuf says, “‘If you humiliate a [legitimate] ruler, God will humiliate you.’ That’s a hadith in Tirmidhi.”
Once again, he neglects to mention that it was he who was bashing Muslim leaders of the Axis of Resistance at the Syria Freedom Rally,
The leadership... in Lebanon and Iran [allies of the Syrian government] have revealed themselves to be the political machiavellian people that they are. They have revealed themselves to side with the tyrants against those who are oppressed.
The irony of it all is that since insulting the Islamic Republic of Iran and Lebanese Resistance in 2012, it is Yusuf who has fallen in disgrace, tumbling in the eyes of the Muslim masses as he revealed his true self by insulting the Black Lives Movement, affiliating with the UAE government’s peace forum, becoming a human rights advisor to President Donald Trump, and crash landing today with the release of this video. He tried to humiliate the Axis of Resistance through the Syrian crisis, but it is his comments on that very issue that are destroying him on social media today.
It’s not a coincidence that the final nail in the coffin of Yusuf’s respectability (whatever little he had) as a Muslim scholar came on the day of ‘Ashura’, when Muslims around the world commemorate the triumph of good over evil. There are so many political lessons to be learned from Karbala’. If only more Muslims would remember, understand, and analyze the events and personalities of Karbala’, they would clearly be able to recognize the Husayns and Yazids (and Yazid’s court scholars) of today.
 

Salina Khan

Friday, February 01, 2019

"Church Protection in Islam: Too Late, Too Little"

