Showing posts with label Christchurch shooting. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Christchurch shooting. Show all posts

Wednesday, April 03, 2019

Islamophobia’s Deadly Consequences

Zafar Bangash
Islamophobia is real and it has frighteningly deadly consequences for its victims. The Christchurch masjid attacks may have been a surprise only because New Zealand is a relatively peaceful country. Anti-Muslim hatred resulting in terrorist attacks are all too real, and frequent. Most people were also surprised that a multicultural society like Canada witnessed a murderous attack on Muslims in their place of worship two years ago (Quebec City Masjid attack that resulted in six deaths).
For those following the rising tide of Islamophobia and anti-Muslim rhetoric in the West closely, it was only a matter of time before some white terrorist individual or group struck. Politicians, security agencies, and the police were all chasing “Muslim terrorist” phantoms duly amplified by the right-wing media. True, there are Muslim extremists but they pale in significance with the right-wing white extremist groups. In any case, most Muslim extremists were already known to the intelligence and security agencies. In most instances, their murderous plots were instigated by intelligence agencies to impress their bosses and keep their hefty budgets flowing.
In almost every terrorist act blamed on Muslims — whether in the US, Canada, or Europe — the intelligence agencies have been deeply involved. Even the most spectacular attacks of 9/11 are considered by most experts to be an inside job. Canada’s Toronto-18 case of June 2006 was similarly instigated. It was RCMP agents that received obscene amounts of money to trap gullible Muslim youth into their diabolical plot. John Nuttall and Amanda Korody were fortunate to have their case thrown out by a BC judge in 2016 when she accepted that RCMP officers pushed the couple into the bomb plot. The British Columbia Supreme Court similarly dismissed the crown’s appeal against stay of charges of the earlier court verdict and upheld that the couple was manipulated into the plot.
Quite aside from these disturbing acts by intelligence and security agencies against Muslims, the threat of white supremacist groups in Western countries is real and growing. Even the intelligence agencies admit this threat but politicians do not want to take any action against such extremist groups. Is it because they target Muslims, people projected as the bad guys and, therefore, deserving of the punishment inflicted on them?
If politicians in Western countries are serious about addressing this growing threat — and it is bound to affect others as well, not just Muslims — then a number of steps are necessary. First, Islamophobia must be declared a hate crime. In several countries, anti-Semitism is already a hate crime under law. Second, the white supremacist groups and their enablers must be identified and banned. If groups like al-Qaeda, ISIS, etc. are banned as terrorist organizations — quite rightly — then white supremacist groups like Soldiers of Odin, Canada First and other such groups including the Jewish Defence League (JDL) must also face the full force of the law. In the US, the JDL has been banned since 2002 as a terrorist group; why is Canada so far behind in confronting this bunch of terrorists?
Third, political leaders must stop pandering to racist groups in the name of “freedom of speech.” Hatred against an identifiable, law-abiding group — the Muslims — that results in such horrific crimes cannot be accepted as “free speech.” Words do carry weight and lead people to violent acts. The murderous attacks in Quebec City and Christchurch provide ample proof, if proof indeed were needed, of the impact of hate speech against defenceless people.
Finally, we must come to the real point: the West’s endless wars on Muslim countries. Launched under the rubric of the war on terror, it is actually a war on Islam and Muslims. Since 9/11, the number of Muslim countries attacked is very long. Dirt-poor Afghanistan has been virtually destroyed. It had already been wracked by decades of warfare.
America’s attack in October 2001 made the situation much worse. While there is a glimmer of hope that Washington’s destructive war in Afghanistan may soon end, there are other areas that are still in the throes of externally instigated violence and bloodshed. These include Iraq, Syria, Yemen, and Somalia. Venezuela has also now been added to the list. The Palestinian and Kashmiri people have suffered decades of oppression at the hands of alien invaders. Islamic Iran is also constantly demonized.
With the exception of Venezuela, all other countries are predominantly Muslim, hence their demonization and dehumanization. This leads to riling up racists and bigots in Western societies that go on rampages killing innocent Muslims in their places of worship.
The West’s history of violence against others is long and gory. The Crusades were launched from Europe but the Inquisitions were carried out in Europe. The slave trade and genocide of Native peoples in North America, Australia, and New Zealand followed. Then came the internment of Japanese and Italians during the Second World War. Jews and Catholics were also targeted. Why should this pattern of oppression and humiliation continue?
Isn’t it time to end this shameful conduct, this time targeting Muslims?
Zafar Bangash is Director of the Institute of Contemporary Islamic Thought (ICIT).

