Showing posts with label Ramin Mazaheri. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Ramin Mazaheri. Show all posts

Saturday, December 28, 2019

Blaming China for the Great Recession… to avoid emulating China’s (socialist-inspired) success

By Ramin Mazaheri 
The Chinese economy is, according to the Western financial media, both a huge success and also a huge failure. It has become an economic rival and superpower, and yet it is also accused of being the cause of the global slowdown.
Why such contradictory, nonsensical reporting?
When the economic panic hit in 2008 Washington needed a scapegoat, as it was US citizens who were the author of the crimes, so they turned to China. “Blaming China” emerged at the very beginning of the crisis.
This 10-part series (this is Part 7) uses as its jumping-off point the 2018 book Collusion: How Central Bankers Rigged the World by Nomi Prins, a former Wall Street executive who saw the light and is now informing on the crimes of Western imperialism-capitalism. Prins gives a thorough and chronological account of central banker doings in key areas – Mexico, China, Brazil, Japan and Europe – ever since US banker crimes set off the Great Recession in 2007. The essence of her thesis is that the US orchestrated collusion among the central bankers of many of the G20 economies and the Eurozone in order to primarily save busted US banks, and then also to maintain the 1%-enriching policies of QE, ZIRP and no-strings attached bailouts.
“Blaming China” emerged at the very beginning of the crisis: immediately after Lehman Brothers in September 2008, Prins notes: “To assign blame elsewhere for US economic problems, the US Treasury Department strongly criticised Chinese exchange rate policy and colluded with other developed countries to do the same.”
Who can forget Barry Obama’s constantly reading from his script and accusing China of “currency manipulation”? Obama’s “pivot to China”, replete with fake South Sea warmongering propaganda over desolate sandy islands, was clearly all an attempt to divert public attention from American financial crimes. “Currency manipulation” was always a code phrase for “financial policies independent from Washington and NYC”.
Rather incredibly, even though Timothy Geithner was the chief of the Federal Reserve Bank of New York – the locus of the banker crimes which created the Great Recession – he got a promotion by Barry Obama to Secretary of the Treasury. In an obvious sign of 1%er collusion and more proof (if anyone needs it) that the Democrats and Republicans are two sides of the same coin, Geithner reportedly also would have been the choice of Republican presidential candidate John McCain.
Print refers to a May 2012 visit along with Hillary Clinton to Beijing: “He (Geithner) was relentless, as if the entire future of the US economy was contingent upon minute differences in the dollar-yuan exchange rate.” It was an obviously absurd emphasis and analysis, and obviously propaganda.
Yes, China will act to protect their currency should disaster arise, but they have floated the yuan since 2016. And yet, years of Obama-era propaganda had their effect on Trump, who in August pressured the Treasury Department to formally declare China as a “currency manipulator”. The IMF didn’t back Trump up, but anti-China rhetoric has a proven track record of propaganda success, thanks to the Democrats false “pivot to China” instead of properly blaming Wall Street.
There is a huge fatal flaw in any Western criticism of Chinese “currency manipulation” – Japan. Since 2011 the yen has lost a whopping 42% of it’s value to the US dollar, making their exports hugely cheaper to buy – so why aren’t they considered to be “manipulators”? The answer is easy: Tokyo follows in lockstep with Washington and NYC in QE and elsewhere, whereas Red China refuses to join Western capitalist imperialism and sticks with the hugely successful “socialism with Chinese characteristics”.
The ‘Blame China game’ – how long can this go on despite all their success and the West’s failure?
A more recent diversionary tactic has been the pathetic reason that “China’s slowing growth” is the reason for the global economic slowdown. Anyone with a basic grasp of global economics knows that this is not just an inherently absurd argument, but a pathetic one.
China’s growth rate has been remarkably stable since 2012 (which was when the West went all-in on “QE forever for 1%er benefit”) despite the global slowdown, always falling between 6.6% and 7.9%. If we take China’s average annual GDP over the last decade to be around $10 trillion annually, a loss of 1% translates to $100 billion – hardly a sum which would have saved the $75 trillion per year world economy. Of course, this all rests upon the faulty idea that China is solely responsible for its minor economic slowdown.
The current tactic is just as absurd – that “Trump’s trade war” with China is the cause of the global economic woes.
Slightly decreased US-China bilateral trade caused by Trump’s sanctions cannot possibly wreck the global economy because the world is so much bigger than just the US and China. Sadly, the US has the biggest megaphone so anything they want to focus on gets over-amplified. US-China tariffs could shave a point of the US annual GDP and 1.5 points off China’s, perhaps, but that would still represent a loss of just 0.2% to the global economy.
Thus, if anything, the neoliberal Mainstream Media’s hype, hysteria and anti-Trump propaganda will probably do more damage to business and consumer confidence than Trump’s tariff increases.
What should be clear is that tiny fraction of global GDP and cannot possibly be more damaging than the neoliberal policies which created the original Great Recession, and then the Lost Decade of Eurozone economic growth and broad economic stagnation which were the pathetic result of men more neoliberal policies.
For example, what if the Eurozone – the biggest macro-economy in the world – had not chosen far-right economic austerity policies which resulted in a lost decade (2008-2017), which is turning into a lost score. They averaged just 0.6% of growth, which makes “blaming China” so absurd considering Beijing centrally-planned their way to results which (8.3% annual average over that period) were 14 times (1,400%) superior.
Adding just 1.4% of average annual growth to a rough average of $12 trillion to the annual Eurozone GDP over the last decade gives $168 billion. Over a decade that adds up to nearly $2 trillion, dwarfing the impact of China’s alleged “currency manipulation”, Trump’s tariffs and would more than offset China’s allegedly horrific GNP fall from 7.9% in 2012 to 6.7% in 2018. “It’s European austerity, stupid,” continues to be the right answer for why the global slowdown persists.