Court scholars represent power, not Islam

John Andrew Morrow


In 2016, the Ministry of Awqaf of the Supreme Council for Islamic Affairs for the Arab Republic of Egypt published a work titled Church Protection in Islam in various languages. The work, which is dedicated to “Mr. President ‘Abd al-Fattah al-Sisi, the president of the Arab Republic of Egypt,” one of the greatest violators of human rights on the planet, features a foreword from Professor Muhammad Mukhtar Jumu‘ah, Minister of Awqaf, an introduction by Professor Shawqi ‘Allam, along with articles by Prof. Muhammad Salim Abu ‘Asi, Professor ‘Abdullah al-Najjar, Professor Muhammad al-Jibali, Professor Muhammad Nabil Ghanayim, Professor ‘Abd al-Halim and Dr. Majdi ‘Ashur. If you read one, you have read them all, as they all essentially repeat the very same thing, quote the very same Qur’anic ayat, quote the very same prophetic hadiths, and use the very same arguments.
Protecting the church is an obligation in Islam. In other words, there should be no need for Muslims to even speak about it. They should simply act. They should defend the church, protect it from all aggression, care for its members, and support them permanently. This is what the Qur’an commands. This is what the Prophet Muhammad (pbuh), commands. To point out that Islam asks Muslims to protect the church is as silly as pointing out that the sky is blue and that clouds are white. God, the Most Compassionate and the Most Merciful, commanded Muslims to protect and defend all believers. To stress the importance of an obligation that should be well-known to every conscientious Muslim is simply senseless unless, of course, those who do so to seek some sort of revenue. Not only should such work be met with ridicule, it should be met with indignation and outrage. The Prophet gave a clear, direct, and unambiguous order. What these establishment scholars at the service of al-Sisi have done is too little and too late.
Why is it that Church Protection in Islam only appeared toward the end of the ISIS crisis? Muslims have been suffering from the savagery of salafi jihadism for centuries. The scholars who contributed to the work were not around 200 years ago; however, they have been Muslim leaders for decades. They have lived long enough to witness the horrors inflicted by the salafi jihadists upon Muslims and non-Muslims for decades in places like Algeria, Afghanistan, Pakistan, Iraq, Tunisia, Libya, Nigeria, the Philippines, Syria, Egypt, Somalia, Niger, Mali, Kenya, Yemen, Cameroun, India, Burkina Faso, Bangladesh, Chad, Turkey, Mozambique, Iran, and elsewhere. Is it because these Egyptian scholars were bred by the Muslim Brotherhood? Or is it because they are court clerics and palace scholars who would never act on their own initiative and simply responded to a request from al-Sisi to combat domestic terrorism?
The answer to these important questions comes from one of the contributors himself, Professor Muhammad Salim Abu ‘Asi, the Dean of the Faculty of Islamic and Arabic Studies for Girls, al-Azhar University, Sadat City. He provides the following apologia for the takfiri Wahhabi terrorists who have raped, tortured, mutilated, mangled, and murdered thousands of Christians on a yearly basis over the past few decades, “For me, the reasons that some ignorant people, who have no good understanding, may be involved in violation against the non-Muslim places of worship are as follows:
1. Immature understanding of legal indication and lack of juristic integration in relation to the rulings of the People of the Book in the Islamic law, especially on the part of extremist groups;
2. Absence of a standard approach and an ideal method for studying the rulings of the People of the Book, [namely, Jews and Christians], which can highlight the differences between the work of a mufti and the work of the one who just cites rulings from traditional references. In addition, it is important to know the difference between the unanimously agreed-upon legal rulings and the debatable rulings and between the missionary rulings and the rulings within the area of the Shari‘ah-oriented political system. Speakers, who are not well versed in Islamic sciences, on issues related to the People of the Book lack this knowledge; and
3. Inconsideration of changes in conditions, times, persons, circumstances, and necessities as well as new information whereas the legal rulings follow their rationales in presence and absence” (pp. 20–22).
The man sounds like an advocate — the devil’s advocate, one must add — trying to downplay the demonic deviation of the salafi, takfiri Wahhabis. They are simply “ignorant people” who “have no good understanding.” They lack a “standard approach” to jurisprudence. They also fail to contextualize their legal rulings. Lovely. With friends like this, namely, court clerics and apologists for terrorists, we, Muslims, do not need enemies. They are already the “official leaders” of our religion! To add insult to injury, these scholars for dollars employ a supposedly religious and juristic language for the single purpose of treating others as if they were imbeciles. They use so-called technical language so that people with little education will say, “Wow. I don’t understand any of this but based on the terms used, it seems like the authors know a whole lot.” Ultimately, this is how people shamelessly accept falsehood, nonsense, and unjustifiable justifications.
We, of the Covenants Initiative, have bent over backward, using all resources available, and sparing no expenses, to expose so-called “Islamic terrorists” for what they really are: infidels, heretics, criminals, and psychopaths who, in addition, are avowed enemies of God, religion, and humanity. There is no doubt about it. We do not make excuses for them. We do not consider them to be “stupid young boys” as Hamza Yusuf does equating them with juvenile delinquents who stole candies, broke windows, and spray-painted brick walls. We hold them accountable for crimes against humanity that are unforgivable. And we hold accountable those who failed to fulfill their obligations and thereby allowed salafi Wahhabi takfirism to spread without an adequate response and rebuttal.
We, of the Covenants Initiative, financed with faith and armed with good intentions, have waged a grassroots public relations campaign to protect the image of the Prophet (pbuh), Islam, and Muslims in the eyes of non-Muslims. With arguments and evidence, we convinced scores of non-Muslims that true Islam protects the People of the Book and that takfiri terrorists were outside the fold of Islam. We were confronted, from day one, with so-called “traditional” Muslim scholars who insisted that takfiri terrorists were simply ignorant or misguided Muslims: they were sinners, but they were believing Muslims. Anyone who accepts this argument might as well believe the Snake in the Garden. A rapist may claim to be chaste; however, his actions show otherwise. As Imam ‘Ali al-Rida said, “Faith is belief in the heart, a speech of the tongue, an action by the limbs” (Majlisi). The Messenger of Allah himself made it clear that any so-called Muslim who persecuted and oppressed Christians was an enemy of God, the Prophet, and Islam. Such a person cannot be a Muslim. Such is the stance of the Covenants Initiative. But such is not the stance of the Supreme Council for Islamic Affairs for the Arab Republic of Egypt that continues to conceal The Covenants of the Prophet Muhammad with the Christians of the World.
It may well be that the rediscovery of the Covenants of the Prophet clued these Egyptian religious authorities that they had now better turn in the direction of a new wind that is blowing. To mention the Muhammadi Covenants would mean that they ignored or occulted them, placing themselves in a poor light. Acting as they did, they have a slim chance to seem as if they had always taken this position. Clearly, if liars and cowards are forced by circumstances to tell the truth and do the right thing, this is not a good sign for their souls, but it is a good sign for the situation. The state of their souls is an affair between them and Allah (swt), but if the situation improves — whether or not the Covenants Initiative had a hand in it, or whether or not the Covenants of the Prophet get the credit — then al-hamdulillah!
When the hypocrites among the Quraysh embraced Islam after the liberation of Makkah, Allah (swt) may not have conquered their hearts, but he did restrain their hands: all praise be to Allah, Lord of the Worlds, Owner of the Day of Judgement.
 