Terrorism, Mass Murders, and Islamophobia

Right-wing crazies following a script written in Israel

Zafar Bangash
The horrific murder of 50 Muslim worshippers in two Christchurch masjids on March 15 has evoked global condemnation except for some hardcore Islamophobes and racists. Those slaughtered in cold blood included women and children. Some of the wounded are in critical condition.
The mass murderer, a 28-year-old white supremacist terrorist from Australia, Brenton Tarrant, was arrested shortly after his deadly rampage. He appeared in court on March 16 and is scheduled to reappear on April 5.
Beyond the condemnations and the sympathetic manner in which New Zealand Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern has handled the situation, there are deeply troubling aspects to the alarming rise in Islamophobia. There are a number of factors and individuals that inspired the terrorist’s demonic ideology. These include US President Donald Trump, the Norwegian terrorist Anders Breivik, the Quebec City terrorist Alexandre Bissonnette, and Serbian mass murderer Radovan Karadic. This emerged both from the names he had written on the semi-automatic weapons he used to murder innocent worshippers as well as the 74-page manifesto he uploaded to the internet.
There is little doubt that he was consumed by intense hatred of Muslims. He not only set out to “cleanse” New Zealand and his native Australia of immigrants and refugees but also to avenge the defeat of Christians at the hands of Muslims (the Turks’ historic battles in Europe) as well as glorify Christian victories over them. In his demonic rage he slaughtered 50 innocent Muslims.
Let us get some facts straight. Muslims constitute less than 1% of New Zealand’s population. But for a man consumed by hatred, even one Muslim is one too many. This racist and bigot conveniently ignored the fact that immigrants, primarily from Britain, populate both New Zealand and Australia. Such details, however, are inconsequential for him and his fellow racist Fraser Anning because the early immigrant settlers are white and their victims are non-white.
There are many dimensions to this latest tragedy. Unfortunately, it won’t be the last. The wars that the Western imperialist regimes are waging against Muslim countries necessitate painting Muslims — all 1.8 billion of them — as evil and violent extremists that must be eliminated. This campaign of vilification, however, came up against the fact that millions of Muslims live quite peacefully in Western societies. The image of Muslims as violent extremists did not fit this description. Thus, they had to be demonized as well. The Zionists were happy to oblige; indeed they are the principal instigators together with evangelical Christians in stoking anti-Muslim hatred.
The corporate-owned media has eagerly amplified anti-Muslim venom spouted by right-wing politicians. Again, the Zionists have been in the forefront of this campaign of demonization. The West’s wars of aggression have resulted in turning millions of people into refugees who are forced to seek shelter elsewhere.
In a gesture of commiseration, fealty, and solidarity with the be-reaved Muslim community of New Zealand, Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern — a Mormon by birth and an agnostic by choice since 2005 — dons the Hijab as she attends funeral services for those who were killed in the massacre. In addition to vowing to change the country’s gun laws and to never publicly mention the name of the right-wing murderer-terrorist as a way of impersonalizing him altogether, she also instructed her government to cover all the funeral expenses for the deceased, to provide welfare and other services to those families dependent on wage earners who lost their lives, to cover repatriation expenses for those who wanted to return to their countries of origin, to cover the travel expenses of those foreign relatives who wanted to participate in the funeral processions of their own, and to provide counseling and hotlines for as long as necessary for all those affected by the tragedy, Muslim and non-Muslim alike.
Fascist politicians, right-wing media outlets and the Zionists have all played on the insecurities of people in Western countries to whip up hysteria against Muslims. “Brown Muslims are coming to swamp your land and take your fair ladies turning them into sex slaves” seems to be the constant message.
“They want to impose Shari‘ah law here” is another frequently heard refrain. This is a misnomer; there is no such thing as “Shari‘ah law.” Most politicians and media outlets have no clue what Shari‘ah stands for but it is enough to frighten the ignorant masses and whip up hysteria.
It is, however, Tarrant’s mentors — and also his financiers — who need a closer scrutiny. In his so-called manifesto, Tarrant expresses great admiration for Trump, Bissonnette, and Breivik. The Norwegian terrorist in turn has admitted to being inspired by the arch-Zionist Robert Spencer, a self-proclaimed “expert” on Islam who has not studied the Arabic language, much less the Qur’an, to get a clear grasp of the Muslim holy book. According to the Daily Beast, Zionist operative David Horowitz pays Spencer $167,000 a year for his Islam-bashing services. This is no small beer!