A fundamental problem is: why is decreased demand from China the problem, as opposed to the decreased demand in the US and EU caused by QE, which diverts money from infrastructure growth/consumers’ pockets, and austerity, which worsens infrastructure and takes money out of consumers’ pockets? Why must China pull all the weight?
The answer is: China must pull the weight because the West’s political and cultural elite has used the past 11 years to fundamentally exploit their own communities in neo-imperial fashion. The West has relied on China’s superior economic engine to achieve their incestuous neoliberal goals, but China cannot be blamed by anyone (except a Trotskyist).
China has become a superpower despite the Great Recession, but it’s not because of China
To paraphrase a very intelligent refrain of Prins’: What’s certain is that if, back in 2008, G7 central bankers wanted to do everything they could to empower their enemy – socialist China – they have succeeded wildly.
Beijing says thanks: The past decade has seen China soar so high they have broken the glass ceiling of a unipolar world. This was certainly not the case in 2007.
But it is not “China” which succeeded – that is essentially an ethnic or nationalist argument. China has policies which have nothing to do with lo mein and Fu Manchu moustaches – their policies are globally available and referred to as “socialism”.
It is socialism which is succeeding – saying “China has succeeded” is to divert, in an essentially jingoistic way, credit from socialism.
Of course, capitalists would stoop to any explanation in order to avoid the spread of the acknowledgment of socialism’s fundamentally-superior policymaking and humanity towards its citizens. Capitalists famously launched World War I to prevent the spread of socialism; socialists back then mistakenly assumed that enough people finally realised the stupidity of fighting wars t enrich bankers and were certain that the war would be called off due to a lack of grunt participants – they were dead wrong. A century later the West’s political intelligence and modernity is even worse than back then.
We should absolutely credit China, but the true credit must go to socialism – central planning, state ownership and control of the majority of the economy, actually listening to public opinion when formulating public policy, socialism’s guiding belief of empowerment of the “average person” and not the “exceptional person”; and its implicit rejection of capitalist policies – central planning limited to conjunction with the military, creating state assets via taxpayer money and then privatising them to the 1%, having as few legal restrictions on business as possible, policy formulated by bankers (and now primarily to serve the stock market).
China is fundamentally a Stalinist (socialism in one country) nation rather than a Trotskyist (socialism universally and all at once) nation. Maoism, which highly praised Stalinism of course, is constructed upon a generation of Stalinist success, and later disagreements cannot ever change socialist China’s childhood and adolescence. What Trotskyists and capitalist-imperialists both endlessly, stupidly and boringly criticise China for is the fact that they will gladly manufacture and sell the rope for you to hang yourself with.
China’s central bank is all about encouraging market reforms – of a Chinese socialist-market format and not neoliberal-market format, very significantly – which encourage your consumption and their savings & security. Being a leftist who wants to actually win and a patriot I say, “Yay for Stalinism (which is really “Marxism-Leninism-Stalinism”, of course) ” and “Yay for China”.
China does not want to be France or the US – whose economies are based mostly on consumer demand (i.e., household debt) – they want to be Germany. And that is what they have achieved over the past decade – these are the 2 countries with the biggest positive trade balance. Of course, the US wants China to be like the US, and thus less competitive, but Beijing takes no orders from Washington, unlike Paris.
China’s (Marxist-Leninist) Stalinist-Maoist ideology pushed it to be the only major central bank which actually pursued policies in the past 10 years which were designed to benefit China and the broad Chinese people and not New York City and Washington. Unsurprisingly, this has created growth (2008-17) 14 times better than both Europe and Japan, and 6 times better than the US. China is able to plan years and decades ahead, as every nation should and as Iran does, but this is against free market ideology.
China thus pursues this very sensible, moral and modern ideology and thus has reaped the benefits. As time goes on, and as neoliberal capitalism continues its inevitable trajectory to an even worse bust than in 2009, I see no logical reason why we cannot see China’s rise during the Great Recession as a historical trend towards more socialism around the world.
The USSR, after all, fell when Gorbachev imposed completely anti-socialist policies – the ending of central planning, the ending of the state being the biggest economic actor, the end of bans on capitalist propaganda, the weakening of the revolution party’s (Communist Party in the USSR) primacy. The USSR fell thanks to Western capitalism and not at all due to socialism – Gorbachev’s policies cannot be interpreted otherwise. China has rejected this Gorbachevian switch to “Westernism”, and at a time when the West and Japan doubled down on capitalism… and they have thrived.
Developing countries are noticing this. Western countries should notice it as well… thus the massive “blame China” propaganda campaign.
The reality is “emulate China” is the answer, but that’s a faulty nationalist claim. It’s not China which is superior, but having national policies influenced by socialism and not capitalism.
********************************************************
Ramin Mazaheri is the chief correspondent in Paris for Press TV and has lived in France since 2009. He has been a daily newspaper reporter in the US, and has reported from Iran, Cuba, Egypt, Tunisia, South Korea and elsewhere. He is the author of the books I’ll Ruin Everything You Are: Ending Western Propaganda on Red China and the upcoming Socialism’s Ignored Success: Iranian Islamic Socialism. His work has appeared in various journals, magazines and websites, as well as on radio and television.