John Andrew Morrow

Thursday, January 03, 2019

Scholars for Dollars

Excesses of kings made palatable by the servility of scholars

Zafar Bangash
Three groups of people have caused immense damage to the Ummah in the history of Islam: the munafiqun, the Khawarij, and court scholars. The first group loosely translated as hypocrites, but more accurately as dual-loyalists, had emerged at the time of the Prophet (pbuh) in Madinah. ‘Abdullah ibn Ubayy ibn Sallul is known as the chief of munafiqs in history. He and 300 of his followers had broken away from the ranks of Muslims just prior to the Battle of Uhud. Throughout his life, he opposed and tried to undermine the Prophet’s mission. Allah (swt) has condemned the munafiqs in very harsh terms in the noble Qur’an (9:73) and Surah al-Munafiqun, in particular.
The Khawarij appeared at the time of Imam ‘Ali’s khilafah following the Battle of Siffin when the Islamic army was on the verge of defeating Mu‘awiyah’s rebellion. The Khawarij broke away from Imam ‘Ali and ultimately caused his death. A member of this gang stabbed Imam ‘Ali as he was heading to the masjid for Fajr prayers resulting in his martyrdom, plunging the Ummah into turmoil, and leading to the imposition of hereditary kingship.
The third group — the court ‘ulama’ (or “scholars for dollars” in contemporary parlance) — appeared when the khilafah was subverted into hereditary kingship. The committed ‘ulama’ (scholars) opposed these tyrants but were imprisoned and mercilessly tortured. In their place, the tyrannical rulers found pliant “scholars” whom they lavished with gifts, money, and titles to the do the king’s bidding. It was such court ‘ulama’ that distorted the message of the Qur’an and the prophetic Sunnah to lend legitimacy to illegitimate rulers. This has caused great damage to Islam and the Ummah.
These dirham/riyal/dollar scholars have continued their nefarious activities in the service of Ωulm and nifaq. To justify the kings’ illegitimate rule, they use a “hadith” quoted in the sunan of Muslim whose text has the Prophet (pbuh) saying something like,
“The best among your rulers are those whom you love and they love you in turn, those who pray [make supplication] for you and you pray for them. The worst of your rulers are those whom you hate and they hate you in turn, and you curse them and they curse you.” Someone asked, “O Messenger of Allah! Shall we confront them with swords?” The Prophet (pbuh) replied, “No, as long as they establish prayers among you. If you see from your rulers what you hate, hate the action they do but do not rebel against them.”
There are other versions of this hadith in al-Bukhari as well but the gist is clear.
Before discussing this hadith, let us outline a general principle of Islam. A Muslim ruler assumes office through ba‘yah (willing consent of the people, 48:18) and rules in all matters according to shura (mutual consultation among the committed Muslims, 42:38). Rulers who impose themselves through the sword have no legitimacy and must be opposed with full force.
Second, when the Prophet (pbuh) mentioned that they “establish prayers” committed scholars clearly understood this to mean that they implement the laws of Islam, or that Salah, in and of itself, ought to be a social and transformational activity in the lives of the Muslim community, that is, it “withholds [the Muslims] from moral deviation and social deviation” (29:45). The expression to “establish prayer” in this context is a linguistic device just like “freeing the neck of a person” (4:92). The latter is indicative of freeing a slave from bondage. The Qur’an is very clear, “And whoever does not judge according to what Allah has revealed, then it is they, they who are the kafirs [deniers of Allah’s power presence and authority]” (5:44).
There is also the Qur’anic command of enforcing the common good and prohibiting the munkar (social deviation, 3:104). A prophetic hadith is equally emphatic. Failing to do so would incur Allah’s condemnation of the Muslims.