The Southern Poverty Law Center has said Horowitz’s organization specializes in “giving anti-Muslim voices and radical ideologies a platform to project hate and misinformation.”
The Zionist connection runs deeper. Tarrant visited Israel in 2016 and spent some time there. Further, Zionists are the principal promoters and instigators of Islamophobia.
While there is a general perception that Islamophobia intensified in the aftermath of 9/11, this is only partly true. Long before the 9/11 false-flag operation that most informed observers believe were an inside job, Zionists were busy peddling Islamophobia.
Tommy Robinson (real name Stephen Yaxley-Lennon), right, founder of the English Defence League (EDL), which is financially underwritten by billionaire Zionists from the US and elsewhere, was sentenced to 13 months in jail for contempt of court on 5-25-2018. According to the EDL and a nexus of right-wing fascist websites, such as Britain First (whose videos were forwarded by US President Trump), Britain is portrayed as a police state that is overrun with Muslims. Even though he and his acolytes routinely characterize Muslims as lawbreakers, Robinson himself was jailed in 2005 for assault, and was sentenced to 10 months in jail after he used a friend’s passport to fly to New York and fled from secondary inspection at JFK airport.
The first foreign visitor to the US after Bill Clinton became president in late-1992 was Israeli Prime Minister Yitzhak Rabin. The Zionist regime was then facing the first Palestinian intifadah (Rabin had vowed to break the bones of Palestinians!). Since the intifadah drew inspiration from Islamic values, Rabin urged Clinton during his visit in March 1993 to confront what he termed “Islamic terrorism.” The low intensity war on Islam went into high gear.
Clinton needed little prodding. The US had already suffered defeat with the victory of the Islamic Revolution in Iran in 1978–1979. Hizbullah delivered further blows to both US imperialism and Zionism in Lebanon. Led by the Islamic movements Hamas and Islamic Jihad, the intifadah eclipsed the secular Palestine Liberation Organization (PLO) and its corrupt leaders.
Given this context, we can begin to see why the most virulently anti-Muslim voices are those of pro-Israeli Zionist individuals and groups. They have made common cause with white supremacists against Muslims.
In an investigative report in the Guardian (December 7, 2018), the London daily found “The British far-right activist Tommy Robinson is receiving financial, political, and moral support from a broad array of non-British groups and individuals, including US think tanks, right-wing Australians and Russian trolls…” Describing Robinson as “an anti-Islam campaigner” the Guardian names individuals and organizations that fund his anti-Islam activities: Daniel Pipes and his Middle East Forum (MEF) have contributed $60,000 to Robinson, the American “billionaire Robert Shillman financed a fellowship that helped pay for Robinson to be employed in 2017 by a right-wing Canadian media website, Rebel Media, on a salary of about £5,000 [approx. $7,500] a month.” Ezra Levant of Rebel Media lost a lawsuit last year when he was forced to pay $80,000 to Khurram Awan, a law student whom he falsely accused of being an anti-Semite.
A racist anti-Muslim group in Australia, the Australian Liberty Alliance, also admitted to funding Robinson, but refused to disclose the amount when asked by Guardian reporters. Is it far-fetched to surmise that the same Australian group has also funded Tarrant and that he has received funding from well-healed Zionists in the US as well?
Consider the coverage of similar rampage events — one blamed on a Muslim, right, and the other on a right-wing terrorist — in a British tabloid with the fifth largest circulation in the country, which is a reflection of the way the mainstream media shapes public perceptions and then manufactures consent for the imperial ambitions of its crusading politicians. Note that the New Zealand terrorist is not even presented as one, rather he is just called a “mass killer” who started off life as an angelic boy who happened to take an aberrational wrong turn in life. By contrast, Omar Mateen, the alleged Florida nightclub shooter, is basically staged as narcissistic evil incarnate from birth, and his shooting of innocents harkens back to the mother of all terrorist attacks, the 9/11 false flag. Insofar as the Aussie terrorist is concerned, the media here does not offer up any precedent; to get that, one would have to dig into the story on the inside so as to become acquainted with the murderer’s manifesto and those who inspired him.