Friday, November 29, 2019

Western counter-revolution tragically on display at gas price hike protests

by Ramin Mazaheri for The Saker Blog

(Ramin Mazaheri is the chief correspondent in Paris for Press TV and has lived in France since 2009. He has been a daily newspaper reporter in the US, and has reported from Iran, Cuba, Egypt, Tunisia, South Korea and elsewhere. He is the author of the books ‘I’ll Ruin Everything You Are: Ending Western Propaganda on Red China’ and the upcoming ‘Socialism’s Ignored Success: Iranian Islamic Socialism’.)
A simple question for you: are there, for lack of a better word, “counter-revolutionaries” in Ukraine, Hong Kong or Syria? By that I mean: do those nations have people on the far extremes of the political spectrum who will provoke, take advantage of and even relish in violence against their governments?
Obviously, only a liar or somebody foolishly playing devil’s advocate would not respond that, yes, in these nations there are many such persons – the proof is overwhelming.
So why would it be so hard to believe that there are such persons – counter-revolutionaries – in Iran, and that they hijacked recent protests over gas price hikes to provoke, take advantage of and devilishly relish in death and violence against the government? Iran, unlike the nations I listed – and unlike almost every nation, period – actually had a popular revolution for extremists to counter in the first place.
Iranians are reminded of their exceptionalism when, for example and for certain, such far-right groups drove on a motorcycle to a gas hike protest, fired on the crowd, and fled.
Such vicious, armed people – the allies of the governments of many of those reading this article – are obviously the worst, most anti-democratic type of criminal. Their goal is just as obvious – to foment a counter-revolution in Iran.
What is unfortunate regarding the West’s coverage of the national tragedy which was the violence at the Iranian gas hike protests is that there isn’t the barest mention of this very real, very life-and-death, very accurate reality.
The term “counter-revolutionary” staggers the Western mind in its tracks – they seem to think it has been consigned to history? Or because there are no revolutionary countries in the West, and many ones filled with neo-imperial propaganda, perhaps they cannot even conceive of the existence of counter-revolutionaries?
The impact of such naivety is profoundly deadly.
Iranian counter-revolutionaries are aware of this yawning Western blind spot, and so they know that every single Iranian death – when reported by Amnesty International or Western journalists – will be blamed on the government and national security forces even though every Iranian knows that this is false and impossible.
The sweet, good-hearted innocents at Amnesty and the desk-only journalists in London, Paris and New York City simply do not have the experience, or maybe even the editorial approval, to write this truthful question asked by every Iranian: how many innocent deaths were caused by counter-revolutionaries, and how many counter-revolutionaries pushed their far-right views all the way to their own demise?
We don’t know, as an official government report of the deaths has not yet been released. But everyone in Iran has an idea of the answer – a lot of them.
And there were many innocent deaths of protesters, too – this is why the gas hikes protests are a tragedy.
And we know, because no one denies the right to self-defense, that the government simply had to fire back: when somebody drives by on a motorcycle and opens fire… what is the alternative for any civil servant working in security?
What needs to be impressed on non-Iranians is that there are regular protests in Iran and that they are not violent. Iran is not Cuba, which has no protests besides the “Ladies in White”. Iran is also not China, which has almost too many protests to keep track of. Iran is also not the US, which seemingly forgot how to protest in between the end of their Vietnam invasion and the election of Donald Trump. So if Iran has many protests which do not get violent, why did these?
The gas price hikes were launched without warning, and I assume it is because the government knew that they would be very unpopular… but they didn’t want them to be explosive.
And by “explosive” I mean that they didn’t want the old-money monarchists, the insane MKO who are even less popular than the criminal monarchists, ISIL (an attack of theirs caused 70 innocent casualties in Tehran in 2017), the cynical mercenaries bought by Western nations and their Arab monarch puppets, the secret service agencies of such nations which of course target Iran (is this is not a great number of people, already?) to have time to plan their drive-by shootings, building bombings and arsons at a moment of heightened social unrest. I would say it’s not that the government wanted to catch the Iranian people by surprise, but to catch these illegitimate, undemocratic, far-right, definitely “counter-revolutionary” forces by surprise.
Were there legitimate protests against the gas hikes? As I mentioned, of course, and nor were they unusual or unexpected.
But attacking a police station, probably to get weapons – it is a normal journalistic question to ask if these are the works of counter-revolutionaries or “normal protesters”, regardless of the passport such attackers hold? Take a moment to imagine what the Western mainstream response would be be if French Yellow Vests did that – the idea that any of them would receive the barest sliver of public support is preposterous.
Just like with the Yellow Vests, the West lies about the true authors of protest violence
This should be stating the obvious to anyone with a rudimentary political awareness, but in the Iranian context a “far-rightist” is synonymous with a “counter-revolutionary”. This is the case of every society which had a revolution since 1917, and Iran is no different. There is no “far-right” party in China, Cuba, Iran or in any revolutionary nation because revolutionary nations all banish/declare war on far-right forces, after all.
It is difficult for Westerners to understand the recent Iran protests because they are denied this historical-political honesty and context about Iran. Their difficulty is further compounded by the fact that the top NGOs and the Western mainstream media cannot or will not admit that in Western nations the far-right is firmly a part of their establishments, unlike in Iran.
Look at the Yellow Vests in France: across the West they have been portrayed as violent, far-right thugs masquerading as protesters. The reality is – and I have been there nearly every Saturday and can testify – the scenes of extreme violence always come from Black Bloc members who infiltrate the protests. Black Bloc is totally detrimental to the legitimate pro-democracy and socioeconomic demands of the Yellow Vest protesters; their ultra-left anarchism is totally unwanted; they are easily infiltrated by rogue cops, who merely have to wear black; French riot cops don’t lift a finger to stop Black Bloc’s vandalism – they are either colluding or, certainly, told to allow violence to occur in order to discredit the Yellow Vests.
The Yellow Vests are innocent protesters, just like the Iranian gas hike protesters – they are unarmed and cannot possibly stop people from committing unreasonable violence. Therefore, how can the West blame the Yellow Vests for violence they disavow and have no part in? I don’t know… but that is certainly what they have done for a calendar year.
The real violence comes not from Iranian gas price hike protesters nor Yellow Vests (who started following a gas price hike) in either of their situations, but from outside, unwanted, self-interested forces with incredibly dubious democratic intentions.
It is crystal clear: Just as the West doesn’t report that it is Black Bloc committing violence and not the Yellow Vests protesters, the West also doesn’t report that it is far-right/counter-revolutionaries who are the authors of violence in Iran.
The Iranian government must absolutely punish police wrongdoings whenever proven. They must not be like France, which last week finally opened their first trial for police brutality despite the full calendar year of incredibly calculating repression. Iran has had a short-lived paroxysm of violence – the French government cold-bloodedly wages police brutality with sadistic regularity and precision.
However, comparing France and Iran is to compare apples and bowling balls. France’s government doesn’t have to spend one second thinking about catching “anti-France” forces “by surprise”. France is not beset by many rich, far-right groups/nations/monarchs/ex-monarchs/terrorists who get out of bed in the morning with the sole goal of destabilising their national system.
Iranians, unlike the French, know this article is full of truths.
They know that because they know what propaganda is: France just had its bloodiest day since being kicked out of Beirut some 40 years ago, as 13 French soldiers died while fighting in Mali. President Emmanuel Macron immediately tweeted, “These 13 heroes had just one goal: To protect us.” Now that is laughable propaganda about France’s “one goal”!
Nobody can believe that, but many in France and the West do – all part of the “war on terrorism”, right? But Malians know better: A January 2018 poll in the capital of Bamako revealed that 80% of respondents believe that France’s army is in Mali only to defend its own interests. Which is, of course, obviously the case. Macron immediately and robotically made his phony “war on terror” claim because he knows such scaremongering propaganda is desperately needed to stop honest discussion.
Just as many Westerners will believe Macron’s false propaganda, many Westerners will believe 100% that the Iranian government is responsible for every recent death. The emphatic, self-righteous certainty with which Western propaganda insists this falsehood and inaccuracy is appalling.
Iranians believe otherwise – some told me the majority of the dead were ardent counter-revolutionaries. This is a common perception, but it cannot be verified yet – what’s certain is that innocents did die, and that is a tragedy.
US clarifies its ‘diplomacy’: allow a counter-revolution or starve to death
The real economic problem in Iran is the Western sanctions blockade. Such sanctions are made to create instability to the point of civil war. The West also funds groups which are designed expressly to create the most sparks precisely at times of heightened dissatisfaction and difficulty.
Those are all facts, and why would they not have been on full display at the gas price hike protests?
They were, but honest analysis of Iranian politics has few forums available. This article has discussed and analysed these rarely-discussed realities which Iranians know well and will not deny.
In Iran the violence comes from an ultra-violent right but the West naively acts as if such a political sector in Iran does not exist. The West also naively acts as if within their own nations there is not establishment support of far-right, conservative, certainly “counter-revolutionary” ideas and groups. It should thus be clear why the West is so unwilling to support revolutionary Iran in maintaining its revolution.
The West allies with the far-right across the world. Iranians know this, and they also pay the price. They pay the price at the gas pump, as the West’s blockade has undoubtedly forced the recent price increase, and they pay the price in so very many litres of blood, just as they have done ever since the beginning of the Western-forced invasion by Iraq in 1980.
Why can such realities not be even be broached in Western media or by Western NGOs? To this, I have no satisfactory answer.
US Secretary of State Mike Pompeo just said, essentially, that Iran has to have a counter-revolution if “they want their people to eat”. As Yemen proves (in case North Korea did not do this already) – the US is fine with starvation as a “legitimate” political tactic.
What is certain, sadly, is that no Western journalist called Pompeo a “far-rightist”, a “fascist” or a “counter-revolutionary” – they all simply nodded and reported what he said without question, contestation or a hint of shame.
The counter-revolutionaries lost in Iran recently, again; Iran mourns that they still keep trying. The nation mourns most of all because of the West’s never-ending blockade against Iranian self-determination.
The terroristic inhumanity of their starvation-strangulation-sanction policy is something which can not be broached in Western media, NGOs, governments or among many Western citizens, as well.

Wednesday, November 20, 2019

Iran vs. Mexico: ‘economic inflows’ versus ‘economic independence’