Hamza Yusuf, vice president of the Forum for Promoting Peace in Muslim Societies. The forum has been denounced as a PR initiative to boost the UAE image abroad and deflect criticism by human rights groups. Human Rights Watch said, For someone as influential as Sheikh Hamza Yusuf to call the UAE ‘tolerant’ contributes and gives credibility to the authorities’ carefully tailored, yet false image as a progressive and rights respected state.”
Consider the case of the illegitimate rulers in the Muslim world today. Almost all of them were planted by the British colonialists and remain in power through the support of the imperialists and Zionists. They serve the interests of the enemies of Allah (swt) against the Muslims. The Muslim masses have not given them consent to rule.
In order to camouflage their illegitimacy, these rulers need the pronouncements of celebrity “scholars” to claim legitimacy. This was most recently demonstrated at a conference in Abu Dhabi at which people like the American convert Hamza Yusuf, his teacher Abdullah ibn Bayyah, and the South African hate preacher, Maulana Bham resorted to distorting the prophetic hadith to pacify people’s anger against rulers who are doing the bidding of imperialists and Zionists. These rulers are directly responsible for the deaths of hundreds of thousands of Syrians and Yemenis and the starvation of 22 million people in Yemen, including one million children.
Hamza Yusuf (his real name is Mark Hanson, born in Walla Walla, Washington state) insisted the UAE is a “tolerant society” since it even has a “ministry of tolerance”! He also said the country is committed to a civil society. Wonderful. He must have gotten a huge amount of bakhshish for making such a statement.
As Muslims negotiate their way through a maze of conflicting information, they should keep in mind the advice offered by Imam al-Ghazzali in his masterpiece, Ihya’ ‘Ulum al-Din, “Do not seek advice from scholars who stand as supplicants in the court of the ruler. Instead, seek out scholars at whose door the ruler stands in awe!”

Saturday, December 22, 2018

Traitors in our midst: The scholars of colonisation


By 5Pillars


Hamza Yusuf (r) and his teacher Abdullah bin Bayyah
American Muslim writer and lecturer, Daniel Haqiqatjou, says scholars like Hamza Yusuf and Abdullah bin Bayyah follow in a long line of ulama who have betrayed the Ummah in favour of supporting tyrant rulers.
What’s wrong with scholars like Hamza Yusuf, Abdallah bin Bayyah, Habib Ali Jifri, et al., supporting Arab dictators and legitimising their regimes?
There has been lots of analysis on the 2018 UAE forum for “promoting peace,” but some of this analysis misses the mark.
For example, what I keep reading over and over again is that Saudi and the UAE are not truly tolerant and they are not truly democracies, therefore it is a major violation for scholars to support them. This is silly. When did democratic secularism and liberal tolerance become the standard for determining legitimate vs. illegitimate governments as far as Islamic morality is concerned? This makes no sense.
Another criticism is that these are brutal regimes that have shed the blood of many innocent Muslims and oppressed many more. This is a good criticism. It boggles the mind how any informed person could excuse, much less defend, a scholar who has made a career out of praising clear oppressors and their regimes. (And to be fair, there are uninformed individuals who need to be shown the exact implications of their excuses and defenses of such scholars.)
It doesn’t matter if you think the scholar is a wali. What about the hundreds of thousands of people being killed and oppressed by the tyrants your “wali” is praising? You don’t think there were any awliya buried in the rubble or gunned down in Yemen, Palestine, Egypt, Syria, etc.?
Only your favorite scholar is a wali, but not any of the hundreds of thousands of Muslims killed and oppressed by these dictators? What about the scholars that these tyrants have jailed or executed? Is it not possible that those scholars were awliya? This whole “wali card” is ludicrously incoherent and, when you think about it, quite despicable.
Scholars on the payroll
Now the further point here is that these scholars are the successors of a long line of co-opted ulama who, historically, would use religious arguments to support the colonisers.
Since the beginning of the colonisation of the Muslim world over 200 years ago, the colonisers figured out that the best way to avoid backlash from the native Muslim population was to get traditional scholars on the payroll.
These scholars would then go around teaching about the virtues of loyalty to the new colonial masters and the values of peace and co-existence with them, the “wisdom” of their culture and religious traditions, etc.
These scholars would teach the community to disavow Islamic governance, to disavow khilafa, to disavow jihad, to disavow the Sharia, to eschew religious exclusivism, etc. They would emphasize this idea of الإنسانية قبل التدين (humanity before religiosity), essentially promoting the central tenet of liberal humanism.