Robinson’s other backers include the New York City-based think tank, the Gatestone Institute that has published a series of articles supporting Robinson’s anti-Islamic crusade. The David Horowitz Freedom Center (DHFC), a California-based think tank that describes itself as a “school for political warfare” — yes the same Horowitz who is financing Spencer — is also active in Robinson’s defence.
It gets murkier. MEF, Gatestone, and the DHFC are well funded by influential Zionist donors. In the two-year period (2014–2016), the Guardian found that their returns showed they received a total of almost $5 million from several millionaire donors.
“MEF received $792,000 from a foundation led by Nina Rosenwald, the co-chair of American Securities Management, once dubbed “the sugar mama of anti-Muslim hate.” Rosenwald is a self-described “ardent Zionist” who funds Israeli institutions on a regular basis.
“The DHFC received $1,638,290 from five wealthy benefactors, one of whom is believed to be among the biggest-ever donors to the Republican Party.
“Gatestone has received more than $2m in donations, including $250,000 from the Mercer Family Foundation, which is funded by Donald Trump’s top donor, Robert Mercer, and run by the billionaire’s daughter Rebekah.
“All three think tanks have been repeatedly accused of stoking anti-Islam sentiment in the West and spreading false information about Muslim refugees in Europe…” according to the Guardian investigation.
The Guardian’s piece of last December so alarmed the Times of Israel — yes an Israeli newspaper — that it wrote its own piece on January 24, 2019 authored by Eric Cortellessa decrying, “Why are US ‘pro-Israel’ groups boosting a far-right, anti-Muslim UK extremist?” While Pipes, Horowitz, and others of their ilk peddle their anti-Muslim rhetoric under the rubric of “free speech,” for the Times of Israel, “the support Robinson has received from a web of Israel-backing groups may be about more than just protecting ‘free speech.’ As at least Pipes and Horowitz have made clear, it’s also about advancing his ideas.”
Robinson has more than one million Facebook followers, most of them in Australia, the US, Canada, Sweden, and Norway. It does not take rocket science to figure out that Tarrant is one of them. And he has acted out what Robinson has been peddling: anti-Muslim bigotry and violence.
The role of right-wing media in stoking Islamophobia cannot be ignored either. For instance, the Daily Mirror, a British tabloid carried this headline after Tarrant’s murderous attack on two masjids, “Angelic boy who grew up into an evil far-right mass killer.” A childhood photograph of Tarrant in the arms of his father appeared alongside the headline. Contrast this with the way the same Mirror newspaper reported the Orlando nightclub shooting by one Omar Mateen in June 2016, “ISIS maniac kills 50 in gay bar.” There are reports that Mateen was also gay and had a fight with one of the patrons leading to the shooting and not for political reasons.
Let us also identify some politicians that are actively promoting anti-Muslim hatred. In Canada these include Maxime Bernier of the newly-formed right-wing Peoples Party, Andrew Scheer of the Conservative Party of Canada, and Quebec Premier Francois Legault.
It is not surprising that there have been numerous attacks on masjids in Canada, most notably in Quebec where six worshippers were murdered and 29 injured when Alexandre Bissonnette attacked the Quebec City Masjid on January 29, 2017.
Other cities have not escaped either. For instance, the small town of Peterborough in Ontario was subjected to arson attack in December 2015 while a couple of months ago, members of the racist outfit, Soldiers of Odin, appeared at an Edmonton masjid taking photographs and intimidating Muslims. The provinces of Quebec, Manitoba, and Alberta seem to have the largest number of right-wing fascist groups.
Britain is also a hotbed of anti-Muslim terror with several groups operating freely. On March 18, Britain’s Security Secretary Ben Wallace admitted in parliament that Christchurch type attacks are possible, indeed likely in Britain. Four days later (in the early morning of March 22), five masjids in Birmingham had their windows smashed. Other attacks are likely to follow as racist groups have started intimidating Muslims near their places of work and worship.
It is little better elsewhere in Europe. France seems to be leading the way in anti-Muslim bigotry but it is not the only one. Germany, Sweden, Norway, Hungary, and a host of others are embracing racist ideologues.
In the aftermath of the Christchurch masjid attacks, there have been expressions of sympathy offered by many politicians. What is needed is to take action on two fronts: first, ban the right-wing fascist groups that actively promote hatred, especially against Muslims. Second, declare Islamophobia a hate crime and confront those indulging in it with the full force of the law.
Failing these two steps, all expressions of sympathy and support are meaningless. Muslims will face other murderous attacks with each group and institution hoping that it won’t be them. These are dangerous times for Muslims.