by Ramin Mazaheri for The Saker Blog
The principle is the same as when the French loaned money to North African beys in the 19th century: barring your perfect money management and zero outside shocks, foreign capital aims to ultimately control all your natural resources, capital and labor market for as long as possible.
Hey, bey? Did you think they’d be glad you repaid your loan? Don’t you know that non-Islamic finance means that if they can’t bankrupt you then at least they want to keep juicing you for as long as possible?
But these monarchs’ money skills naturally included a great talent for extravagance, self-aggrandising projects and unaccountable corruption, and thus they soon found their king’s cabinets filled with White European faces, mainly in the seats reserved for those controlling the kingdom’s purse strings and security.
Hard-core capitalists in developing markets are always clamouring for more foreign investment – Western Mainstream Media tells everyone that this is the only way they can ever possibly raise funds.
However, Iran’s “Resistance Economy” takes the opposite tack – it generates internal demand and internal self-sufficiency. Naysayers will say that this the long, slow road, but how can anyone point to the positive role of QE and foreign capital in the last 10 years? If you think you can, you didn’t read about how Brazil went from the top of the world in 2011 to chaos in just a few years in the previous part of this 10-series, QE paid for a foreign buying spree: developing countries hurt the most.
One of the good things about the arrival of Donald Trump is that there has been some – not much, but some – Western ink spilled regarding how bad NAFTA has been for the average Central American: NAFTA destroyed local farmers, who couldn’t compete with (heavily taxpayer subsidized) US farm corporations, and the mass exodus from Central America which helped Trump to office is a direct result of the damage wrought by NAFTA.
From 1994-2014 Mexican real GDP per person grew 18.6%, whereas from 1960-1980 that figure was more than five times higher, at 98.7%. Mexico’s per capita GDP growth from 1994-2014 was half that average growth of the rest of Latin America, and its poverty rate is unchanged. The conclusion is simple: “If NAFTA had been successful in restoring Mexico’s pre-1980 growth rate – when developmentalist economic policies were the norm – Mexico today would be a relatively high income country, with income per person significantly higher than that of Portugal or Greece.”
(Remember the word “developmentalist” for later.)
Such real data confirming NAFTA’s failure for Mexico can be under-reported, but not denied.
What’s never, ever discussed – because the US press views it as such a positive – is how deadly NAFTA was to Mexican banks.
With NAFTA Mexico’s leadership chose economic inflows over economic independence, and thus true, national economic development.
The land of Emiliano Zapata no longer
Mexicans once knew what a risk US bankers posed. After the US led the world into the Great Depression Mexico wisely banned foreign banks from operating in Mexico for almost the next six decades.
However, NAFTA immediately made banking one of the very first industries it forced open to foreign competition. The impact was immediate, and stunning.
This series uses as its jumping-off point the 2018 book is Collusion: How Central Bankers Rigged the World by Nomi Prins, a former Wall Street executive who saw the light and is now informing on the crimes of Western imperialism-capitalism. Prins gives a thorough and chronological account of central banker doings in key areas – Mexico, China, Brazil, Japan and Europe – ever since US banker crimes set off the Great Recession in 2007. The essence of her thesis is that the US orchestrated collusion among the central bankers of many of the G20 economies and Eurozone in order to primarily save busted US banks, and then also to maintain the 1%-enriching policies of QE, ZIRP and no-strings attached bailouts.
“By 2015, five foreign banks, led by Citigroup/Banamex, owned 64% of Mexican financial assets, more external bank ownership than any other country. The top five banks held 72 percent of the country’s total financial assets. Only one – Banorte – was local. Foreign banks in Mexico, armed with cheap money, could afford to be less accountable for speculative activities.”
Mexico went from being totally protected and self-reliant to having a higher degree of foreign bank ownership than any country in the world. Mexican banking policy is thus no longer made in Mexico City, but in New York City and Washington.
A rarely discussed reason why this is so dangerous is because during times of crisis foreign banks liquidate their assets in foreign countries before they ever touch the motherland. To paraphrase Prins: Western nations worry about their banks, emerging markets worry about feeding their people.
In practice this means that when there is financial turmoil – and busts are guaranteed in the capitalist cycle – Mexican clients are going to have their loans called in or terminated at a moment’s notice, fatally gutting their development projects or whatever they are working on; capital will precipitously leave the country, and leave the native citizens deep in debt and with a half-finished home/factory/store. This was explained in detail in the previous part of this series, as was how since US QE 3 newly-printed money has been stuffed into developing countries.
In 2016 the IMF relayed that emerging and developing economies are receiving $1.5 trillion of capital inflows per year. Again, this money is going to rush out when capitalism has its next inevitable crisis.
But it’s worse this time around, and we can return to Prins quote: “Foreign banks in Mexico, armed with cheap money, could afford to be less accountable for speculative activities.” (emphasis mine)
Just as it has in the West, this recent wave of loans to developing countries has gone to bond markets, stock markets (Mexico’s stock market has appreciated some 60% since regaining its pre-crisis level in 2010), real estate in the capital and other 1%-er investments instead of the “real” economy. Money will rush back out in the next crisis, and this time asset prices will crumble even worse because Western-allied developing nations have created their own “subprime entire economy crisis”.
How much of the bill will have to picked up again by the average person, and how many state assets will have to be sold? If this cycle looks familiar, it should – it is called “capitalism”.
Since 2008 China has risen, Iran has resisted, Mexicans have relocated
It is pure political nihilism – as well as a journalistic inaccuracy – to say TINA (There Is No Alternative). China is one model, and Iran is another – both are doing much better than Mexico.
China, Iran and a few others realise that capital markets might be good for an individual banker but they are not a force for social good: the Great Recession was caused by capital markets devouring the lower-class housing market in the US, and further damage has been created by trying to appease capital markets via the “confidence fairy”, austerity measures and QE. Mexico, in an obvious recognition of this reality, has gone left by electing Andrés Manuel López Obrador.