Abdullah bin Bayyah has close connections with the UAE

In the end, anything that could possibly threaten colonial power was denounced as “backwards” and, ultimately, “un-Islamic.” This was to ensure that the Muslim community would not violently resist the new political order that had been brutally imposed upon them and would, instead, become docile, accepting subjects of the invading colonial force and its systematic domination.
Prominent scholars who played this role for colonizers over the past 150 years include figures like Muhammad Abduh, Uthman bin Yahya, Mohammad al-Hajwi, Mustafa al-Maraghi, Syed Ahmad Khan, and many more.
Of course, there were other scholars who fought the colonisers and considered resisting colonial invasion necessary jihad in defense of the Umma. These included figures like Omar Mukhtar, Abd al-Qadir al-Jazairi, Imam Shamil, Imam Bonjol, and Muhammad `Abd Allah al-Hasan.
These brave Muslim leaders were denounced as barbarians (what would be called “extremists” or “Islamists” in today’s nomenclature) by those religious scholars who had been bought by the colonisers. Thankfully, most of our ulama today are in the mold of these brave figures who fought on behalf of the Umma instead of the minority who betrayed it.
Betraying the Ummah
So, in a nutshell, that is what is so wrong with scholars legitimising secular Arab tyrants. They are endorsing the current day neocolonial project of secularising and subduing the Muslim world via brutal Western-backed puppet tyrants, who are themselves agents of Western imperialism.
This is precisely how these scholars are contributing to bringing the Ummah under the control of Western (and Israeli) powers economically, politically, socially, culturally, and, of course, religiously. (And notice how these “peace” initiatives always have Zionist representatives and representatives from Western security and anti-extremism agencies.)
This is the “peace” that they are promoting: Be peaceful while the West continues to rape you. Be peaceful while the oppressors continue to slaughter you. Be peaceful while the missionaries and the Zionists indoctrinate you and turn you away from your deen.
This is a huge betrayal of the Ummah and should be denounced in the strongest terms, lest this behavior become normalised in and acceptable to the community at large.
But let’s not forget the social justice imams in the West who are also legitimating tyranny. Instead of praising MBS, MBZ, et al., they praised Hillary Clinton, campaigned for her, endorsed her, etc.

Omar Mukhtar, the hero of the Libyan independence struggle

They went far beyond merely picking Clinton over Trump as the “lesser of two evils,” but instead expressed enthusiastic support and even giddy joy at the thought of electing her as president, and told the Muslim community that it is a religious obligation (fard) to vote for her, even though she was directly responsible for the destruction of at least one Muslim country and had threatened war against others. So, what makes these scholars for Hillary any different from the tyrant endorsers?
Abu Dharr related, “I was walking with the Prophet ﷺ and I heard him saying: “There is something I fear for my Ummah more than the Dajjal.” He repeated it three times. So I said: “O Messenger of Allah, what is it other than the Dajjal which you fear most for your Ummah?” He said: “Misguided Imams.” [Musnad Ahmad]
And as far as advancing the secularising, liberalising colonial project, a scholar doesn’t have to attend a UAE sponsored peace forum to do that. There are some imams who are doing that without even leaving the country. They simply endorse liberal political platforms and, in effect, if not intent, promote perennialism (the view that all “sacred” religions are acceptable to Allah), LGBT, radical feminism, abortion rights, dissolution of family, dissolution of marriage, etc., etc. s
Their vocal support of these left-wing political factions and policies colonises the Muslim minds in the West and furthers the colonial project in the Muslim world as well. They are providing the veneer of religious legitimacy to views that are deeply antithetical to Islam and are harmful to the interests of the Ummah writ large.
Furthermore, they are benefiting financially from these liberal connections and are granted access to many circles of power and influence within governmental and non-governmental organisations as well as think tanks, media, “charitable” funds and foundations, and billion-dollar companies. So, there is nothing more hypocritical than such social justice imams and activists acting indignant and holier-than-thou with respect to Hamza Yusuf, et al. They’re just the other side of the same coin.
Of course, the vast majority of imams and scholars in the West and the East have nothing to do with such evil, alhamdulillah. We need to support these ulama for their bravery and principled stance against the tide. These are the Omar Mukhtars of our times. May Allah bless these scholars of haqq and us with them, and protect the Umma from every evil tyrant and every traitorous scholar.
Daniel Haqiqatjou was born in Houston, Texas, and has studied Islam traditionally with respected ulama. He has written and lectured on contemporary issues surrounding Muslims and modernity over the past ten years, and has spoken at universities and mosques around the world.