Monday, March 25, 2019

Christchurch Mosque Massacre: Feigning Indifference About Israel's Role as Architect of Islamophobia is Unforgivable

Iqbal Jassat
 
Violent brutality often seen on cinema screens as well as TV and online broadcasts - a hallmark of Hollywood, always ends with a sigh of relief in the knowledge that fiction triumphed over reality. "Dead" actors wake up and walk, ready to "die" and walk again in sequel after sequel of blockbuster movies, enthralling millions of eager viewers demanding more of the same.
Whether films depict wars or drama and yes, entertainment too, blood curling violence, murder, rape and hatecrimes appear to be intimately entrenched in the script. Though reviewers and critics do often question validity of gratuitous violence, it seems script writers and producers are of the opinion that blood sells. And that the more bloodshed the more popular films will be to rake in huge profits.
Unfortunately for the victims and families of the #ChristchurchMosqueMassacres in New Zealand, the reality of being mowed down in cold blood was far removed from fiction. Though the killer resorted to filming his ghastly crime via realtime digital media as he calmly proceeded to pump bullets into the bodies of Muslim women, men and children, they will not walk again.
The orgy of death in the sacred precincts of mosques has shocked the world. That it was captured on video and has gone viral, depicting the utter ruthlessness of the killer splattering blood of innocent worshippers, has sparked fury.
Pressure on social media platforms to halt further broadcasts showing depravity of the perpetrator's killing spree may be an idea to not reward him with his "scoop", but the larger question remains unanswered: who are his scriptwriters?
There is no doubt that Ali Abunimah's tweet correctly singles out Israeli war criminal Benjamin Netanyahu as a leading architect of anti-Muslim hate campaigns as well as an ally of white supremacists and Nazis.
His active pursuit of Islamophobia, incitement of wars and execution of Palestinians are not chance occurrences. Netanyahu, as head of the Middle East's sole colonial entity, has been in the forefront of global war efforts to target what he unashamedly defines as "Muslim extremism" and "Islamist terrorism".
A vocabulary of racist invectives which he popularized and as is evident has been absorbed by US president Donald Trump along with his circle of rightwing white supremacist thugs such as John Bolton and Mike Pompeo.
To assume that the Christchurch massacre is an isolated case is to deny the existence of scriptwriters in Tel Aviv, Washington, London, Paris and many more capitals of the world. The results of the cancer of hate spread by them against Muslims is found in the debris of war ravaged Iraq, Afghanistan, Libya, Yemen, Somalia, Kashmir and scores of unidentified rural villages dotting the Muslim world.
The names of these scriptwriters are known to the world, but regrettably not for the enormity of their illegal wars and crimes associated thereby, but as "statesmen". Tony Blair, George Bush, Bill and Hillary Clinton, Barack Obama and the group of killers in Israel, are glorified as "leaders" on the world stage, while their records of mass murders are either glossed over or justified as necessary under the false rubric of the "War on Terror".
Miko Peled correctly links racist killings to the impunity whereby Israel and the US kill Arabs and Muslims. And insists that unless Israel's "dominant influence" is halted, expect more #ChristchurchMosqueMassacres.
Displaying outrage and issuing statements of condemnation as Netanyahu, Trump and their fellow travelers have done, smacks of blatant hypocrisy and double standards. Their insincerity stinks and must be called out if the world is to rid itself of white supremacy.
Even while the International Criminal Court dithers by displaying impotence in regards to the prosecution of Netanyahu and his British/American counterparts, it behoves civil society, multinational corporations as well as independent governments to turn their collective backs on them.
Glorifying baby killers is not an option. And those who do so as has been the want of conglomerates to invite the likes of Blair and Obama, is equivalent of extending a lifeline to white supremacists.
A social comment I read says that Islamophobia has been normalised and legitimised to such an extent that it's commonplace for certain commentators to argue that it's entirely natural and rational to dislike and be fearful of Muslims.
Though Trump may be despised by the world and many folks in America, he remains entrenched as the Commander-In-Chief with his unsteady finger on the nuclear button. His malignant views of Islam and Muslims did not emerge out of the blue. Chaps like Steve Bannon who cherish and fuel hate and are acknowledged as rightwing bigots, exploited the fertile Islamophobic ground laid by Trump's predecessors and an array of Israeli allied think tanks to gain access to power.
The intrinsic network of rightwingers including heads of governments and white commentariat as described by Lebanese academic Amal Saad, pose the most damning threat to global peace and security. Yet Israel's recent threat analysis would want the world to believe that the Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions campaigners (BDS), are terrorists in suits, worthy of being jailed, tortured and killed.
The smear campaign against BDS is a replica of hate campaigns against resistance movements, Iran, Venezuela and of course Muslims.
To be shocked, outraged and saddened by the gory murders in New Zealand is understandable. But to feign indifference about the role of the US/British/Israeli axis of white supremacy is unforgivable.
Iqbal Jassat is Executive Member of the Media Review Network, Johannesburg, South Africa