But for AMLO to really succeed he’d have to be Zapata Jr. and re-declare fiscal war on the US by instituting a moratorium on US banker involvement. The US would respond that this is crazy expressly because of the existence NAFTA-type globalisation – which has failed – even though it seems like a rational response to a crisis created by criminal US banks (which remain unpunished).
Why would ending US banking sound crazy?
Mighty Mexico is basically a third of all of Latin America, and they have oil. Are you telling me that in order to succeed they simply must follow the lead of their northern neighbours, and even when El Norte is full of criminal bankers? Iran and Mexico aren’t China-big, but they aren’t Pago Pago.
I don’t know why reclaiming independence from the West would not be considered a good idea? Prins agrees:
“During and after the 2008 financial crisis, countries exhibiting the most growth were not those that followed the Fed’s lead to zero (interest rates), or the ECB and BOJ’s rush to negative rates. The most resilient were the transitioning economies, like China, that developed local infrastructure and partnered with regional and longer-distance partnerships on long-term growth projects instead of harnessing monetary collusion.”
It is both surprising and totally unsurprising that Prins makes no mention of Iran’s “resistance economy” in her book. However, Prins may not realise that what she discusses as an alternative is essentially what Khamenei – that indisputable revolutionary – and many others in Iran keep pushing, only in Western translation: “New Developmentalism”.
Prins’ book covers Mexico, but Prins gives a tiny amount of space to this idea in her section on Brazil, probably because Brazil is more independent from the US than is Mexico and is pushing for status quo change via BRICS. And it is also because the theory is promoted by former Brazilian finance minister Luiz Bresser-Pereira. Prins relates:
“According to Bresser, imperialism still existed.”
OMG,I have to stop for just a second there. Such a sentence is why the ex-Wall Streeter Prins makes an honorable snitch but cannot possibly be a leftist: She thinks it’s necessary to cite a source to say that imperialism still exists, LOL! This also why her book gets reviewed in mainstream media but many great leftist books go totally unnoticed. But I’ll continue where Prins left off:
“The US system impeded stability and autonomy in developing countries. The reality, he said, is that ‘countries like Brazil don’t really need foreign money or finance.’ Instead, they must develop more domestic finance and investment opportunities, which would also alleviate currency crises and wars.
He considered economies to be nationalistic: the world is still divided into nation-states that compete more than cooperate, which threatens social progress in general. Rather than being spent on people, cheap money (QE, ZIRP, etc.) constantly seeks to expand itself. The cheaper the money, Bresser argued, the more it can be used to help people. Yet, in practice, that didn’t occur, especially in the developed world. Instead, fabricated money was used as a weapon in financial warfare. It altered domestic and international power structures by furnishing capital to the G7 nations and their banks so that they could speculate globally, especially in developing countries, in markets rather than in direct economic investment that benefitted populations.”
In my margin notes I wrote: “Duh”.
However, this is only because I have listened to Iranian politicians like Khamenei, Mahmoud Ahmadinejad and others for quite some time. This type of discourse is part and parcel of Iran’s “Resistance Economy” ideology: developing domestic capabilities, because that makes Iran stronger, whereas reliance on foreign abilities will ultimately lead to our Persian rugs being pulled out from under us. And, to an Iranian, life without many rugs is unthinkable!
Westerners like Prins have probably never heard such discourse and has been told that, LOL, there is no economic component of Iran’s revolution to possibly relay and to consider. Even the West’s most advanced economic whistle-blowers like Prins have been economically indoctrinated to the point where they are apparently not sure that imperialism still exists. Such is Western philosophical life after the fall of the USSR….
However, given their similarities, the Iranian economic model is a great fit for a country like Mexico. And, of course, this anti-globalisation and “economic patriotism-first” model is exactly what was used by the US, UK, France and everyone else to get their economies to the top-most rung in the first place.
“New Developmentalism”, “Resistance Economy” – whatever you want to call it, the realisation should be that whatever gets Mexicans to want to stay in Mexico is win-win: Mexicans don’t have their communities emptied out of desperation, American workers aren’t angry at wage-reducing competition, and only those free spirits who want to emigrate do so but from a place of security instead of resignation.
Developmentalism is also an accurate description of what China used during their Cultural Revolution, as I detailed in this 8-part series earlier this year: economic opportunities were created at the peasant and local level – both had unprecedented, astonishing booms in agricultural and industrial projects – via the cooperative use of local money, resources and talents, not foreign ones.
Developmentalism is also exactly what Burkina Faso engaged in during the 1980s revolution led by Thomas Sankara. There are many Burkinabes in Paris, and it is incredibly inspirational to see them light up when I ask them about the Sankara era.
In just four years, before he was assassinated by a French-led coup, Burkina Faso underwent a Cuban-sized rebirth via undertaking a Resistance Economy which closely paralled China’s Cultural Revolution-era economic explosion (which set the stage for China’s 1980s explosion). Rejection of foreign capital was an absolutely key plank, and perhaps what Sankara may be most remembered for: “Debt is a cleverly managed reconquest of Africa. It is a reconquest that turns each one of us into a financial slave.”
Debt slavery at home and abroad of the common man… this is what capitalism has always aspired to, from fuedalism to sharecropping to digital neoliberalism.
Incredibly, despite the crimes of the Great Recession and the obvious failure of their economic ideology, Westerners have been able to increase their debt stranglehold over the past decade in places like Latin America.
The last decade has shown the logical, rapacious progression of neoliberalism as well as the success of Resistance/Developmentalism-based economies. Pass it on to Poncho, because Mexico would make an invaluable ally in the fight against US domination of Latin America (excepting Cuba).
And, a final reminder: yes, imperialism does still exist.

Monday, November 04, 2019

Hiding the West’s ongoing neo-colonialism in Lebanon via blaming Iran (1/2)

by Ramin Mazaheri for the Saker Blog
I have spoken with many in France’s huge expatriate Lebanese community – and from all groups – and not a single person has ever claimed that Iran was the power behind the scenes in Lebanon. Without fail I was told that this title belongs to France.
It shouldn’t be surprising: France completely devised modern Lebanon.
Many Lebanese don’t like to be reminded of this, but Lebanon is an artificial nation which France constructed entirely on the basis of racism: just as Zionists to the south wanted a “Jewish nation”, Lebanon was hacked off of Syria in 1920 to create a new Christian-majority nation.
That’s a “no longer relevant” tale of divide and conquer to some, even though a few centenarians may still remember the actual event.
France also devised Lebanon’s sectarianism-enshrining, woefully unmodern constitution, which has ensured divisive identity politics ever since.
Thus, just as Israel is a little part of the USA in the Middle East, Lebanon is the older, French version. The saying, “Beirut is the Paris of the Middle East” could not be more correct.
And yet, were an alien to visit and read Western mainstream media coverage of the recent protests in Lebanon it would not imagine that France ever had any role in Lebanon, much less a prominent role there today.
Instead, Western headlines and reports all push the totally absurd claim that Iran has somehow become the neo-colonial master in Lebanon. Somehow – and via the poorest, most marginalised sectors of Lebanese society, no less – Iran has been able to usurp a century of French power.
Furthermore, despite the century of French involvement it is not France but Iran which is responsible for the corruption that has pushed so many Lebanese into the streets.
Apparently Iran took power and also became corrupt so very quickly that the Lebanese themselves didn’t even realise it! The idea is laughable.
Or perhaps: the Lebanese themselves don’t know what is actually going on in their own country – the West knows better.
These are the kind of ideas only a Westerner could believe.
The reason is simple: advertising works. Astute observers already realise that when it comes to the Middle East every problem – big or small – is blamed on Iran in the West.
However, what’s rarely examined is how this very real Iranophobia allows the West to obscure places where their neo-colonial machinations could not be more obvious, such as in Lebanon.
If it’s not Iran then it must be Hezbollah, but it can never be France
If the West cannot destroy Iran in 2019 they will happily settle for destroying Hezbollah.
There are two types of political parties: those which citizens fight to destroy (like the Yellow Vests and the three mainstream political parties in France), and those which citizens fight to preserve. There is no doubt which camp Hezbollah belongs to.
Hezbollah is the “Party of God” and the party of Lebanon’s poor, but many insist they are not a political party but a larger “resistance movement”. Amal is a political party allied with Hezbollah, and Western media coverage is doing their best to lump both in with the older, Western-aping, billionaire-backed parties which are the true cause of the recent corruption protests.
Hezbollah has always said they would never turn their guns on Lebanese, and even if the West doesn’t want anyone to know that the Lebanese certainly do. They know that without Hezbollah southern Lebanon would be called “Northern Israel” today. Or, nearly as badly, it would still be the State of Free Lebanon, that stillborn Israeli client from the early 1980s which no country besides Israel recognised. (That’s just more “no longer relevant” history to Western mainstream journalists of course.)
The West hates Hezbollah for the same reason Lebanon supports it – Hezbollah is what ensures Lebanon’s security from repeated, deadly, infrastructure-ruining Israeli invasions. After the 2006 war with Israel most Sunnis and an estimated 50% of Christians supported Hezbollah – that’s hardly sectarian hatred.
After saving the Lebanese from Israel on multiple occasions, the undeniable and enduring popular support of Hezbollah and Amal comes from their education, health and other social welfare organisations. Southern Lebanon is most notable not for being mostly Shia but for its extreme poverty, which was the result of decades of neglect from Paris-allied Beirut. Hezbollah and Amal helped reverse that, to the extreme embarrassment and consternation of France, Israel and their many sectarian militias, mafias and political puppets in Lebanon.
And yet despite being so late arriving to power, despite being anchored in the poorest regions, despite decades of neglect from Beirut, and despite illegal and inhuman US-led sanctions on Hezbollah… the West wants us to believe that Hezbollah and Amal are the ones responsible for the corruption at the heart of the current protests!
One has to wonder: if these two groups are so corrupt then where is the money, because it is certainly not in southern Lebanon?
The idea that Hassan Nasrallah, who can make a fair claim to be the most popular Muslim leader and hero in the world currently, is about to fall due to decades of corruption in Beirut is an absolute fantasy which can only be taken seriously in the West.
Again, what we have here is another situation where Western propaganda is aiming to manipulate legitimate unhappiness created by long-tenured Western client politicians in order to deny the West’s neo-colonial culpability. The legitimate demands in Yemen, Palestine and Iraq are all being portrayed as being caused by an Iranian neo-colonialism which does not exist, when the real culprit is the very real and very accurately-named Western neo-colonialism.
The West, of course, may speak of neoliberalism but never neo-colonialism.
The long-running source of corruption in Lebanon: Western-allied, neoliberal & neocolonial puppets
I would imagine that up to this point a Lebanese reader has been quite bored – I have only relayed things which he or she already knows quite well. But perhaps a Lebanese expatriate in Brazil or the United States – who cannot visit Lebanon so easily and who foolishly relies on the Western mainstream media – may not know some of these things.
What most Lebanese know quite intimately is that they no longer have a “real” economy. Their export capabilities are so woeful that scrap iron was their third top export in 2017, at just $179 million.
This is unsurprising, because Lebanon’s longtime function was to serve as France’s Middle East banking haven, with Switzerland-level secrecy laws dating to 1956. However, they have increasingly been replaced by Qatar and other Persian Gulf nations.
Banking is still a strong sector of their economy, but now mainly due to the huge number of remittances (only 4 million Lebanese live in Lebanon but there are an astonishing 8-12 million living as expatriates).
All this wouldn’t be a problem if Lebanon had a strong government to centrally plan and direct their limited economy, and also a government which cared for their 99% instead of their 1%, but Lebanon has neither of these things. The reason for this has nothing to do with Hezbollah, but everything to do with the real root of the current protests.
After the Taif Accords in 1989 and the fall of the USSR in 1991, Rafic Hariri, who became Lebanon’s richest man/prime minister thanks to earning billions via construction with the House of Saud, embarked on the massive “Horizon 2000” privatisation plan, which sold off the major industries and real estate of the Lebanese people. Hariri, in classic Western fashion, privatised the people’s wealth mainly to himself, but also to French companies.
Hariri’s “There Is No Alternative” (to neoliberalism) plan also included massive efforts to attract foreign investment, which ballooned the national debt – the funds were not spent on the poor, of course, but lined the pockets of the rich. France is always the one who organises the regular international debt conferences to restructure Lebanon’s debt, reaping compound interest payments all the while. Rafic Hariri was yet another Arab aristocrat who yoked his people to Western debtors for generations.
Hariri also banned protests and encouraged bribes and kickbacks to the army in order to continue his neoliberalisation drive totally unfettered.
For these reasons (i.e., he made them rich via ruthless self-interest) the assassinated Hariri is worshiped in the West as a true martyr to the neoliberal faith, whereas his corruption in Lebanon was infamous and resented. The most common phrase about him is, “He treated the state as if it was his home.”
His son Saad could have hardly done worse, but he certainly has tried: $16 million to a bikini model mistress, getting abducted by the Saudis and then resigning on their TV, etc. Saad Hariri has held so very many closed-door meetings with France’s president over the past decade that I truly just got tired of covering it for PressTV – I think he must have a private room at Élysée Palace?
What I have described is three decades of oligarchic economic corruption, mismanagement and economic far-right neglect, and here is the bill: At 158% Lebanon’s debt to GDP ratio is the 5th highest in the world, just behind Greece.
Few commentators go further, however: Lebanon’s external debt to GDP ratio is only around 45%, implying that there is a lot of money in Lebanon but held – in an inherently corrupt manner – by extremely few hands. And this is certainly the case: Lebanon’s richest 0.1% own the same amount of wealth as the poorest 50 percent, making Lebanon one of the most unequal countries in the world.
Lebanon is thus an economically rudderless, economically unequal and economically corrupt nation, and it is quite obvious that none of this happened because of late-arriving, poor-loving Hezbollah or Iran.
It is absolutely preposterous to believe that Iran or Hezbollah is the source of Lebanon’s inequality and corruption, and thus that they could be the true target of protesters. The Western Mainstream Media – mostly privately owned, incredibly chauvinistic – is trying to sell an anti-Iran/anti-Hezbollah conspiracy even though the Lebanese themselves will not be fooled by it for one second.
The West, especially France, created, applauded and profited Lebanon’s economic corruption via their unstinting support for the corrupt and despised Hariris, and also Israel’s expatriate-inducing, infrastructure destroying invasions. France’s role in saddling Lebanon’s economy with two million of Syrian and Palestinian refugees is also glossed over by the Western mainstream media, of course.
I hope the true profiteers of Lebanon’s misery will finally be called to account. The Lebanese know who has robbed them, and it is not Hezbollah, Nasrallah or Iran.
Part 2 in this series will give more details on the corrupt Lebanese politicians of today, most of who are associated with violent militias armed and funded by France and/or Israel.
Ramin Mazaheri is the chief correspondent in Paris for Press TV and has lived in France since 2009. He has been a daily newspaper reporter in the US, and has reported from Iran, Cuba, Egypt, Tunisia, South Korea and elsewhere. He is the author of the books I’ll Ruin Everything You Are: Ending Western Propaganda on Red China and the upcoming Socialism’s Ignored Success: Iranian Islamic Socialism. 

Thursday, August 01, 2019

Sanctions on Khamenei? Ending the myth of the ‘Millionaire Mullah’

by Ramin Mazaheri for The Saker Blog (cross-posted with PressTV)

There are many pieces of nonsense about Iran which are fervently believed in the West but which have zero credibility inside Iran. “Millionaire Mullahs” is a concept which has captivated the Western imagination, even though it has no basis in reality.
The idea of “Millionaire Mullahs” was conceived in 2003 by the uber-capitalist magazine Forbes. What’s worse, it was created by their longtime Russia editor… Russia during the age of Yeltsin, when neoliberal capitalism was shamelessly gutting all the nations of the former Soviet Union and transferring the longtime assets of the people/state to Western high finance.
The idea “sounds right” to Western ears for three likely reasons: they are often ardently secular and suspicious of all religious authority, they assume all Muslim religious authorities are as rabidly capitalist as the Roman Catholic Church has often been, and also because they know nothing about the revolutionary (unique) and inherently anti-capitalist post-1979 changes to the Iranian economy.
Let’s stop with the nonsense: being a mullah in Iran usually places one in the lower middle class. Iranian Shia clergy do not have extravagant lifestyles, and they have certainly chosen the wrong calling if that was their aim. Furthermore, the Iranian press – which casts an open and intensely critical eye on the government, contrary to Western perceptions – would absolutely have a field day were there any mullahs living the lavish lives of millionaires. The entire idea is absurd and – rather crucially – unproven.
The subject has come up again, due to the incredibly foolish sanctions by the US against Supreme Leader Ali Khamenei.
Khamenei, like his predecessor in the Leader post, Ruhollah Khomeini, and his family are known by all Iranians for living simple lifestyles and for possessing absolutely common levels of personal wealth. How does all of Iran know this? Well, doesn’t everyone in the US know the general financial background of Trump?
But first, a bit of background for non-Iranians: Khamenei is from clerical families on both sides of his parents. They were not rich clerics, but lower-middle class, like the majority of Iranian clergy. The 1979 Revolution was decidedly class-based – it was called “the revolution of the barefooted” – and this extended to the clerical class as well, so it should not be surprising that someone from Khamenei’s class background rose so high.
Because clerics are humans, they have a right to have varied personal interests: ex-Iranian President Hashemi Rafsanjani was rather an Iranian Islamic Revolution anomaly – a revolutionary cleric from a rich background (pistachio farmers) – and he had a personal interest in the affairs of business. It is common knowledge that Khamenei has never evinced this interest, and nor have his several brothers, who are also clerics – the family’s interests are clearly religion and politics.
Furthermore, simply check out his speeches on YouTube (and perhaps while you still can do so, as PressTV was banned from YouTube in April): Khamenei is always discussing the example of his namesake, Imam Ali, the personification of personal austerity in Islam. “Shia” means “partisan of Ali”, so non-Muslims should be able to easily imagine that if Khamenei was constantly exhorting everyone to follow “Pope” Ali’s worthy example, yet not following it himself… this would be cause for immediate and widespread comment among the highly-educated, very politically-involved Iranian general public.
So even the whiff of a mere rumour of personal embezzlement would be a major risk to Khamenei’s job status! Part 2 will fully quote and explain the begrudging exoneration of Khamenei by one of his biggest adversaries – Western mainstream media – that there is “no evidence” that Khamenei has used Iran’s wealth to enrich himself. And, of course, there is no logical reason why he would thus tolerate theft and fraud among his fellow lower-ranking clergy who also work as civil servants.
Khomeini’s and Khamenei’s precedents of clearly living in a manner which rejects worldly riches will certainly help produce this same type of Leader in the future, but whoever is the Supreme Leader at any time in the Islamic Republic of Iran will likely be forced to live lives of transparent piety and to display moral, spiritual and fiscal rectitude – that, combined with self-sacrificing patriotism, is the very essence of the job. The Supreme Leader post is not that of a technocrat, as Western leaders are now often merely supposed to be – he is essentially called to act as the “soul of the nation”, and, I would also add, “of the government”.
Such values are anathema to Western secularism, which is a governmental philosophy that was certainly available in 1979 for Iranians to select. However, even atheistic secularists must concede that Western-style secularism was democratically rejected by Iranians, and this fact cannot be ignored, no matter how disagreeable non-Iranians may find this fact.
To put it plainly: Does the West really think that Iranians don’t have a good sense of Khamenei’s personal morality? He has been living in the public eye longer than French President Emmanuel Macron has been alive, and the French all know about Macron’s privileged upbringing, marriage to a chocolate heiress who was his high school teacher, and Rothschild banker-paid lifestyle. An entire nation simply cannot be kept in the dark about the true personal nature of its leaders; people are not stupid, anywhere, and and the Iranian press is far from being either non-existent or totally subservient to power.
You can take the average Iranian’s word for it: if Khamenei was living lavishly – or, living like every single Western CEO does, and with absolutely zero Western media condemnation, sadly) – all of Iran would know it, and there would be serious repercussions.
This all explains why Iranians view the recent US sanctions on Supreme Leader Ali Khamenei as absurd and based on both propaganda and ignorance. The sanctions put the The New York Times in a quandary – they had to choose between their iron-law Iranophobia and their equally unobjective anti-Trump editorial policy. Their jeering-but-accurate headline, “Iran Greets Latest U.S. Sanctions With Mockery”, reflects that the anti-Trumpers drowned out the Irano-/Islamophobes… on that day in their newsroom.
Beyond Khamenei, I can very briefly explain how and why the West can persist with their “Millionaire Mullah” mythology:
There are many economic principles that guide the Iranian economy which have no basis in the West – they are, after all, “revolutionary”. Many are based on principles of Islamic charity and of Islamic finance; many are also based on anti-capitalist principles which were obviously drawn from 20th century socialism. There are almost too many to list, but in Part 2 of this 3-part article I will pick a few key ones which specifically relate to clergy, and which – when added with Iranophobia – create such widespread and ignorant propaganda.
Part Two
Beyond Khamenei, I can very briefly explain how and why the West can persist with their “Millionaire Mullah” mythology:
There are many economic principles that guide the Iranian economy which have no basis in the West – they are, after all, “revolutionary”. Many are based on principles of Islamic charity and of Islamic finance; many are also based on anti-capitalist principles which were obviously drawn from 20th century socialism. There are almost too many to list, but in Part 2 of this 3-part article I will pick a few key ones which specifically relate to clergy, and which – when added with Iranophobia – create such widespread and ignorant propaganda.
One of the five pillars of Islam is to give to charity (zakat), but one of the five additional pillars of Shia theology is that businessmen must give 20% of their profits to charity (khums). Thus, it should be clear why some say that Iran has an “alms-based economy”. That’s an exaggeration, because there are state taxes as well, but this money goes directly to religious authorities and has gone there for over 1,000 years.
For example, Khamenei was raised in a family (lower middle class clerics on both sides of his parents) which would have never received this money directly – they would have been the recipients of this charity from much higher-ranking clergy.
Khamenei, through hard work, sacrifice and other virtues, is now a “Marja’” (top religious authority). He now heads various religious foundations which receive – and redistribute downwards – this zakat and khums money.
Of course, he heads these foundations, but this money cannot (and is not) be used by him to by a Ferrari for his favourite nephew, for example. The Iranian press would die of happiness at the sales prospects caused by such a sensational, unheard-of event! These are “religious foundations” not “The Clinton Foundation”: These foundations serve the poor – they do not trade high-level political access & favours in return for funding a jet-set lifestyle. Of course, most Western media cynically assume that everyone – even a Marja’, and even a Marja’ as publicly present as Khamenei – secretly operates on shameless Western capitalist principles….
Let’s clarify two key issues: zakat and khums are individual choices – they are not compelled to go to Khamenei. Iranians can send their charity to a Marja’ in Iraq if they like, and many do. Secondly, drastically changing this historic process of zakat and khums would certainly constitute a major revolution in Iran – however, for many it would constitute a rather “un-Islamic Revolution”, and there is no doubt that the democratic majority wanted an “Islamic Revolution”.
Therefore, Islamic charity is a reality of modern economics and finance in Iran. It is not something which non-Muslims can easily comprehend, perhaps, but the failure to do so will help fuel nonsense like “Millionaire Mullahs”. Unlike neoliberalism in the West, these financial principles have the virtue of being democratically-supported, and I can easily argue that they have the additional virtue of far more efficiently increasing economic equality than neoliberalism does.
Khamenei, as the Supreme Leader, is also often listed as the head of companies simply out of respect by the company’s founders. It is often purely honorary. Khamenei is not, for example, giving ideas on product improvement or production strategies to such companies (now the rare ex-president Rafsanjani – rare because he was an Iranian Islamic Revolutionary cleric from a rich, business-oriented background might have gotten involved, but Khamenei has evinced no such interest) and he is absolutely not in any control of the company’s assets. He is there in name only as a sign of respect for him, Islam, Iran, etc. Of course, this is distorted/misunderstood by Western pro-capitalist papers.
The Iranian Islamic Revolution also did something which no doubt enrages Western imperialist-capitalists, and about which they have no desire to spread honest information: the revolution took a huge chunk of the factories and industries owned by the shah and his tiny coterie and gave them to charity.
These are called the bonyads, and they are an estimated 15-20% of the entire Iranian economy. A staggeringly revolutionary concept, no?
The bonyads are thus different from the Islamic charity I have described, and the Islamic foundations which administer that charity, because the bonyads were expressly charged with getting involved in economic production.
The bonyads are not designed for capitalist profit, but are co-operatives which exist to create low-cost goods and jobs for Iranians. This planned” inefficiency” – in attaining maximum profit, but not in social cohesion and equality – is falsely branded as “corruption” by raging Western capitalists, sadly.
Khamenei heads some bonyads, and this gives him economic influence, of course… because the popular, democratic, openly-debated decision to award a significant chunk of the Iranian economy to the administration of religious authorities was a popular, democratic, openly-debated decision of the Iranian people. Oppose decisions arrived at in this manner, and you oppose democracy for Iran.
Bonyads are not specifically proscribed in The Koran, unlike zakat and the ubiquitous concepts of charity and anti-usury (high interest/compound interest), but if one tries to overturn them… well, all I can say is – prepare for a serious fight. If you think the millions of bonyad workers and recipients of bonyad lower-cost goods want all that to be replaced by (mostly-Western) stockholders… good luck with your efforts.
Very obvious, but of course not perfect, parallels can be made elsewhere: the lower class supporters of Chavismo’s collectivos have won an unprecedented number of votes (and street battles) to preserve similar anti-neoliberal economic concepts and structures. Iran is not nearly as susceptible to Washington’s meddling, in large part because such gains have been consolidating democratic support for the government for a generation longer than in Venezuela. Cuba adopted similar (though not Islamic-influenced) concepts a generation earlier than Iran did. China is a generation up on Cuba, and aren’t they doing rather well? China doesn’t have bonyads, of course, but Beijing and Tehran have such a strong and long-term alliance because they obviously have much in common… once translations are made.
So, between zakat, khums, the bonyads, generalized Iranophobia and a desire to denigrate any economic thought which is not far-right neoliberal capitalism… this is how we have arrived at Western nonsense like “Millionaire Mullahs”, and the propaganda is unrelenting.
Like, for example, the 2013 Reuters report on Setad, a bonyad headed by the Supreme Leader post, which was absurdly titled, “Khamenei controls massive financial empire built on property seizures”.
Part 3 will examine this report, which is still being cited today despite its obvious bias, misrepresentations and clear goal of spreading Iranophobic and Islamophobic propaganda.
Part Three
Part 1 of this article discussed why the recent US sanctions on Supreme Leader Ali Khamenei provoked laughter in Iran and derision even from Iranophobic Western mainstream media.
Part 2 proved that – between zakat, khums, the bonyads, generalized Iranophobia and a desire to denigrate any economic thought which is not far-right neoliberal capitalism – it is easily understandable how we have arrived at Western nonsense like “Millionaire Mullahs”.
Part 3 will show (NOTE: these three links go to the PressTV versions) how this propaganda is unrelenting.
Like the 2013 Reuters report on Setad, a bonyad headed by the Supreme Leader post, “Khamenei controls massive financial empire built on property seizures”.
Uhhh… yes, confiscating the ill-gotten property of the king and his 1% was undoubtedly the democratic choice of Iran. Iran is a rare country to have done that, but it was not the first. Economically right-wing Reuters, of course, opposes every such occasion where this has happened.
Reuters’ report spends just ten miserly words to describe for their readers both bonyads and khums, which is certainly not enough to give a sympathetic, much less objective, rendering of these rather vital parts of the Iranian economy. Reuters makes apparent its total disinterest in admitting Setad’s universally-known, multi-billion charitable functions with the brief and dismissive: “It’s unclear how much of its revenue goes to philanthropy.” It’s a report which openly airs the grievances of lawyers based in Beverly Hills, California, because talking about the economically-redistributive concepts at work in the Iranian economy are expressly against Reuters’ editorial policy.
As Reuters admitted, with a brief sentence that indicates their maximum disappointment: “Reuters found no evidence that Khamenei is tapping Setad to enrich himself.” Exactly. All Iran already knew that. Reuters’ buried a sentence which has been a headline in Iran.
Beyond the role of Islamic charity, the usury-banning role of Islamic finance, and the unique (revolutionary) economic principles installed after 1979, the widest-view statement I can give about the Iranian economy is this: because it is (Islamic) socialist-inspired when it comes to handling the economy, the Iranian state controls the Iranian economy even more completely than today’s “hosting tourists is ok” Cuba. Both nations control their economies in a patriotic way, though Iran has, thankfully, far more oil wealth; both nations reject foreign control (neoliberal/globalist capitalism); and both nations have been incredibly successful at improving the lives of their average citizen despite decades of murderous sanctions by the US and Europe.
The revolutionary Iranian economy is thus most succinctly described (this is “daily journalism”, after all) as “Iranian Islamic Socialism” because it is exactly that, and in exactly that order of importance: first come the patriotic needs of Iran, then adherence to the principles of Islam as much as possible, and then the clear rejection of capitalism-imperialism and neoliberalism/globalism. Importantly – at least to those who believe Iranians have a democratic right to choose their own path – Forbes, Reuters and Washington are resolutely dead-set against the success of all of these principles, and their actions and stances show that they view tolerance, accommodation and limited cooperation as impossible.
But this – the enormously anti-neoliberal aspects and the enormously successful redistributive aspects of the Iranian economy – is something the West can never admit because… they might be copied! Indeed, when Washington talks about Iran’s “destabilising behaviors”, there is nothing more destabilising to US and Israeli hegemony in the Muslim world than the very example of Iranian democratic success.
What works usually is copied, but Iranian economic solutions do not “work” for the aristocratic readers of Forbes. Therefore, “Millionaire mullahs” has been the Western editorial line, and they are sticking to it.
It should be clear: it is a well-known reality is that Khamenei does not personally have much to sanction at all; the Iranian economy is so unique (revolutionary) that it is easily distorted and rarely attempted to be understood; the guiding economic concepts democratically installed after the Iranian Islamic Revolution will always be the subject of massive Western propaganda efforts.
Therefore, pity Trump and his New York City slumlord/Pentagon gun-runner advisors – by foolishly sanctioning Khamenei all they did was insult him, and insult his tens of millions of often-ardent supporters, and show their total ignorance of how the Iranian economy actually works!
How did they get so misled? Simple: they read too much Western propaganda, which since 1979 has had an editorial line of “100% fake news, 24/7” when it comes to Iran. Such an editorial line is designed by their 1%-owners to push Trump, and others, to wrongly assume that Iran is some sort of dystopian, totalitarian regime where the top leader owns everything and can liquidate anything at any time for their personal profit.
Such a system only exists in comic books… and in the Arab monarchies. And are sanctions on these Arab despots arriving next? LOL, not likely. Forbes and the neoliberal-loving, English-Canadian Reuters are likely in the middle of preparing their latest puff-piece on yet another Arab monarch-dictator.
It is ironic that the only type of millionaires these rabidly capitalist media seem to have a problem with are of the Iranian clerical variety, a variety which Forbes was the first to ever claim even existed. But the phenomenon they allege does not exist, and Khamenei is often held up as a standard of good and moral leadership in many nations for very justified reasons.
What is certain is that Washington’s ignorance of and opposition to the nature of the Iranian economy will cost them dearly – sanctions on Khamenei will be totally ineffective in reaching their totally unjust aims. Such sanctions are amusing… but that is actually a sad commentary: the decades of murderous sanctions on Iran, Cuba, Korea and others shouldn’t be funny at all.
(Ramin Mazaheri is the chief correspondent in Paris for PressTV and has lived in France since 2009. He has been a daily newspaper reporter in the US, and has reported from Iran, Cuba, Egypt, Tunisia, South Korea and elsewhere. He is the author of “I’ll Ruin Everything You Are: Ending Western Propaganda on Red China”.)